UNVOTE:
VOTE: Lurker
For jumping on two different bandwagons already with no contribution otherwise. Also, for living up to namesake.
↑ Revenus wrote:↑ Ms Marangal wrote:UNVOTE:
I had a vote placed for far to long. its Icky :<
and yes, to much of an advantage if scum. you have two heads, meaning twice the thinking power.
This is such a bad post
Vote:Marangal
↑ Bacde wrote:↑ kashoodles wrote:I thought I had tagged more things to quote... hmm. Re-read through the pages.
@Bacde
Can you explain this? At this point, you sheeped BrightEyedFish from Zoidberg, which is fine, we were in RVS-ish stage, but then you say this. Literally all BrightEyedFish said at that point was "Nice list... How'd you come up with it?"
It takes about 10 seconds of original thought to realize that Zoidberg made a list with all of the players who had posted as "Town" (except Ms Marangal who was "iffy" for voting Zoidberg) and everyone else as scum
since BEF didn't realize this, I figured he was scum for not being fully mentally present in the game. Scum are in a different headspace than town and often aren't able to replicate the analytic thought process town have
now he just seems derp
↑ Bacde wrote:↑ kashoodles wrote:
I'm confused also as to why you're voting Rev, especially because his confusion is similar to mine about the comment quoted. You seem semi-serious yet semi-trolling (or just semi-trying to copy Zoidberg?).
Its gut based on the way Rev has been playing this game
But I think Hiraki is more likely to be scum than Rev, #75 was too bad
you should vote for Hiraki
Doctor Zoidberg MD wrote:kashoodles's slot is conftown.
↑ Ms Marangal wrote:Why only call out Lurker though? Safety and I both have posted very little in this game, and what I have posted so far can easily be called fluff. no scum hunting can be found in any of my posts at all
↑ Lurker wrote:Side note: I really don't like how in #41 Safety doesn't vote me, notices my behavior, then votes for me WITH THE EXACT SAME REASONING. I don't know why he waited, but it is nothing in and of itself.
Keyblade is acting pretty badly.
He gets into a breif flame war as soon as he is in the game, Talks about ongoing games, Continues this until page 5, where he votes for someone with a replacement, Then IMMEDIATLEY backslides and wails "why are you lynching meeee", and then tries to get Safety onto another wagon, following by saying there is no reasoning for his wagon, even though he stated "You're overreacting", which at this stage of the game is more then sufficient to warrant a vote.
VOTE: Keybladeweilder
↑ Keybladewielder wrote:The fact that I've been watching your games and live been an idiot in every one of them is incredibly bad for you
↑ SafetyDance wrote:Prod doge.
If anyone's being an idiot, admitting to being an idiot, then they should be lynched in an instant on day one.
↑ Keybladewielder wrote:Rev, I fail to see your logic here. You say that calling you scummy and listing reasons for said accusation, that puts me in a scum position. How?
↑ Keybladewielder wrote:Also, you need to calm down. I won't call you a Idiot anymore, BUT that doesn't change my opinion. Post some real content, and then well see.
I'm voting you because the Village Idiots get lynched first for being dumb.
It's happened to me a thousand times. So don't get all pissy with me over a name.
This is the Internet dude, you can't take stuff seriously.
↑ Keybladewielder wrote:No. I'm voting you because you are you, and as such are sounding scummy as crap.
I'm not providing your games because they are both going on right now.
↑ Xegarus wrote:
How so?
Mind if i ask a newbie question?
In a game with 13 players, how many scum would you expect?
↑ Keybladewielder wrote:Requesting a replacement?
UNVOTE: Revenus
VOTE: BrightEyedFish
Seems fishy to me (sorry bad pun)
↑ Ms Marangal wrote:I just... ugh
I'm starting to think KBW's play is conf. scum play in my eyes but w/e
KBW got super jumpy as fuck when SD moved his vote on him, Scum being jumpy?
