Open 527 - Hard Boiled: Dixon Hill's Maudlin Madness

[BROseidon]

Woohoo 6 pages already let’s do this.

I'm claiming now
I'm a VT
Anyone else who claims VT is added to my townblock
I love this playerlist

Second time I’ve seen this reaction test. Let’s see how it goes.

NS’s reaction probably null given that it’s NS.

Don’t like SD’s or Eagle’s reaction.

Seriously considering a policy lynch on all hydras.

This line is important if Eagle is scum. Gonna keep that here so I can look back to it later.

DP that doesn't matter, only scum push PLs. Vote Eagle.

Going to come back to this in a minute, but you’re not looking at the context.

I'm heading to the beach shortly. Will catch up by phone once in a while today.

Care to explain the wagon on me?
Help out a poor guy who is confused.

Will get to this in a minute.

Light townread on notscience thus far and a light scumread on baldy. In other news I am considering attempting to metashift with this game, though I doubt I would actually succeed and would probably revert to my old ways within a few posts. I would really love to not get lynched this game, win or lose.

This bothers me.

7. BROseidon CHECK

We have no completed games together. It’s strange that you’d know that I’ve read a few of your games that I haven’t been in.

You guys are all out to lynch me... What else was I supposed to say?

There were much better ways to handle the situation.

Okay, done with catching up. The reason why the Eagle wagon was only meh despite the fact that he responded really badly to TIP’s reaction test is that he’s new. In my first game on site, I “fell” for the exact same reaction test as a town PR, and the first real wagon of the game was on me as a result. Granted, I was able to shake it without claiming my PR, and Eagle’s reaction to his wagon was meh, but that is probably largely indicative of him being new. Before I started playing with spammy posters, my town-self had a lot of similar views (fluff=scum, etc).

TIP is my only townread with anything behind it. Very slight scumreads on SD, Ceph, and Eagle. Everything else is null.

[BROseidon]

I'm not convinced. You're picking up on a lot of newb-tells.

[BROseidon]

@VS: Why should Hider claim?

This.

Also, there's another reason that you shouldn't townread me for the newbtell point: ffery and Nacho were both in the game where I did the same thing and would probably call me out if I tried to attack Eagle for it.

[BROseidon]

What about the hider getting to pre-crumb their target to hide behind scum?

[BROseidon]

Wait.

Tracker can track the hider? I thought it would just fizzle. Apparently my understanding of PR order is wrong >.>

[BROseidon]

Hider do not claim

DO

NOT

CLAIM

As long as people are CAREFUL around L-1's it's fine.

But you're going for a breaking mechanism which is BS

The fact DP isn't here contesting it is bugging me

Pedit ALSO MARA IM OBVTOWN AND YOU HAVE ME AS PROBS WTF

...Breaking open setups is part of playing an open setup. If you don't like using gamestate to your advantage day 1, don't play opens. Hider should claim.

[BROseidon]

I'm not sure he's even null, given what he's capable of as town.

>:C Stop setting unreasonable expectations for me.

Catching up now. Been absent from this game the past few days >.>

[BROseidon]

Hydra dissonance of DP re: NS is annoying. Both people chainsawing are un-cc'd PRs. That looks bad for DP. His argument is blegh.

I want to see a lot more from TF and SoS today. We're not lynching anyone yet.

Why these two specifically?

I may need to look at Xenoblade or whatever it is.

You mean that game where ffery was scum and spammed up the thread to the point that her hydra had the most posts until day 7 or 8 despite having been lynched day 1?

She had a lot to say.

The CS/VS interaction goes entirely over my head.

Mac shouldn't release reads. Make it easier to scum to counter what he's thinking and makes him more killable. x.x

This. Like, Mac shouldn't post reads and nobody should try to direct him so that scum are in as bad a position as possible for catching him out.

i'm seriously loving this avatar but syr and cabd didn't like it that much, which makes me seriously seriously sad.

The avatar is great, you should keep it.

BRO's open is pretty solid. I like his stance on TiP's claim in particular.

Why did you like it, given the context of you, ffery, mala, and mara all being in this game when noobtown-me got baited by it?

Good read on me Nati

10/10

welcome to the scumreads with Mac as well

>:C

Can you try acting like town if you're town and scumhunt? Be useful? Anything?

I make people defy their preconceptions about town

What, that town play in such a way that they demonstrate a town interest?

When I'm scum I play more protown

Not even joking

Nat's last reads list is very scummy, which negates our initial townread, we agreed on this.

What about his reads list is scummy?

Not sure NS and SD make sense as scum together.

I don't think they do.

My expectations are quite reasonable.

I don't like this pressure

[BROseidon]

Also I would be voting NS right now except I don't know what he's at in terms of votes and don't want to accidentally hammer like a derp.

He's done literally nothing but spam up the thread, and I trust Mac and GiF here (former is conf-town, latter is a strong townread)

[BROseidon]

This is not really a scum or a town tell for him. I gathered some meta analysis a while ago on him. He's not really following either meta on what I have on him.

I'm not townreading NS, so I'm willing to defer to other townreads on sorting him.

Care to make a case on why he's town so I don't put him at L-1?

[BROseidon]

Because I've played with them several times and am used to them being more proactive.

Are you referring specifically to the Nacho/ffery heads of these hydras, or are you including Cabd/GiF in this?

[BROseidon]

BRO, what's your Cephrir read?

Null/null-town right now.

[BROseidon]

? Hider dies if they hide behind scum as well I thought?

It's funny that you point this out. Because he hid behind you.

VOTE: Natirasha

[BROseidon]

I'm sold.

VOTE: BRO

10/10

[BROseidon]

VOTE: nat

Just in case.

See you on the other side Bro!

I was looking forward to playing with this group of players too

Oh well, at least I did my job.

[BROseidon]

Thanks for the carry Tammy. You played a sick game.

Btw after I died I thought of a better way at breaking the setup that would have allowed me to have not had to claim if Mac hid behind scum night 1. Makes me want to play again and not roll scum so I can use it.

Also lol @ Mara hoping tracker/vig wouldn't pick Vig. Picking Vig is pretty much outright wrong, imo.

[BROseidon]

Also lol @ Mara thinking I would be an easy enough mislynch target ^_^

[BROseidon]

Good thing you died, then ^_^

[BROseidon]

In my first game on site, I “fell” for the exact same reaction test as a town PR, and the first real wagon of the game was on me as a result.
I don't think BRO is PR.

Wait.

Tracker can track the hider? I thought it would just fizzle. Apparently my understanding of PR order is wrong >.>

awkward, noting.

[BROseidon]

Not enough l's and o's.

[BROseidon]

Just saying you and Mara should really work on that hydra dissonance if you hydra again, Jiffy. I think you guys made a mistake killing SoS over Cait Sith night 3 though.

CS was lynchable. SoS was not.

You know who was more lynchable?

Any non-PR other than those two.

[BROseidon]

No. Bert wasn't getting lynched. Neither was TIP or Ceph.

Except for the part where TIP would have lynched Ceph...