Gears of War Mafia - ( Game Over! )

[PeregrineV]

Vote: The Goat

Rhyming rocks.

[PeregrineV]

You love me really AP.

Who are you Cryo?

It's a hydra of Cryo and Nudist. The naked one is Nudist.

[PeregrineV]

That seems kinda a reach for this early in a game... I don't even particularly like meta cases at any point in a game, but this early just feels somewhat off.
@Angelius: have both heads posted, or is this just Arc/just Nero so far?

So you don't like meta cases, which are mostly completely subjective anyway, and, in addition, bork's meta case feels "off"? Like, he shouldn't be able to produce it, or he produced it badly, or he's wrong, or you want him to think he's wrong?

Vote: Knight of Cydonia

Super extra lynch vote: Majiffy

[PeregrineV]

How is Mac scummy from that interaction?

Is Mac=KoC?

[PeregrineV]

Lost me post from here earlier.

In summary:

Town

1. Colonel Guile ( Uberninja/guille2015 hydra )
5. Angelious Nero ( Nero Cain/ArcAngel9 hydra )
6. PirateCat ( Pirate Mollie/Malakittens hydra )
8. Majiffy
9. AngryPidgeon
10. The Goat
15. Jal
17. mastin2

Not so much:

The Rest

[PeregrineV]

Why the fuck do I get a sad face? How rude.

In Posh mafia, you had the most town posts at 503 and town lost.
In You can be anyone mafia, you had the second most town posts, and town lost.

I think your town this game, but a certain refinement in your technique would be appreciated, and I think, improve your scumhunting efficiency.

The sad face was because I REALLY wanted to lynch you.

[PeregrineV]

Why the fuck do I get a sad face? How rude.

In Posh mafia, you had the most town posts at 503 and town lost.
In You can be anyone mafia, you had the second most town posts, and town lost.

I think your town this game, but a certain refinement in your technique would be appreciated, and I think, improve your scumhunting efficiency.

The sad face was because I REALLY wanted to lynch you.

Both of those games are games where I had called out members of the scum teams very early on, and no one bothered to listen to me.
Meanwhile, there are games where people DO listen to me.

So you can fuck off.

Sorry, I remember it differently, with an early vote on scum, a late vote on scum, all other votes on town, and a self-hammer on your town self.
But that's water under the bridge....

or it will be when my tic goes away

.

So, who are your scumreads right now, Majiffy?

[PeregrineV]

Caught up, but may have missed some, but probably just forgot.

I can see Cyro as scum for early posting behavior. But, having fessed up, I'm willing to wait for redemption posting that tickles my towndar.

Keep townreads, but Guille and Jal slipping southwards until I hear more from them.

Separate posts for more specifics.

[PeregrineV]

Didn't think this was addressed to me, but I guess I can rebutt it.

When you notice that there's actually a WHOLE BUNCH OF SHIT HAPPENING instead of just dismissing the people voting you as "idiots" or being snarky, and actually start contributing to the game (assuming what you contribute is actually useful, pro-town stuff), I'll reconsider my vote. Until then? You're doing nothing to help move the game along which does nothing but distract from finding actual scum (if you're town and this is just you being a VI), and producing zero active scumhunting of your own, which means you're either a retard (no bueno) or scum (similarly no bueno).

This kind of sums up Majiffy. But I'm going on the theory that his posting can be improved, and since I think he's town right now, you'll probably get better results by addressing specifics to him (no gurantee, but worth a try).

[PeregrineV]

Thegoat, what do you think of AN's case on mac, and why aren't you on that wagon?

I'm assuming you're referring to his early read on Mac's overreaction to Bork's post. I saw it similarly. I am not on that wagon because I don't feel as strongly about that as I do about KoC being scum.

I'll be phone posting for the rest of the day as I can; may check in very late. Apparently my workplace's Websense filter dislikes Mafiascum.net.

It wasn't really an over reaction though, it was me pondering bork's opinion and offering my own.

I actually missed out a couple of words meaning it looked like I was accusing GIF of being scum

. I would never class him as scum straight off the bat from that, but his question would be, in my eyes,

more likely

to come from scum than town.