↑ IFM wrote:Ok, just finished reading through the thread and I can definitely see why you guys would want to lynch my slot. With that being said their could be a host of other reason's why Fish would sub out and being noob scum definitely isn't the case in this situation. I'd like you guys to step back and consider that you can't make a meta-read off his scum play and before he asked to be subbed you thought he was more a derp than anything else. Personally, I think he didn't know how to respond to pressure and choose instead to sub out instead of jeopardizing the town's chances. It has already been established that he didn't know how to play the game that well, so jumping to considering my slot scum based on that is a bit of a stretch imo.
Key immediately asking for reasons when he was voted seems extremely scummy too me. In my experience when people do that they are scum, who think they haven't given any reason to be voted. That causes them to immediately ask for the reason to the vote instead of pushing it off like a town alligned person would do.
As a result:
UNVOTE: whoever fish voted
Lurker wrote:Side note: I really don't like how in #41 Safety doesn't vote me, notices my behavior, then votes for me WITH THE EXACT SAME REASONING. I don't know why he waited, but it is nothing in and of itself.
Keyblade is acting pretty badly.
He gets into a breif flame war as soon as he is in the game, Talks about ongoing games, Continues this until page 5, where he votes for someone with a replacement, Then IMMEDIATLEY backslides and wails "why are you lynching meeee", and then tries to get Safety onto another wagon, following by saying there is no reasoning for his wagon, even though he stated "You're overreacting", which at this stage of the game is more then sufficient to warrant a vote.
VOTE: Keybladeweilder
VOTE: Keybladewielder
Keybladewielder wrote:I don't give a crap if IFM is my neighbor, he's my vote.
Keybladewielder wrote:You realize I'm about to freaking ragequit.
I'm not trying to be anti town, that's just vow they are interpreting it.
↑ Keybladewielder wrote:Get this through your obviously thick skull:
I DON'T LIKE REV.
Now, I can deal with his bullshit for another day to eliminate the Fish guy, but jeez.
Pedit: You know what I'm talking about, rev. You know.
↑ Keybladewielder wrote:No, I was not referring to a current game, I was referring to how much I despise you.
↑ IFM wrote:Wow why was it necessary to mention the neighborhood?
Well now that Key outed the neighborhood thing I might as well explain it. Basically we can talk during pre-game or during nights. It gives no promise of alignment and when I checked the only message was a fluff one from fish.
Now ever since I made my first post Key has been acting extremely childish. I wouldn't say this is 100% scummy, but extremely anti-town and hasn't been backed up by any major contributions. He also seems to be locked in on Rev and I, but really hasn't given any substantial reason for it. I mean seriously, voting someone because you despise them is absolutely awful play and unless he mans up and actually starts contributing I think we should probably vote him.
↑ Keybladewielder wrote:I don't despise you as a person, just as a player.
↑ Xegarus wrote:
↑ kashoodles wrote:So you can twist it to how you want?
I could have, but i didnt. Did i?
To be completely honest, i dont have any solid reads at the moment. Slightly intimidated by the size of this game.
I agree with Hiraki that fish may have rage quited as scum so my vote is staying on his replacement. But would like to hear more from IFM before calling him scum or not.
Keyblade seems to be trying too hard, but with the attention he is getting and the pressure on him, it looks understandable to me.
I dont like the fact that he's getting a little too emotional.
↑ Xegarus wrote:
.........i used the 'noob card'?
Where?
It certainly isn't in the quote.
And why not vote for me if i am a strong scum read? Your reason for voting Keyblade is pretty shit. All you have said about it is 'over reacting'.
VOTE: absta
Stop grasping for straws.
↑ Doctor Zoidberg MD wrote:
You're scum; we're not obligated to answer your questions. Now sit there in the corner while we finish finding your buddies.
↑ Keybladewielder wrote:Perhaps its my ADHD fueled Sugar High!
It is not scummy at all.
Go ahead and vote, you'll be down a town member and I'll be able to focus on the other 5 games I'm playing.
