Gaben Mafia: GAME OVER

[The Mini-Librarian]

Confirming

[The Mini-Librarian]

Redff I love this flavor.

VOTE: seanald because his avatar is a turd.

[The Mini-Librarian]

@Inte: So was your first vote a random vote masquerading as actual content or did Umbrage do something that was so scummy it made you leave your first vote?

[The Mini-Librarian]

Meanmelter, the thing is you didn't say "at least two people in the list are scum", you said "two people from this list are scum". There's a world of difference between those two.

VOTE: meanmelter

In semi-related news every Kuribo post makes me giggle. I think there may be something wrong with me.

[The Mini-Librarian]

I think what Inte said was statiscally useless.

What you said implies you have extra knowledge of the setup. Inte did not do this.

Also, the way you defend yourself by shoveling attention onto others isn't helping matters either.

[The Mini-Librarian]

Once again...

Meanmelter, the thing is you didn't say "at least two people in the list are scum", you said "two people from this list are scum". There's a world of difference between those two.

[The Mini-Librarian]

What are you getting at seanald?

He asked how did he implied he had extra knowledge. Hiraki answered him. MM replied by saying that he didn't say that there was only 2 scum. I'm showing how he did. (Yes, again. But can you blame me?)

Why do you think that I'm not actually "scumhunting"?

If I'm actually scummy why aren't you voting me?

[The Mini-Librarian]

Also are you saying that being analytical in a game of mafia is a scumtell?

If so...

[The Mini-Librarian]

@seanald

And are you saying that anytime I find someone scummy i should just toss a vote on them?
if you find someone scummy auto toss a vote on?

Considering you don't have a vote out on someone you actually think is scummy I do find it a little odd.

Also can you explain what you see wrong in that Darox post.

--

Deathnote is making me twitch a bit. Not liking his complete lack of content.

--

@Meanmelter: Do you have leads on who might be scum?

[The Mini-Librarian]

What about deathnote? I mean he voted MM on a complete sheep, said checkmate could be scum... on a sheep, and, oh yes, said seanald was gullible. Useless and scummy.

VOTE: deathnote

Town Voltron isn't that bad. I have mild town reads on three of the people in there so I can deal with it. Regardless wouldn't be lynching from that pool today anyway soooo...

[The Mini-Librarian]

....

He's voting checkmate and has pretty consistently called him scum. :/

[The Mini-Librarian]

I guess that makes sense about Deathnote.

UNVOTE:

I will probably go on the cheeckmate wagon (#140 is a mess), but I'm going to have to reread some stuff when I'm not at work.

--

If by some miricle Kuribo actually is a dayvig, a meanmelter shot might actually be the best choice. Could really clarify some things on the flash wagon.

--

meanmelter: How is that darox post scummy?

[The Mini-Librarian]

@Umbrage

: Yeah I got a little defensive. He also said I wasn't scumhunting. That kinda pissed me off.

--

VOTE: meanmelter

I just read his iso again. It hurts my eyes. Might be convinced to join a checkmate wagon but I'm not seeing how anyone can think meanmelter is town right now.

[The Mini-Librarian]

@Darox:

Meanmelter is by far my highest scumread.

Other than that, Deathnote and Checkmate are minor scumreads.

[The Mini-Librarian]

@Deathnote: I don't like the way you sheeped without giving any sort of content. Feels like scum trying to not make waves.

@Inte: Hey, here's an idea. Stop being cryptic and explain what scumtell he tripped for you. (I really hate it when people do this...)

[The Mini-Librarian]

Hey look at that. It was a fake dayvig.

@Umbrage: It's not just the sheeping. It's the fact that he's not doing anything

else

but sheeping. The complete lack of content is scummy.

Regardless, this meanmelter wagon is great. Let's keep this going guys.

[The Mini-Librarian]

holy fucking shit... I hate you all.

@Meanmelter: Against my better judgment I'm going to ask you about your thought processes. Why did you ask that doctor question? How can an answer of that question help you find scum?

[The Mini-Librarian]

We're lynching inte.

Oh we are? I wasn't informed.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: inte

Stop ignoring my question.

holy fucking shit... I hate you all.

@Meanmelter: Against my better judgment I'm going to ask you about your thought processes. Why did you ask that doctor question? How can an answer of that question help you find scum?

