Newbie 1345: Mafia in a Bind (Game Over)

[KingPin96]

Vote: theSlimer3

for being slimy....

[KingPin96]

I dont find Mutley particularly scummy. Most of his posts have been fluff or "lighthearted"-which is expected from early day 1. Not much else i can comment on (thats useful) this early in the game. However i think we should start to take the game a little more seriously at this point-now that accusations and suspicions are being thrown around. So

unvote

.

[KingPin96]

Yeah, RQS sucks. Keep away please.

Will be interested to hear Muttley's answer to Xegarus, but for now I have FSnake and Muttley both as town, and Xiao Long is looking scummiest to me.

Not sure about Voodoo's reaction, but for now

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Xiao Long

Why is Xiao Long looking the scummiest in your eyes?

[KingPin96]

@Mp5 you voted for him at the time the majority of players were posting fluff, his posts concerning pressuring/reacting came after. Also, accusing someone of being scummy for being excited early game (also considering its his first) isnt a very valid reason.

Vote: Mp5

What makes you think excitement indicates scumminess?

[KingPin96]

As you also point out KP96, when I voted for him, people were posting fluff (it was rvs). Would you prefer me to vote for someone based on a known possible scum tell, or fluff?

His reaction trying to assert there is no reason is a sucky defence. He is still the most probable scum in my eyes at the moment.

Obviously voting for someone based on a scumtell is the better choice. However, "that excitement-tell" is far too vague as a scumtell. Like you said in that other game he was excited to play as scum and got caught out for it. But it has already been said that people act in differnt ways. One person could be excited to play as mafia, another could be very nervous to play as mafia.

Im not telling you who you should see as scum as thats entirely up to you, but accusing someone of being scum with such a poor logic (almost no reason at all) is quite scummy.

Also the fact you voted for him at first without providing a reason then used his later posts as reasons for voting him is quite suspicious too (I meant to add this part in my last post).

[KingPin96]

Anyone have any thoughts on my case with Mp5 (on both the case and himself)? Or is it just me and xiao who are finding him rather scummy?

[KingPin96]

Even if Mutley's not scum he wasnt being useful to town in the slightest, just being a distraction, so i wouldnt mind a mutley lynch.

[KingPin96]

You thought you had ended it, you didn't realise your vote was already on me. You thought you had taken a power role out first day mr mafia.

A power role would have had more motivation to defend themselves and scumhunt. You have pretty much done neither.

[KingPin96]

Mutley if this is your form of scum/reaction hunting, its not worked very well.

You dont mind if we lynch you and you say it will provide useful info. No, if we lynch you and you do actually flip town, it just continues to prove that you were being a distraction and were hindering our efforts to find real scum.

If we lynch you and you flip scum, then hooray!

[KingPin96]

Reads, Mut is confirmed town in my book. I love his responses. So arrogant and stubborn. Scum is NEVER like this. Not in my experience. Scum is fickle and trying to look good. ALWAYS. Mut isn't scum. He's not afraid to say no. This makes him look so shit to everyone but soo town to me.

Doesnt town not want to look good too? So a myslynch is less likely to happen?

Also its been said before, people act in different ways. Town-mutley could just have been bored and clueless and felt like fannying around, scum-mutley could have maybe felt clueless too, or maybe just didnt like being scum so he has less motivation and just gives up from the start.

In my opinion, it all comes down to opinions and not facts in terms of peoples play.

[KingPin96]

Yes Fsnake the scum or at least one is likely to be hiding in the midst knowing that I would be an easy lynch. Which is why I am very much looking at Kingpin. He was around but never voted me even though he thinks I am scum or anti-town. Maybe because he knows I am going to flip town and therefore won't be looked at too much after cos he wasn't on the wagon.

I never really said you were scum, i just said you were being anti town and a distraction. If i voted for you it would've been a hammer. I said i wouldnt mind lynching you but now that ive thought about it a bit more, I'd rather wait till near the end of day 1 before even considering hammering.

[KingPin96]

For me kingpin is likely mafia due to his not wanting to hammer me. He didnt want to get looked at as the final blow so was waiting for someone else. He lurked a bit and didnt get involved in the exchanges. If he is mafia he knew all I was doing was being 'anti town' therefore was happy to reinforce his opinion in it. So that the town would look at it as in a oh he was right etc He's not mafia!

You I feel are mafia because again you wanted me gone, but also tries to get me to defend myself. Knowing that I would flip town it would make you look town too even though you voted me. Also you posts that have been brought up previously about not thinking you look scummy. You are obviously worried about trying not to look scummy and not just playing the game knowing you don't need to lie because you are town and have nothing to hide.

As you feel the need to call someone a cunt I feel I'd rather vote you over king pin.
Also I feel you've changed slightly since votes have come off me because of my arrogance and stubbornness. You seem to be playing yourself towards that role too. So that you can use that defence of 'well you saw mutley as town because of that post style why not me?'

I didnt want to hammer because like i said, i'd rather wait till close to the end of the day, that way we'll have more information and it you should be more clearer who should be finally lynched.

[KingPin96]

I wasnt trying to defend xio earlier, i just found it odd that mp5 found him scummy without providing a reason.