↑ absta101 wrote:↑ kashoodles wrote:Ruh roh, never finished my ISO's yesterday. Will try to get it sometime today, though I'm semi-VLA-ing for the next couple days.
IFM wagon is interesting - Hiraki, why IFM?
Hearing from KBW and Zoidberg more in general would be super!
Trying to leave the Xeg waggon?
We can deal with IFM tomorrow. Xeg is our man today.
↑ Doctor Zoidberg MD wrote:@ Hiraki
I'm still voting IFM.
Thoughts on Xegarus?
My hydra partner thinks he's overwhelmed town.
-DGB
↑ Lurker wrote:↑ Doctor Zoidberg MD wrote:
Let's examine your case on keyblade for a bit:
↑ Lurker wrote:Side note: I really don't like how in #41 Safety doesn't vote me, notices my behavior, then votes for me WITH THE EXACT SAME REASONING. I don't know why he waited, but it is nothing in and of itself.
Keyblade is acting pretty badly.
He gets into a breif flame war as soon as he is in the game, Talks about ongoing games, Continues this until page 5, where he votes for someone with a replacement, Then IMMEDIATLEY backslides and wails "why are you lynching meeee", and then tries to get Safety onto another wagon, following by saying there is no reasoning for his wagon, even though he stated "You're overreacting", which at this stage of the game is more then sufficient to warrant a vote.
VOTE: Keybladeweilder
Just outlining what he's done is not evidence of anything. What is the scum motivation behind doing the things he's done? Why is getting into a brief flame war scummy? Why is talking about ongoing games scummy? Why is whatever else scummy?
You have to demonstrate that keyblade is coming from a scum mindset.
This looks like a well thought out response except for one thing:
I NEVER SAID
#1 That he was scum in this post.
#2 That I thought these things were scummy.
You are trying to figure out information that I don't have.
Rephrase the question or you get no answer from me.
I said that he was acting "Pretty Badly"
↑ Lurker wrote:@ Kashooldes (Regarding #285, trying to avoid walls o quotes since i don't know how to do the spoiler thingy.)
Q1. Why I voted for Keyblade: The wagon I would say offically became official at post #121 (SafetyDance's vote), followed by IFM and me jumping on the wagon. Now, before this, I was voting BrightEyedFish, who then replaced out. When that slot got replaced by IFM, IFM's first post just screams TOWN TOWN TOWN to me.
He takes a really nice approach to replacing into a slot under scrutiny, and accepts the behavior of his last slot instead of getting a scapegoat for all the votes.
Whe KBW Reacted @ post #122, I saw one of the first tells I was taught in (Some open masons and mafia game, I can't find it right now): Overreacting is a scumtell.
This I found sufficient for a vote.
@Comment #2. I find what you found scummy of that post is not that I am lurking and not giving content, It's that I was backtracking and trying to change what I meant in order to change your read on me. As you said, it is more then just lurkiness, and lurkiness alone is not a sufficient reason IMO to lynch me.
I'll think about more things to comment on when I come back. Hopefully I will actually do it.
↑ Ms Marangal wrote:I'm finding it hard to follow the amount of games that I'm in.
Mod: I'm sorry, but please replace me.
↑ RandomYoshi wrote:Oh God, I just got to the part where KBW outer the Neighbourhood. On that topic, are people still undecided on his alignment, by the way? I've seen arguments that supports him being Scum, and I've seen arguments that supports him being Town. Personally, I feel that he was frustrated Town who didn't know how to handle pressure at all, and decided to out the Neighbourhood out of pure frustration.
Completely unrelated to this, I don't like Bacde's quasi-OMGUS attack on Hiarki that lasted throughout pages 3-4. In fact, Hiarki only had Bacde in his lynchpool as a last resort, yet Bacde thought that Hiarki said that Bacde required death. To me, it seems like Bacde is afraid of being lynched. Bacde, are you Scum?
↑ SafetyDance wrote:Great, all we need is KBW to come back. He's posting elsewhere on site so hopefully will be back soon. It's stalled enough as it is.
