[REVIEW] Open Setup Reviews

James Brafin · Post Post #761 (isolation #0) » Mon Jun 03, 2019 4:34 am

Have a setup. Nothing fancy, but has a neat twist: scum gets to steal PRs from the day 1 lynch and NK, but there are a number of semi-negative PRs available, as well as semi-positive scum-PRs, and the same is true of town.

Scum
Town Rolestealer x2
Mafia Goon

Town
Doctor
Tracker
Vengeful Townie
1-shot Governor
Hated Townie
Follower
Odd-night Commuter
Roleblocker
Borrower (Absorber, but only gets 1 shot for each absorption)
1-shot neighborizer

James Brafin · Post Post #763 (isolation #1) » Mon Jun 03, 2019 6:19 am

Why? Not seeing why that’s a town necessity.

James Brafin · Post Post #766 (isolation #2) » Mon Jun 03, 2019 8:07 am

Ok. Options 1 or 3 would prob be best

James Brafin · Post Post #768 (isolation #3) » Tue Jun 04, 2019 4:55 am

I am hesitant to add too many VTs, because even one or two weakens scum considerably, because most of scum’s power relay on good PR hunting. But if I did Mafia Janitor, some might be ok.

I do have a new list with extra roles, so I could do semi-open.

Scum
Town Rolestealer x2
Mafia Janitor

Town (Random)
Doctor
Tracker
Vengeful Townie
1-shot Governor
Hated Townie
Follower
Odd-night Commuter
Roleblocker
Borrower (Absorber, but only gets 1 shot for each absorption)
1-shot neighborizer
1-shot Vig
Macho Babysitter
1-shot Strengthener
1-shot Deflector
Compulsive Weak Roleblocker

You could even make it a 9-person and just do two Mafia Janitor Town Rolestealers, just to for sure hide what’s been killed.

I kinda like having it semi-open mini Role Madness. You just have to make sure there is a decent mix of negative and positive scum utility roles.