This post makes me feel worse about you, not better. Can you unpack the bolded part for me? Pretend that I'm not only stupid, but also uncaffeinated.

Okay, my post:

Seems more likely for town to do that than for scum (who would already know) to do that.

I found it quite the opposite if I'm honest, scum questioning what scum would be to appear more town.

Pedit: Yeah I know, I glossed over the ninja posts by accident.

It

should've

said "more likely scum questioning what scum would be to appear more town."

It was not intended to be a direct accusation of GIF being scum on page two, more a scumread - hence why it hasn't been pushed, which is the base of Nero's case against me being scum. Hence my confusion of why there's a case on me (which, by the way, I can understand now.) It wasn't intended to be taken as "GIF IS SCUM LYNCH!!!" or else I would've pushed it harder.

And it is also pure coincidence GIF happened to be my RVS.

UNVOTE:

Curious why you defended your vote on Guy in Freezer, then proceeded to unvote him.

[PeregrineV]

Will re-read Mesiah since I don't recall anything of his, but is there a good case someone made?

[PeregrineV]

PgV - my vote was on Ms Marangal. I unvoted following her soft claim shit because I don't what to make of it right now.

Got it.

[PeregrineV]

So, if I'm being realistic: ANG, KoC, Messiah, Cryo, Guile are lynchable. I'd like people to comment on all those players.

ANG- Don't remember, would have to go look.

KoC- Early scumvibes, not much to change that (I think he had one good post since I made that read. Maybe I can find that)

Messiah- Did an ISO. Leaning scum.

Cryo- I understand not getting your head into a game. But you got two. And while sometimes heads get busy and only one can post, that's not what you said. Leaning scum.

Guille- Is this a hydra too? Will go look and see.

[PeregrineV]

Fuck-it: Betelgeuse, Beetlejuice, Beeteljuse!

Vote: Bitmap

Any of the major thread contributors can be investigated, so lynching them without actual cases isn't going to happen.

I expect more from Col. Guille, given Hydraness and town meta of the heads, but willing to wait a day.

[PeregrineV]

Checking in post, but will have to read later.

[PeregrineV]

I'd rather have more larger wagons. Also

@Mod- Qwints voting Pirate and Messiah?

Vote: Messiah

Mostly compromise, don't like the Slandaar wagon, and the Cyro wagon isn't going to happen.

And my favorite sheeple are not pulling through.

[PeregrineV]

Dat Messiah counterwagon to a Slandaar wagon

Yeah, what are you gonna do?

[PeregrineV]

Mock you when Slandaar flips scum.

p-edit: yey

OK, I'll fakevig him tonight. Problem solved.

[PeregrineV]

@Mod- Qwints voting Pirate and Messiah?

That's an error, sorry.

Or... Actually it isn't, Majiffy changed the VC for his post. Qwints was still voting pirate when I made my official VC.

Actually that was me. I was updating the wagons from the last postcount and didn't catch qwints on the other wagon.

Good job. Now the mod's pissed at me.

[PeregrineV]

Angel Nero vote parking and clamming up?

Hmmm.

Vote: Angel Nero

[PeregrineV]

Uber/guile hydra is quiet. Too quiet.

Agree with this too, but Angel Nero seeemd to have spurted posts early to appear townie, but is either trying to ride that or just gave up because too much effort for two people.

Hell, my votes been there over a day and Angel has come in to call me scum for voting her, and Nero hasn't called me an idiot.

Those some pretty big red flags.

[PeregrineV]

Uber/guile hydra is quiet. Too quiet. And Viomi has replaced in and posted absolutely zero content in her posts so far.

Honestly, I just a) keep forgetting I'm signed up for this game and sit there looking at my bookmarks page on my main, waiting for something to happen, and then I'm like "OH YEA GEARS OF WAR" and then I come here and I go "aw shit, ten more pages" and I lose all motivation, and b) never think of signing on as this hydra, and c) keep getting RL busy (srsly this shit is crazy yo).

If guille doesn't make any posts soon I might just replace this hydra with my own username, and then I'll be marginally more active. Either that, or you guys should wagon me to give me some motivation to post. lol

Then do a re-read like your replacing in and say something fresh that we all missed without adding 100 more posts.