Going through the playerlist:
Revenus
Lurker
absta
Zdenek
KBW
IFM
If there's not at least one scum in this group then god help us all, because nothing will save this town >.<
↑ RandomYoshi wrote:kashoodles, what are your reads?
↑ Zdenek wrote:
Kashoodles looks ok on page 6.
But then I dislike Kashoodle criticizing Bacde's vote on Xeg who she is also voting.
Kashoodles why did it matter whether Bacde voted before or after Absta here?
↑ Ms Marangal wrote:I think it's likely that you are both town.
This seems like a pretty unjustified double town read.
Kashoodles could you explain your read on Keyblade around page 7?
SafetyDance, I think that it is false that neighborhoods are always random.
↑ absta101 wrote:Ahhh, thank you for reminding me. IFM is very likely town due to how BEF was acting.
Also, town will lose this game. Xeg replaces out and now no one is voting him. I wouldn't be surprised if Kash was his partner as well.
If you guys decide to lynch me, just lynch these two next and I'll be happy.
↑ absta101 wrote:What do you mean by "pin a mislynch on me"? Xeg isn't mislynch...
Why would I misrep you there anyway?
I must've misunderstood you. It seemed as if you were trying to leave the Xeg waggon after Hiraki (would have) told you why IFM was scummy.
Yeah, maybe i'm Xeg's scum partner. Or, maybe you are?It feels like you know something about the Xeg lynch that I don't...
↑ RandomYoshi wrote:↑ kashoodles wrote:My gut OMGUS at the moment is absta, but I don't think that would make sense. He's been really harsh on Xeg and Xeg had been dodge-y previously and their back and forth seems like they haven't interacted with each other. Could be town-town, but getting scum from both of them, so I think it's a scum-town relationship.
In case it's a Scum-Town relationship, who is the Scum and who is the Town?
↑ Bacde wrote:
Kash's first post was really town, but recently her play has been weird imo. I don't understand why she unvoted Lurker for what was a terrible post, and I keep feeling like she is trying to set me up for suspicion or a mislynch or something with her grilling me w/ questions but not voting me
I could see Kash as scum but actually I want to give Zdenek more time
↑ Lurker wrote:Short Reads
1. RachMarie - Null
2. Revenus - Null
3. Hiraki - Slight town
4. RandomYoshi - Town
5. Doctor Zoidberg MD - Town
6. Bacde - Slight scum
7. Lurker - ????????
8. absta101 - Slight town
9. SafetyDance - Town
10. Kashoodles - Town
11. Zdenek - Null
12. Keybladeweilder-Slight scum
13. IFM- Town
I can elaborate on any one of them.
↑ SafetyDance wrote:
↑ kashoodles wrote: SafetyDance I feel has been somewhat going under the radar - someone I really do want to focus in on more. Nothing he's said has been particularly scummy, but I also feel like he's lurking during the best situations and pops in once in a while.
Once in a while is actually quite regularly. I'm not likely to be in any spamguments, if that's what you're inferring too but I think I've been around fairly regularly. Aas for content, what do you expect when your two main targets leave? I do believe I mentioned my annoyance at that.
↑ absta101 wrote:Kash, I'm one person who finds you scum. What am I setting you up for? Do you honestly think scum-absta would expect people to follow him on just a simple "fake" gut scum read?
Me having a scum read on you is null. I don't see how it can rub you the wrong way. I think you're talking crap.
↑ AngryPidgeon wrote:
↑ RandomYoshi wrote:Why don't you have a single strong scumread?
Why is that scummy behavior? Is it not possible for town-Lurker to not have any strong reads? (Note he IS voting his 'strongest' read)
363 DOES look town though. Lurker isn't trying to appease anyone. Its like how RY voted him for not having any 'scum' reads and only light scum reads. Scum-lurker is more likely to pad his reads list in a way to avoid that sort of crappy suspicion. Its the same way I id'd Darthe as town in NY159 for going all D2 without voting anyone. Its just a small thing that people WILL call you scummy for and that scum players WILL avoid doing for that reason. Also he doesn't bother justifying any of those reads very much which gives me town vibes for the same reason. WIFOM, etc.
