The Wire, Season 1 - Final Credits!

[Oversoul]

I like the ingenuity of Deas's role and Ben's role but I don't think the mafia should have been informed of those specific player identities.

Crumbing the name of the character to each other would have sufficed?

More reason to kill Benmage in LyLo. Isn't this how he won Scummies Winvitational?

Also, what happened with Jason that was so horrible a lot of people are calling for him to be blacklisted?

[Oversoul]

Also, what happened with Jason that was so horrible a lot of people are calling for him to be blacklisted?

He did nothing all game but lurk, and go v/la... pathetic for scum.

You need people to CONTRIBUTE to the game to read them... that's the point of this game.. lurking is pathetic.

That's what the vig is for. At least that is how I would use a vig shot. Kill any potential mislynches being kept around by the scum/potentially hit lurker scum.

Faraday, what I meant was the mafia knowing of DV explicitly and Ben knowing that the traitor was a rolecop. I guess you are right those were minor points about the overall balance seeing as DV could correctly protect/scumhunt well, and Ben would know from the red hat. I'm just a fan of having secrets durin the Game to find out, as both factions. It's why I like being town so much more.

[Oversoul]

The deadqt is interesting.

Yes I purposely broke my "I only town selfvote schtik"... This epiphany occurred in a MD discussion where I came to the conclusion it was essentially cheating. What better game to break it in, no? I didn't even mention my past meta.. so go me fools.

But wouldn't breaking it for one game still be cheating?
Breaking it means never doing it again

[Oversoul]

The deadqt is interesting.

Yes I purposely broke my "I only town selfvote schtik"... This epiphany occurred in a MD discussion where I came to the conclusion it was essentially cheating. What better game to break it in, no? I didn't even mention my past meta.. so go me fools.

But wouldn't breaking it for one game still be cheating?
Breaking it means never doing it again

I have no qualm with self voting... I historically was using it to prove myself town.. Now neither I nor anyone can make that argument.. (formyself)

It is more while your intentions are good (to break a trust tell) you knowingly broke the tell in order to further your win condition so it still was cheating.
Nitpicky but I've done the same thing before

[Oversoul]

Hmm... That's a good point I guess since it isn't self created?
Looking at the scum qt... I want Benmage on all of my scum teams lol.
He has the wrong group scummy to be honest. :p

[Oversoul]

Also I wasn't trying to call you a cheater, Ben, just talking about it