It is true that these players don't always get lynched but they almost always arouse suspicion. It is the same for prickly, or spiky as Maggie Smith puts it, players like Thor, LlamaFluff, and Magua. They are often not lynched but they do arouse their fair share of suspicion for being generally more antagonistic than average.
It is a trait I've noticed in my own lynches. When I talk down or insult the town, I more often get mislynched. When I appease to them, acting nice in the process, they mislynch me less.
But I do have to say, yelling at the town is cathartic.