[The Mini-Librarian]

@Meanmelter: How would that question help you find a loophole in how he scumhunts?

@The Fool: Can you detail why you think MM's town?

[The Mini-Librarian]

V/LA for the holidays. I'll be back monday evening EDT.

The Fool is pinging my scumdar pretty heavily lately. A lot of fluffy non-contributions.

An Inte lynch might not be a terrible thing, but I'm still realllllly feeling Meanmelter as scum and I'm seeing no way how these two can be partners.

[The Mini-Librarian]

CPR doc claim isn't exactly the most provable of claims ever, but I'm wasn't really feeling a inte lynch today anyway.

@Darox: It doesn't look like you'll get to lynch the checkmate slot today. Do you have a secondary scum read?

It's nice to see that Kuribo is starting to get the idea about Meanmelter. The slip is completely secondary to the way he's handled himself afterwards. He has not done any scumhunting at all and when pushed to do so he asked ridiculous non-questions that were more harmful than useful. He had to be pressed to even mention Inte's claim, which should be pretty important to him since, well, he's voting him.

[The Mini-Librarian]

I'm here.

I'm not seeing how the fuck this can possibly be a town play by inte. The fakeclaim was purely done for survivalistic means. If he's actually a one-shot vig WHY NOT CLAIM ONE-SHOT VIG? Seriously, it achieves every single "goal" that he wanted to do with this fakeclaim. I mean I kinda thought he might be a sk with that claim but goddamn this play doesn't make any sense from anyone except mafia.

I'm gonna look at some other people after work to see if anything else pops out at me, but Inte dies today.

[The Mini-Librarian]

You outed yourself first post because you're a mafiate who's trying to buy one more day before you bite the dust. Just like you did yesterday. Delaying your death as a scum member by even one day helps your team win. This isn't rocket science here.

Seriously, let's think here. Say i'm a one-shot vig that's almost lynched d1. What do I do? I claim fucking vig and shoot night 1. I confirm myself as a goddamn killing role.

[The Mini-Librarian]

Other things from day 2:

Posts 502 and 503 make Karnage look really, really bad. 1) Post really obvious questions to appear useful and 2) remember two minutes later that you are supposed to have a scumread on Inte. :/

Can someone tell me exactly what an amished tell is and how it is scummy? I spent some time searching the site and all I could find was that there was once a player named Amished. I think I see it but I'd like some clarification here.

I think that's everything worth commenting on that isn't Inte.

--

@Inte: Here's why you always shoot n1 if you're a one shot vig. YOU MIGHT DIE. The only thing that makes you better than a VT is your gun. And considering you might die from lynching and NK's at any point of the game, it's just ridiculous for any one shot vig to withhold their shot another day. Even if you hit town, the extra flip at night is immensly helpful in finding other scum. Simply put, your play makes no sense coming from the standpoint of someone who can actually generate an extra kill whenever they feel like.

I'm ready to hammer this guy.

[The Mini-Librarian]

While I'm not averse to a Ser lynch, you are all going to have to convince me exactly how Inte's play is stupid-town and not just scum.

[The Mini-Librarian]

My god.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: SAD

Please tell me that looks like a "FOS partner, vote townie" post to someone else.

[The Mini-Librarian]

Sorry. But I only have 1 vote. Unfortunately, I can't vote both people -___-

Also, if people are more interested in lynching Fool, I'll switch just as easily. I'm just saying inte is prob a shitty lynch, because it either involved scum pushing or scum bussing. Either way, we can catch scum from the people who jumped on inte. And, abracadabra!! Karnage is on the wagon with a shitty reason, and is prob scum. Fool is more of the lurking/flying under the radar scum, but if he is scum, he is either associated with someone on the inte wagon, or inte himself. Right now, I think Karnage has more of a chance of hitting scum.

This just looks like you're throwing shit in the air and hoping to cling on to it. So if I had done vice versa, you would still think the same... o.O

Nope. Cause here's the thing: When I read your post going from point to point I expected a Fool vote. The reasons you give for suspecting Fool are much more convincing than the reasons you gave for Karnage. And if you had a half a brain you'd realize that the reasons you give for suspecting Karnage are silly, like Kuribo so deftly pointed out.

Also:

I'm just saying inte is prob a shitty lynch, because it either involved scum pushing or scum bussing.

WHAT?

Is Inte scum or not? Why would scum bussing make it a shitty lynch???