Gears of War Mafia - ( Game Over! )

[Antilles]

1)The "this is exactly why I voted for you" doesn't even make sense. I cited a previous game where basically the exact same thing happened and I flipped town, and you're saying that's exactly why you voted me.
2)You argue that it's too early (via page numbers) for town to get upset about a vote on them, yet simultaneously argue that your vote is totally legitimate.
2b)You emphasize so strongly the specific page number and don't even cite the correct page.
3)You proceed to call me scummy for questioning the shitvotes I have on me.

1.) I was obviously referring to the "town doesn't say that" part, which is why I then proceeded to start the next sentence with "Town doesn't..."
2.) I

almost

see your point. Your reaction to your wagon has been awful all around, mostly down to the way you demanded everyone present a case so you can defend yourself. You're trying to make a distinction between that and "You can't PROVE I'm scum!" but I don't see one, at all, even a little. The fact that it was so early in the game just made it worse, as if you somehow expected AP to be giving you cases to pick apart on page 4. (And yes, post 90 was on page 4. Go check.)
3.) I think you reacted to them in a way that appeared more scum than town, but nice try twisting it to sound better.

--
The Goat is probably town, and the votes on him are stupid. I feel like he would be a lot more appeasing in this situation if he were scum. He admitted to having skimmed the thread before voting when he could have just said he saw the thread was up and just quickly voted before dinner because he remembered that's what you're supposed to do in post 230. I also think the way he explains that people's problem with his late random vote is "[their] problem, not [his]" like in post 275 reads as more townish in this situation too, for the same reason.

mastin and Ms Marangal can be scum. Would definitely vote them.

ANG still reads as scum for the reasons I've previously stated, and I don't like the way he's continued only focusing on his attackers and responding to direct questions. In post 181 he states that GIF and I could be scum on his wagon, but offers absolutely no insight into his thoughts there. I would write something about the hypocrisy there, but it's self-evident so etc.

Oh and Nero, what do you think of Ms Marangal and DGB?