[PeregrineV]

@mod- V/LA Mar 29 to Apr 1

[PeregrineV]

Vote: Messiah

[PeregrineV]

@Slandaar- So you attempted to Masonize PirateCat, and no masonry was formed?
Do you still have your one-shot left, or is it gone?

@Pirate- Why would you speculate 2 scum teams?

[PeregrineV]

@Slandaar- So you attempted to Masonize PirateCat, and no masonry was formed?
Do you still have your one-shot left, or is it gone?

@Slanddar- I suppose these are the questions you're getting answered?

[PeregrineV]

Checking in. Will look at Slandaar interactions.

[PeregrineV]

I can pretty much confirm that PirateCat is town. Just keep that in mind if I'm killed/lynched - thanks.

What?

Just before you kept calling us scum and now we are confirmed town?

What.the.hell?

^ This...

VOTE: buldermar

I'm so relieved. Can you explain your incredibly odd flip-flopping and subsequent cessation of posting yesterday? I'm willing to listen to outlandish explanations like multiple personalities, demonic possession, etc.

I already did and it's super simple. I thought PirateCat claimed to have an innocent investigation on me in her first post yesterday. If she had an innocent investigation on me, she must be town. Therefore I claimed to know that PirateCat is town. However, she then questioned this claim of mine. This suggests that what I intially thought was an innocent investigation on me being claimed in her first post really wasn't an innocent investigation on me. Therefore, I had to retract my statement that PirateCat is town and could once again vote her.

If you'd read my previous posts carefully instead of going into noob-mode and vote me, you'd see that I am indeed telling the truth. You can even read PirateCat's first post of yesterday to confirm what I'm saying. However, we both know that you aren't going to do so because you're scum and you're pretending to be retarded.

@Fitz

- I'd like to hear your response to this explanation.

[PeregrineV]

@Fitz

- NM, you're scum.

Vote: HavingFitz

Would also go for Angel Nero.

[PeregrineV]

OK I read everything after being motivated by Mastins pro buddying technique

Town;
Bork
Mac
Mollie
Goat

Probably town;

Mastin
Jal

I think town:
Majiffy
NC

Undecided

AP

Might be scum
UN (Col. Guille)
GIF (Buldemar)

Probably scum
KoC
ANG (Viomi)
Qwints
Maran

Scum
Cryo

Messiah

anyone I didn't put in this list I really don't have an opinion on; also; I didn't use hydra names because I mostly went from memory.

also; I expect this to be multiball.

Always informative, never dull. (Blue is highly prob-town)

[PeregrineV]

Slanddar "no opinion" list for post 460.


14. Bacde Bitmap *
18. PeregrineV
20. havingfitz *

[PeregrineV]

[6] Slandaar:

Majiffy

, Messiah,

PirateCat

, borkjerfkin,

Knight of Cydonia, CryoNudist

I currently have 5 scum voting me
Its actually hilarious.

Called/argued PirateCat, KoC, Cryo, Majiffy as scum.

Messiah went from a scum read to a buddy (1419).
Bork has 2 mentions only (968 and 975). Sorry, between those posts are back forths.

Bork probably not-scum, or 1264 is bussing when counterwagon could have been increased.

[PeregrineV]

Fitz seems town.

Fitzscum cares about how he appears much more.

Fitzscum cares about how he appears much more.

so at some point you will have no problem pulling up a meta case on him in order to support this and to justify the reasoning behind it.

lol
I probably won't be doing that.

I would rather lynch havingfits personally and he is tweaking the other head's scumdar too.

Oh wait; you are going after low hanging fruit???

I have explained Fitz; he seems town because when hes scum he tries to look town where here he isn't. Not foolproof but especially in his catchup bits I am pretty sure as scum he would write more.

I have no desire to write a case touting his townness though lol.

Why do you think this is such a big issue?

Fitz soft-defense by Slandaar

[PeregrineV]

I'll look for more later, but unless Slandaar and Pirate wanted to just puke up the thread building cases on each other, she's not scum.

So, vote Fitz.

[PeregrineV]

Thanks for modding Venmar. Great flavor and I enjoyed the game even if I died early (to a NK no less).