Newbie 1433 - Game Over

[Klick]

Sup guys. I'll make a post when I get home.

[Klick]

Just based on the posts so far in Day 3:

- Nominull is probably town. He spent time (from 1:33 to 2:04 PM CDT) thinking about the game, and posted his thoughts. I think this shows that he had just now started to consider the meaning of the Peabody kill, instead of already having thought about it during the Night.

- Along the same line, SHY is a slight scumread. His Post #892 looks kinda fake to me.

If I had to call the scum right now, it'd be SHY/Fuzzy.

[Klick]

I would replace out because I'm finding it difficult to make time to post here, but this game really doesn't need a replacement.

I'm going to devout some serious time to this tonight. Promise.

[Klick]

While I can say that I still haven't found the time to sit down and read the game fully through from the beginning, I can also say that from what I have read, Fuzzy seems very obviously scum to me. Especially due to his last post - he's claiming that I have the town's fate in my hands; if I'm scum, that's not necessarily the case. I think Fuzzy is scum making a logic jump and claiming that I'm town.

I think Satan is the other scum, but I feel pretty confident about Fuzzy.

PEdit: No need to have an attitude about it. I've had a rough, busy week, and I haven't been able to due much due to actual life.

[Klick]

Theoretically, if I was scum, couldn't I just stall the game out to scum's advantage? In Post #941, you are only assuming that I am Town.

PEdit: That's the thing. I currently don't have the time to sit down and do a full read, and since I was asked to do that, I was unable to deliver for days.

[Klick]

And, to answer Ree:

TOWN
Nominull
Satan/Ree

Fuzzy
SCUM

[Klick]

Okay, no.

"Satan's probably scum"
"Eh, I don't like how Klick is playing..."

*Nom votes Fuzzy*

"Well, Nom might be scum, and I was sure that Satan was scum, but now that Nom might be scum... *votes Klick*"

Fuzzy, if you're still online: Why did you vote for me over Satan, or Nom, the person who's voting you?

I'll give you thirty minutes. If you haven't responded by then, I'm going to go ahead and vote.

[Klick]

VOTE: Fuzzy

[Klick]

So, uh, explain why that's scummy?

You pretty much just claimed scum. First of all, you didn't respond to the actual question posed to you. Second, you're now grasping at straws and making assumptions based on no real evidence, without me being confirmed scum to you.

[Klick]

lol. I'm going to rip this apart.

Hmm..you have been MIA almost all game than all of the sudden when we get to get a critical moment in the game you decide..hey Im going to be really active now..... I find that a bit funny.

I posted three posts. That's not "really active."

You vote at best is a OMGUS vote however I have have a gut feeling you did it bc you saw Noms vote as an opportunity.

Or it could be the reasoning in the post before I voted for you?

Why should i not believe this is the case when your case is that I am scum is based on very little evidence or reason/.

Is this not the same with you? You voted me before I voted you.

You give me 30 minutes to respond. If you were serious about getting good reads you would of given me more time.

I didn't need to give you time at all. Furthermore, you didn't let me respond to you before voting for me.

we have another day.and a half.... I dont see how a few hours for me to try to give a response to your post is asking to much.

Again, you did the exact same to me. It's hypocritical.

You just sheep people. Nom was focused on me so what do you do, you come up with a weak case based on one comment and declare it was scummy. Than when Nom votes for me you come and vote for me with no real reason or evidence.

You still never actually responded to the post. It was scummy enough to warrant a vote on its own. My vote doesn't really have anything to do with Nom's vote.

I have thought you possible scum all day and if you have read the posts you would of known that.

Same here?

and by what proof do you have I am scum..I have more respect for Noms theory atleast it has plausibility and tries to give some prrof how I am scum while you just seem to be throwing out accusation

See Post #970. I also ask you the same, and repeat the question in said post.

PEdit: Here's a case for you. You said you were "sure" that Satan was scum. However, you had pretty much a null read on me until someone made a comment that I was lurking. Then, you said that you thought I *might* be scum lurking. Then, when

I

brought up the fact that I wasn't just trying to stall out the deadline, you suggested exactly that, but still made it seem like you thought Satan was scummier. When Nom votes you, you show slight suspicion of him, comment that you were "sure" that Satan was scum, and mention the lurking thing about me again... and then vote for me. You really didn't have much reasoning at all, and it seems to be in response to Nom voting for you instead of because you already wanted to vote for me. Furthermore, you didn't make (and still haven't made) any attempt to try and get either of our votes off of you, but still insist that there's no reason to vote for Nom after he voted for you. Now, you're accusing me of being really obviously scum while having very poor reasoning - and that's part of your case against me.

[Klick]

UNVOTE:

VOTE: Satan

[Klick]

Satan, please unvote. Regardless of how confident you are, you shouldn't vote right away in LyLo.

I'm pretty sure that Satan is scum, but I'm going to reread Fuzzy in isolation with both of you.

[Klick]

Because Ree still has a possibility of being scum, and if he is, you're letting him hammer me before I get a chance to post what I find. And I may find something that leads to the conclusion that he's scum.

[Klick]

Actually, I'm wrong. Ree's totally confirmed town. He and Fuzzy were online and conversing while I had my vote on you.

VOTE: Satan

[Klick]

It actually looked really genuine. I hadn't gone into the details of it enough to see the slip, but I had a hard time believing it was fake.

[Klick]

I posted my vote switch before going to sleep. Flip happened at 7:05 while I was getting ready for school.

[Klick]

I'm here.

Ree, I'd rather you vote based on suspicion and not based on Satan making a poor decision. You said yourself that there's a good possibility that Satan is scum anyway. Rather than hammering me regardless, I'd like you to consider the possibility that Satan didn't think about stalling the deadline out when making your vote.

I'm pretty much ready for a hammer.

[Klick]

I mean yesterday.

[Klick]

No, I'm saying that it's possible that you didn't think of letting the deadline running out as a viable strategy.

[Klick]

We had barely any time left, and he was the only player with any significant scumminess to him that I could see, and his Post 967 was that scummy. And, I already explained the vote switch when asked earlier:

It actually looked really genuine. I hadn't gone into the details of it enough to see the slip, but I had a hard time believing it was fake.

[Klick]

If you came into the day with that mindset and were unwilling to let go of it, I suggest that you go ahead and vote me.

[Klick]

Aww man I just got home.

Good job

[Klick]

Well, I'll put it this way...

[Klick]

Nope, I'm actually town.