Open 581: Making Friends and Enemies! (Game over)

CptPicard · Post Post #813 (isolation #0) » Fri Jan 16, 2015 2:01 am

↑ davesaz wrote:Wonder if CptPicard actually picked up the role.

I'm here, sorry about my absence - I'm reading my way through the thread now - I'm on page 11 of 33. I'll post my thoughts as soon as I've caught up.

CptPicard · Post Post #831 (isolation #1) » Sun Jan 18, 2015 1:36 pm

Hey guys. So to make sure I'm caught up now, the losses so far are a townie and a mason?

If I make any mistakes, please let me know, as this is one of my first mafia games. I replaced into both this game and a newbie game, so I'll try to keep everything straight!

CptPicard · Post Post #838 (isolation #2) » Sun Jan 18, 2015 2:00 pm

↑ Grib wrote:Picard, what are your general reads on everyone?

Townlean - Green Crayons, Mala (my opinion is mostly based on awesomeusername's posts)
Null - Corpses/Heartless, Dave, Elle, Grib (named by NJAC as scummy before his lynching...but he was a non-info role), Lone Ranger, WIS
Scumlean - Kaboose, Riddle

My reads are not set in stone by any means, they are primarily judged by everyone's interactions with each other.

I plan to re-read all of the posts soon with a better eye for detail, in order to improve my reads.

CptPicard · Post Post #845 (isolation #3) » Sun Jan 18, 2015 2:35 pm

↑ Green Crayons wrote:
@Picard:
I'd be interested in the basis for your Kaboose and Riddle reads.

I suspect Riddle due to his dodging answering to suspicions in the early parts in the thread. "What merit is there for me to respond to Fairies' suspicions against me?" "Why do I need to defend myself and argue her scumread on me?" It seems that if you were town, you'd want to reply to any suspicions against you to prevent your teammates from voting for you and making a mistake.

I'm not nearly as confident on my read of Kaboose, but despite being here since the very beginning of the game, he has seemingly stayed in the background, not saying a whole lot - which implies to me that maybe he has something to hide, and he's trying not to tip his hand. I really hope to see more from him in this coming 'day' to see how my read changes.

When I go back and re-read the thread soon, I'm hoping more details will jump out at me, and allow me to help move more of my nulls to one pile or the other.