Calvin and Hobbes Mafia(GAME OVER! Grownups Mafia Wins!)

Yates · Post Post #1675 (isolation #0) » Mon Jul 15, 2013 5:23 am

67 pages and haven't read 1.

TL/DR?

Yates · Post Post #1676 (isolation #1) » Mon Jul 15, 2013 5:27 am

Is this a bad time to claim Doc?

Yates · Post Post #1680 (isolation #2) » Mon Jul 15, 2013 5:53 am

Psyche - how many doctors do you think there are in this game??

Yates · Post Post #1682 (isolation #3) » Mon Jul 15, 2013 6:14 am

In post 1681, Psyche wrote:I was pretty confident that there was only one considering conventional setups and how balanced I've been assured this game is.

I was thinking the same thing, hence my concern regarding your claim...

Yates · Post Post #1684 (isolation #4) » Mon Jul 15, 2013 6:23 am

Who says Hobbes is in the game - or that he's Town aligned? He's NOT REAL. Like your claim.

Yates · Post Post #1686 (isolation #5) » Mon Jul 15, 2013 6:29 am

I was in Ghostbusters Mafia with no Peter or Ray so...???

To answer your question, I know you are trying to out the real cop. Maybe I was bluffing?

Yates · Post Post #1687 (isolation #6) » Mon Jul 15, 2013 6:30 am

Real DOC I meant.

Yates · Post Post #1690 (isolation #7) » Mon Jul 15, 2013 6:40 am

In post 1688, Psyche wrote:What have you got Yates?

A cup full of seltzer and a screen full of empty promises?

Yates · Post Post #1718 (isolation #8) » Mon Jul 15, 2013 3:24 pm

In post 1706, Nobody Special wrote:Yates, now what?

In post 1682, Yates wrote:
In post 1681, Psyche wrote:I was pretty confident that there was only one considering conventional setups and how balanced I've been assured this game is.
I was thinking the same thing, hence my
concern regarding your claim
...

In post 1683, Psyche wrote:
Are you a doctor or not??

I still have my Hobbes claim.

In post 1684, Yates wrote:Who says Hobbes is in the game - or that he's Town aligned?
He's NOT REAL. Like your claim
.

In post 1685, Psyche wrote:
Answer the question
.

Hobbes is the second most important character in the entire theme of course he's in the game and real.

In post 1686, Yates wrote:I was in Ghostbusters Mafia with no Peter or Ray so...???

To answer your question, I know you are trying to out the real doc.
Maybe I was bluffing?

In post 1688, Psyche wrote:It's a cruel world out there, and hard to find a good friend. In a world of bullies and bedtimes, I'm Calvin's constant companion. I rarely leave Calvin's side, so I am the town doctor. As a night action, I get to protect a player and protect them from death that night.

^ flavor paraphrasing

What have you got Yates?

In post 1690, Yates wrote:
In post 1688, Psyche wrote:What have you got Yates?

A cup full of seltzer and a screen full of empty promises?

The cup full of seltzer thing is where I conceded he was probably the real doc. I didn't expect it to take that long and he shouldn't have needed to quote his PM, obviously. But...

In post 1699, Rubicon wrote:Psyche, why aren't you voting Yates?

That pinged me immediately. So I had to keep pressing. You would think he would vote me for counterclaiming, but he didn't. Also, he seemed very soft in his defense when I asked him how many doctors he thought is in the game.

*shrug*

The claim was out, I wanted to vet him.

Yates · Post Post #1720 (isolation #9) » Mon Jul 15, 2013 3:47 pm

In post 1716, Rubicon wrote:I mean, the reason the rule exists is because when you quote the role PM it makes it obvious you're telling the truth.
That was my immediate reaction when Psyche did it
- that sounded way too much like Monkey's writing to have been something Psyche made up.

So why point it out? What's the Town motivation in wanting the Doc modkilled?

Yates · Mon Jul 15, 2013 11:56 pm

In post 1729, Skullduggery wrote:I'd rather just lynch Scum first and sort out the details later.

This. And Town Penguin would agree. I think. Let me do some meta checking...

Yates · Mon Jul 15, 2013 11:57 pm

Also as to this point:

In post 1727, penguin_alien wrote:Yates-MS hasn't done anything to be a town read.

I verified the Town Doc wasn't fake claiming!

Yates · Post Post #1733 (isolation #12) » Tue Jul 16, 2013 2:56 am

In post 1732, penguin_alien wrote:when I was part of the larger surviving scum team in this situation I was screaming for us to attempt to lynch the likely last other team scum.

I had a feeling. So why maintain this attitude if you are Town? Why care which team you are shooting for?

In post 1732, penguin_alien wrote:Yates, sure, you pressured the town doc...

That was tongue-in-cheek given I "mod confirmed" his alignment when he quoted his role pm as a response to my claim pressure.

Yates · Post Post #1738 (isolation #13) » Tue Jul 16, 2013 6:19 am

I'm taking Vars off your list...
I'll trust Penguin's read on Skull [even though she had that terrible "bah post" after the modkill]

In post 1735, TiphaineDeath wrote:Skullduggery
T S O
EddieFenix
Nobody Special
Dante

There are four scum in EF-NS-TSO-Dante-Skull. More information inc.

Screw it.
VOTE: Nobody Special

Don't like the voting pattern. Don't like the way HE handled the doc claim. Don't like that he volunteered the "scum cop" scenario. Yeah. He can be our scum kill today.

