Open 343: True Love - Game Over!

[Robotnick2]

Same <3 all.

On a more serious note, as the Mafia are also lover-partners, does that mean if we lynch one, we win the game?

[Robotnick2]

Same <3 all.

On a more serious note, as the Mafia are also lover-partners, does that mean if we lynch one, we win the game?

Page one gambit?

Just asking for rule clarification.

@Pink, anything that isn't noise, basically. And yourself?

[Robotnick2]

Why would you point that out nintendo? Sigh, it was a nice try.

So what music do you guys like?

Could have been scum trying to look like town not reading the setup correctly. Or maybe it was genuine town. So I guess it's null.

Electro, 80's, alternative, and The Beatles. Yes, they get their own genre.

Hmm. Well, I'm sorry for asking a question. If that's scummy, then god help me.

[Robotnick2]

VOTE: Maxous

OMGUS!

[Robotnick2]

Why would you point that out nintendo? Sigh, it was a nice try.

So what music do you guys like?

Could have been scum trying to look like town not reading the setup correctly. Or maybe it was genuine town. So I guess it's null.

Electro, 80's, alternative, and The Beatles. Yes, they get their own genre.

Hmm. Well, I'm sorry for asking a question. If that's scummy, then god help me.

Not necessarily, but that sounded overly defensive. And that

is

scummy.
UNVOTE: VOTE: Robotnick2

I really had forgotten how damned aggressive forum mafia was.

[Robotnick2]

Same for mine.

UNVOTE: Maxous

[Robotnick2]

How many times do I have to clarify this?

I didn't understand the rules. I asked about the rules. I was corrected. That's what it boils down to.

Does anyone seriously have a problem with asking about the rules?

[Robotnick2]

Oh, and @Pink, this is my fourth here, and about my 500th if you count EpicMafia (which I know most of you don't.)

[Robotnick2]

I know, it wasn't aimed at you

Oh, and Isa, could you pretty please link the games that uncledaphne trolled, if that's possible? Ta.

[Robotnick2]

Well that was quick. I apologise for my lack of posting, my internet connection was dead for most of today and yesterday, and at the brief moments when I DID have internet access my time was taken up elsewhere.

Now then.

I completely agree with Andre's last post, so I'm not going to restate what he just said. I also have no concrete reads at the moment. I'm not suprised however that Isa and Nintendo both flipped town; I read them as such. Aside from that, the only real read I have is a slight scum read on Chaotic. Not sure why, but I would definitely be in favour of an uncledaphne lynch.

[Robotnick2]

EBWOP: That should read "on Chaotic, not sure why, but I"

[Robotnick2]

Aside from that, the only real read I have is a slight scum read on Chaotic.

I just suggested we lynch my lover, scum have nothing to gain from suicide like that. But my avatar looks scummy, if that makes you feel any better.

Nice bit of WIFOM you got there.

Okay guys, this is how it breaks down. We're at LyLo, basically, and if you want to be technical

scum already outnumber town

. Let me explain this;

We have 3 lover pairs left, two of which contain scum. If we lynch one person from a pair, we lynch the other, thus we can treat this as having 3 players; 2 scum and one town; thus a 66% chance of lynching scum today. No lynching is useless, as there are no nights. If we lynch the town pair today, we lose. If we lynch the scum, we end up with a 50/50 LyLo tomorrow, where one of us will have to commit "suicide", as it were, in order to lynch the last remaining scum. So obviously, we have to lynch scum today.
However, would prolonging the day as long as possible in order to gain more solid leads be a good idea?

[Robotnick2]

However, would prolonging the day as long as possible in order to gain more solid leads be a good idea?

We have 13 days until the deadline. It really is your choice.

Ah, true. I'd forgotten that we have a deadline; in the other game I'm playing, we don't.

I will just say here that I

FoS: uncledaphne

for his scummy play throughout. I however am aware that Isa had him down as a troll, hence my reluctance to vote. Also, he and Chaotic cannot be scum together, so if he is scum Chaotic is town, which means one of my reads is wrong; I'm leaning towards my Chaotic read being wrong. If he and Chaotic are the town-pair (which I feel is unlikely), then the two scum can quickhammer and win.
Going to trawl his meta, see whether he acts like this in all of his games.

[Robotnick2]

Because I think Chaotic Neutrality and uncledaphne are the last T/T pair.

I guess its possible that Maxous is scum over you but I think you acted scummier andre. Either way your team dies.

