Open 337: Twin Trap (Game Over)

[HermanoBro]

Hey, will read and post by tomorrow

[HermanoBro]

Finished reading. This is challenging as a replacement, idk about you guys.

I agree that Isa's disinterest in Neil seems suspicious, but saying 'I thought he was scum so why didn't you mislynch him too?' isn't looking great either.

It's easy for me to say he didn't look that suspicious because I knew he was town, but I do think you guys put a lot of stock in his tone and response considering he claimed to be both frustrated and disinterested.

[HermanoBro]

I am interested in hearing what parts of the Neil case you found valid.

I don't remember any off the top of my head that I found "valid". But I partly understood why people ended up voting him if only because he seemed a bit abrasive/condescending at times.

It's more that I can't relate to your willingness to say he likely wasn't scum; what about his play made you think that?

[HermanoBro]

Will read back some and post within the next 24 hours

[HermanoBro]

@thomas I really didn't have any good reads when I finished rereading before. I suspected all 4 of you equally, possibly because I don't really develop town reads very well, and also cuz I was really paranoid about anyone left alive. Now I have a better grasp.

looking back, I am pretty unhappy with Fakinha's day 2 as well. I mainly noticed this in Collyer's case when I reread. I don't think it's a coincidence he was killed last night as well. I also agree with Isa that town probably wouldn't unvote in this lylo situation. And the way he rode the neil wagon went noticeably from trying to start conversation to just waiting for the lynch to happen.

I know we have time before deadline, but no one is doing much suspicious(or at all) today(even Fakinha). I don't see a major scum slip-up happening anytime soon.

vote:Fakinha

[HermanoBro]

well sorry town. I was pretty stumped by this one.

Isa, I really agree that you basically already had the game won. I really didn't suspect the buddying thing with neil because it seemed so ham-handed in retrospect/iso. Doesn't it seem like an obvious mistake to pretend to have a town read like that? Like I said, I never get good town reads, and if I do I don't mention them, but it seems like something a lot of foolish townies actually do. Like you said, no one ever thought it was a protown thing, did you just do it to follow through with your "opposite stance" policy with thomas?

I honestly just didn't see a case on either of you. You were playing much more reasonably than the remaining town, imo.

[HermanoBro]

oh yeah, I was watcher, forgot to mention.

mod told me:
Night 1 he watched Neil, and saw Collyer target Neil.
Night 2 he watched Collyer and received No Result.