Yates · Post Post #1742 (isolation #14) » Tue Jul 16, 2013 6:49 am

In post 1739, TiphaineDeath wrote:Hey yates, if NS flips scum would you think there is or is not a real scum doctor?

I'm not going to design my game around the

potential existence

of a scum doctor. So I don't really care. Essentially, I just think he was trying to put the doc claim into question [scummy] more so than to attempt to ascertain the truth value of the claim itself [townie]. Does that answer your question?

Yates · Post Post #1743 (isolation #15) » Tue Jul 16, 2013 6:51 am

In post 1741, Dante wrote:Having to chose one:

Vote Nobody Special

That's a good vote. If he flips Town, though, I'm voting you tomorrow. Just fair warning. So get your things in order.

Yates · Post Post #1745 (isolation #16) » Tue Jul 16, 2013 7:11 am

Hey Tip - come join us on the NS wagon. The Varsoom train isn't going to leave the station and he's on your short list.

Yates · Post Post #1764 (isolation #17) » Tue Jul 16, 2013 9:10 am

In post 1750, Rubicon wrote:Predict remaining scum is in this group:

EddieFenix

TiphaineDeath

Nobody Special

penguin_alien

I could do either of the bolded. I'm on NS right now. I didn't look as deeply into Eddie's ISO as I did NS so my vote went to NS. NS seems to be more of a universal scum read anyway. Everyone seems to have him in their top 3 so... Yeah. Let's lynch NS.

Yates · Post Post #1768 (isolation #18) » Tue Jul 16, 2013 9:54 am

In post 1767, T S O wrote:
In post 1743, Yates wrote:
In post 1741, Dante wrote:Having to chose one:

Vote Nobody Special
That's a good vote. If he flips Town, though, I'm voting you tomorrow. Just fair warning. So get your things in order.
Nah, we'll get Eddie tomorrow.

I'm sorry, do you have a dog in this fight? Did not realize...

Yates · Tue Jul 16, 2013 11:19 am

In post 1771, TiphaineDeath wrote:...if only I could shake this feeling that NS is town.

Try this - why is NS Town? If you go back and you can't make a case for NS-Town then he isn't Town. It's that easy.

Yates · Tue Jul 16, 2013 11:21 am

Also, note that he hasn't really addressed me outside of asking me "what next" after the modkill despite being the main proponent of the NS lynch. Does that not strike you as odd? Town NS would be giving me the business. Scum NS is waiting to see if everyone else is going to buy it before determining how hard to defend.

Yates · Post Post #1801 (isolation #21) » Wed Jul 17, 2013 5:18 am

In post 1797, Varsoon wrote:@TSO: Probably isn't a good strategy to subtly suggest you are on a scum-team with NS...

Yeah. This pinged hard. I can move my vote to TSO.

VOTE: TSO

Yates · Post Post #1806 (isolation #22) » Wed Jul 17, 2013 6:27 am

In post 1803, Dante wrote:Your posting style has pinged hard as well. Metal Sonic played like bored scum...you play with an agenda. Could see a Yates, Rubicon, NS scum team.

Why don't you just bus your buddy and we can have this conversation tomorrow.

Yates · Post Post #1815 (isolation #23) » Wed Jul 17, 2013 8:31 am

In post 1809, Rubicon wrote: Yates, why do you want to lynch T S O now?

My NS wagon never left the station. I feel better about NS scum but the TSO wagon seems legit and obviously has far more traction.

Yates · Post Post #1820 (isolation #24) » Wed Jul 17, 2013 9:34 am

In post 1816, T S O wrote:you know I looked through Nobody Special's ISO

and I really wanted to make a strong Town case on him.

but I just can't. I'm sorry. It doesn't exist. His posting through the game gave me a "disinterested Town" vibe but his ISO is nearly the opposite of this.

I would actually understand if you guys lynched me, not because I'm scummy, but my play has been sub-par here.

I agree with you. NS will be my target tomorrow.

Yates · Post Post #1866 (isolation #25) » Sun Jul 21, 2013 4:31 am

I'm

GIGANTIC CALVIN

- VT.

When I don't want to do my homework I have daydreams where I become a giant.

Yates · Post Post #1867 (isolation #26) » Sun Jul 21, 2013 4:34 am

Also, I was right about NS-scum and pushed that case hard. So suck it, Varsoon. On the flip side, you have a good point about PA. Scum typically get safe claims. And "Invisible Calvin" doesn't sound like a character claim someone would fake out of the blue.

VOTE: penguin_alien for overplaying her fake counter claim. Nice try.

Yates · Post Post #1869 (isolation #27) » Sun Jul 21, 2013 9:42 am

In post 1868, penguin_alien wrote:You've played with me plenty; is such a move anywhere near consistent with my play style?

I have played with you plenty. You're one of my favorite scummers. I don't recall ever playing with scum-PA, though. So I can't guess what you would do as scum. My hunch about your move has to do with the fact we are in LYLO. All you need is one mislynch to win.

Riddle me this: why were you so reluctant to join the NS wagon with me yesterday? You claimed to have him as one of your top scum reads and yet....

Yates · Post Post #1870 (isolation #28) » Sun Jul 21, 2013 9:45 am

In post 1868, penguin_alien wrote:Unvote, unless you're scum.

Also, why are you worried about a single vote?