Oh and if everyone thinks I'm being scummy please vote me because I honestly find robo scummy but I'd prefer to stay alive another day.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: pinkfloyd

To be honest sweetie, I've had my eye on you for a while. You never put the cap back on the toothpaste, you always leave the toilet seat up, you flatly refuse to cook or clean... and then there's those "late meetings"...
You're cheating on me. And I have proof!

The language he gives off makes me feel like he is noob town.

Nice attempt at discrediting everything that I say.

Oh and if Chaotic Neutrality and uncledaphne are lovers I want them lynched next.

You never actually gave reasoning for this. And THEN you claim that you think they're the last T/T pair? Explain this please.

>Robo never says anything about me or questions why I didn't post in ages

The same could be said of nearly everyone. And by the way, why didn't you post in ages?

These are the only examples as you don't have that much content, which is scummy in itself. At least I've tried to write at least a paragraph whenever I have something to add to the game.

[Robotnick2]

*pretend this is a vote on Pink Floyd*

He claims that Robo gives him a noob town feel earlier when people were gonna lynch Robo on Day 1, and then states that Robo has hardly said anything so how can he discredit Robo's words.
He pulled that 'noob town' read on robo straight out of thin air to attempt to save Robo from a lynch.

Because I wanted robo to trust me more and open up, as well as hope he would respond to noob claims in a townie matter. He didn't.

Firstly, you wanted me to trust you more? Why?
Secondly, I get called a noob a lot. Not sure why. It tends to just go over my head, except when people make a big deal out of it, at which point I regard it as a scumtell and react to it in the same way that I would any other scumtells.

[Robotnick2]

And yet you lied about your own reads.
In this game, pinkfloyd, one must trust no-one. Until it can be unequivocally proven that a given person is town, which in this setup is impossible, then one cannot and should not trust them. Therefore, seeing as giving reads is standard practice, it stands to reason that one does not have to trust someone to tell them their reads. Thus, your expectation of me to "open up my reads" if I were to trust you is a logical fallacy. Furthermore, it also stands to reason that your

expectation

of me to trust you is a scumtell, because I have absolutely no reason to, unless I were to

know

whether you were town or scum. The only people in this game who know town from scum are the scum themselves. Thus, your arguement is invalid; if I were scum, I would not need to trust you, and if I were town, I could not trust you. Furthermore, I would posit that you are scum, using scum reasoning as to why I should trust you.

Fixed tag
~mod

[Robotnick2]

Again, this is getting nowhere. As uncledaphne is my other scum candidate;
UNVOTE:
VOTE: Uncledaphne

That puts him at L-1 folks! Anyone wanna hammer and prove me wrong?

[Robotnick2]

Maxous, when was the last time you spoke to Andre in your Lover's QT?

[Robotnick2]

Bump. I think Maxous and I should talk some in our private chat, since we haven't done that all game.

Then this was referencing the Andre/Maxous lover QT. Thought so the moment it was posted, just needed proof.

Pinkfloyd, what in that sentence makes you think he was referencing the scumchat?

[Robotnick2]

...what you just said makes no sense.

I ask this quite sincerely pinkfloyd; Is English your first language?
FTR, "our" is a plural possessive pronoun. "The book belongs to us; it is

our

book." "The private chat is between us; it is

our

private chat."
Nothing about what he said was scummy, and indeed Maxous backs that up.

AND ANYWAY, how could Maxous and Andre be scum together? There are only 2 mafia in this game, and one of them is dead. Also, Maxous and Andre cannot be scum together anyway... they're lovers.

For that reason (the tremendous scumslip on your part,)
VOTE: Pinkfloyd

[Robotnick2]

Bump. I think Maxous and I should talk some in our private chat, since we haven't done that all game.

This....wording...implies....another.....quicktopic

VOTE: Andre that was a definite slip.

You say that his wording implies another QT, and vote him for being scum. Implying that you believe that the QT he was supposedly referencing is the scum QT.

Pinkfloyd, what in that sentence makes you think he was referencing the scumchat?

This part

I think Maxous and I should talk some in our private chat

In OUR private chat as if to say he has been writing in another private chat. Why not just say "Lets talk kin private chat Maxous", because we all clearly know each others partners.

And here you explicitly state that you believe that Andre and Maxous are talking in the scumchat.

[Robotnick2]

Good win Andre, didn't suspect you for a second

GG all.