@Kash:Feel better : ). I think Im mostly over my flu/cold.
↑ absta101 wrote:
@KashNot "partly", fully! I was responding to him...It's more like you keep mentioning it as an extra afterthought that is unnecessary in the situation. I wouldn't find it weird except you keep bringing it up. Though I was skimming yesterday and Rev asking you about it was part of it so that was partly influencing it.
What? Why would that be helpful to scum-absta. Even if I were scum and you were right about me setting something up, how would I know who would get lynched?It just seems like you keep bringing up these points now for something later on, like after the lynch today.
↑ absta101 wrote:
@KashThis obviously doesn't work because i'm the one pushing his lynch the hardest.That's why it feels weird. It makes me think Xeg is town and you are trying to make it seem like I pushed a mislynch
Push a buss?Xeg is scum and you are trying to push a buss.
You mean to say i'm trying to sacrifice Xeg/Zed for the small chance of getting town-you with him? If scum-absta wanted you dead, why not just NK you? Generally scum go after more easier targets. I'm like the only one who is suspicious of you. It doesn't make sense.
↑ absta101 wrote:↑ kashoodles wrote:Also, I think that's L-2 before people jump on the BW and claim they didn't know.
Np, you better self vote after I flip town.
↑ DrippingGoofball wrote:absta is town, town, town.
There is exactly one scum on his wagon.
AngryPidgeon, SafetyDance, RandomYoshi, Kashoodles, Lurker (L-2)
↑ AngryPidgeon wrote:Dat scumslip. How do you know the neighbors are town/town?
Also Bacde is fucking mafia isn't he? He would try to kill me.
↑ SafetyDance wrote:Have you been upset/annoyed this game? You're original wagon (which you're now distancing from) was not the night kill either. Areyoumad? If that's how you normally play, why aren'tyoulike that?
If we play similar and all...
↑ IFM wrote:
I assume it was different enough from your town meta that he considered it your scum.
After being the second leading wagon yesterday Yoshi has done nothing today. It seems like he is trying to stay out of the spotlight now that the pressure is off of him.
Vote RandomYoshi
I don't have any problems with absta and in my eyes he is leaning town. I wouldn't have any major problems with voting Zde, but I think we need to get some pressure on Yoshi to get him posting.
Also sorry about my inactivity for most of the day so far. I was at a convention until late last night and wasn't able to read through stuff today.
↑ AngryPidgeon wrote:Mmm, ok. I can explain some of my trolling, I just rolled my fav PR and I'm giddy cause I'm conftown in my head.
Im a 1 shot bulletproof town.(In addition to being a neighbor)
So Im pretty sure I am the reason why there was no NK last night. Im also suspicious of Zoid a little bit because I expected them to die last night. My crap about wanting to be protected was just WIFOM to imply I was a big PR.
All of my crap today about 'killing pidgeons' and 'Bacde would kill me' is light trolling for reactions cause I'm pretty sure my 1xBP sponged the scum NK last night. Oh, that was also part of my decision to quick hammer lurker since Im only 1 shot.
Also, my vote on absta was just to see how other people reacted. I'm actually certain that absta isn't hiding anything after skimming last night. So I'mbehindabsta-town for now.
↑ SafetyDance wrote:
Attempting to understand reason that post has to do with RandomYoshi or AP's read on RY...
...
...
...
Attempt Failed.
Please, do enlighten.
↑ Doctor Zoidberg MD wrote:So? Scum aren't obligated to kill people who are seen as very-towny. Maybe they tried to pick off a suspected PR. Maybe they no-killed on purpose. There are lots of equally plausible explanations and your reasoning is specious.↑ AngryPidgeon wrote:
Dear Dr. Zoidberg. The rest of the town may be content to let you pretend to be too carefree to back your bullshit up, but Im pretty sure you are scum. You were a universal townread