Newbie 1419 - GAME OVER

[mail-mi]

VOTE: vote: mail-mi
Come on guize! Wagon on him! He is scum!

[mail-mi]

VOTE: vote: mail-mi
Come on guize! Wagon on him! He is scum!

Curious.

What? He's a scummy guy! Wagon on mail-mi!VOTE: mail-mi

[mail-mi]

@mail-mil, this appears to be your first game. Self-voting is generally frowned upon, especially in newbie games.

It got people talking, no? I have played in a multitude of other games on another forum. I know the works.

That said, UNVOTE: mail-mi.

[mail-mi]

@mail-mil, My apologies. I assumed a lot due to the join date. What site did you play on? Links please.

Given the fact you have played before, this tells me you like to gambit and that makes you dangerous (note dangerous =/= scummy).

http://forum.dominionstrategy.com/index.php?board=40.0

Also, if you have any assumptions regarding jailors and roleblockers, mention them now. When I came here, assuming the wrong things greatly derailed my first scum game as jkmatthews can attest.

I've played with them before, roleblockers block the Night Action of the person they target, and jailkeepers roleblock and doc at the same time.

[mail-mi]

Nah, I like lettersgaiden



Mai, get an avatar please. It makes it easier to distinguish between people

We have several people yet to post. wooo.

Done.

[mail-mi]

@mail, how often do you use that self vote at the start of the game? i'd like to hear some more about why you decided to go with it. considering jkm and titus are discussing it, i'd like to hear more before i make my own decision.

Not ever, I think. It felt like a good thing to get the game going, and look it did.

[mail-mi]

@Mail-mil, not everyone gets notice if they are roleblocked and jailors don't remove and create their own night chat. Jailors don't execute either. Your site requires a log in btw.

We need to get out of RVS and I suppose M-M's gambit got the game going. I have him as a slight townread for now.

Oh yeah sorry about that. The ready of the forum (where we talk about the game Dominion) is accessible though. Only members can access the forum games. forum.dominionstrategy.com

[mail-mi]

Generally, it is better if we ate all straight up. Sometimes gambits and withholding information are essential.

@notscience, please put jkm's thought into your own words. I am beginning to get suspicious that your vote was opportunistic and you wanted someone to make your case.

why do you think withholding information is essential?

also could you remind me why you think mail's self vote was pro town? youve mentioned that scum wouldn't have pulled that move whereas i can't think why a townie would either.

Would scum want to get the game moving, or keep it in (almost useless) RVS?

[mail-mi]

You know, this argument is as follows "Would scum really try to move RVS? Clearly no. Thus anyone who promotes RVS must be town." I really hate circular logic.

What I'm saying is scum would usually just go with the flow and end with RVS when it ends, but not actively enforce it or stop it.

[mail-mi]

i have more of a scum vibe from mail currently; if we assume that he knows what he's doing (as per his comments regarding other games he's played in), and we assume that he is town, his actions just don't make sense to me.

Do they make sense from a scum perspective?

Answer this please, verbs.

[mail-mi]

I'm sorry but I am too busy for this right now I have to /out. Sorry!