@Slandaar, ok let me answer a few things for you.
Slandaar wrote:Or hes... scum? everyone else can see its null why not him?
yeh he could be, but i've read MOI as town..
Slandaar wrote:
Malees posts were just overdone for basically saying 15nulls a couple town and a couple slight scum reads.
Slandaar wrote:sword_of_omens wrote:
Same place, Kurtis then jumps on and parrots your reasoning for Malee (#149)
How is this indicative of my alignment?
It is when Fennin does the exact same thing, but you call him out as scummy for it. Selective reasoning on your part?
slandaar wrote:
Fennin agrees with the reasoning but was voting me. He was the one contradicting.
so people are allowed only one scumread? He's voting for you and agreeing with your logic on Malee..
Scum do bus, y'know...
Slandaar wrote:I think that slot is scum. What is your point? just a little fact; she replaced out here before some other games she was in.
again, mainly weak pot-shots...replacing out does not make her scum...look at the frickin' list..almost EVERYONE has replaced out...doesn't make em all scum..
Slandaar wrote:No thats part of a whole its not a 1 line they are scum due to this alone. Why are you suggesting as such? Note more likely, note how you are ridiculously stating they ARE which is clearly not what I said anyway.
from post# 136
Slandaar wrote:
So now we are getting somewhere, Scum are more likely to take her side because it is in principle the 'right' side. They are not going to go out on a limb on my side.
So who was on side Malee
SD/Fennin/Magna... maybe someone im forgetting
i re-read your whole post....I will concede this point to you somewhat, however, I still disagree with your reasoning behind it. You are saying that scum would ONLY side with Malee and not you. Your original attack on Malee was weak to begin with and you agree that "Malee's side" is the "right side". You're admitting that your attack on her for this is weak/wrong. Yet you are using this as one of your main points that Malee is scum.
Slandaar wrote:You know I wrote a case on SD, you quoted a line from it in this post.
wow, I did not reallize that that was your whole case on SD. He thought you were lying about knowing the thread opened but he didn't vote you. Oh, And that he took Malee's side.
I honestly don't read SD as scum like you do..he's actually had some decent posts..
[quote=""Slandaar"]Now Sword, why isnt magna scum for refusing to explain SD read or drop the lurker argument? or contradict himself with the lurking argument on SD himself? Oh did that escape you? I remember you seeing it, but you told me to let it go? why should I? Magna is contradicting his own argument which he will not drop.[/quote]
why should (Magna or anyone else for that matter) have to defend SD? Let SD do it for himself..if you think SD is scum, pressure SD. As far as the lurker argument goes…Moi is pressuring you (lurking is part of it, but he's got other ammo in there as well)….when i said let the lurking issue go, I meant both sides..not just you.
Slandaar wrote:I have also taken note of your contradiction you suggest I am scum not explaining WC, but not magna for not explaining SD
I thought I already clarified this..if you think someone is scum, make a case on them and pressure..we are in the business of catching scum, not catching town. Shouldn't you explain your reasoning on someone you think is scum? I would think so. Now as far as making a case on why someone is town? especially this early in the game makes no sense to do. Let the person you are making a case against defend themself..not have someone else do it for them. Take note of the actions and stances people make and then go from there...
now, gonna finish catching up from what i missed on the weekend...be back in a bit.
)