You could be Anyone IV - GAME OVER

[PeregrineV]

/confirm

[PeregrineV]

Will read today.

Vote: Aunt Jemima

Missed you!

[PeregrineV]

VOTE: PeregrineV.
This is not a serious vote.

I propose we--aw, who am I kidding.

Yes!

I feel the love!!

[PeregrineV]

I should probably make my way through the 20+ pages, and I think I will, but for now I'm selling my vote to the first person to request it. Be like a jump start, perhaps.

[PeregrineV]

I should probably make my way through the 20+ pages, and I think I will, but for now I'm selling my vote to the first person to request it. Be like a jump start, perhaps.

Vote Elyse please

We have a winner!

Vote: Elyse

[PeregrineV]

I should probably make my way through the 20+ pages, and I think I will, but for now I'm selling my vote to the first person to request it. Be like a jump start, perhaps.

I request you to vote Klingoncelt.

Birds of Prey for the win.

Hmmm, a counterproposal.

I'll start reading with these.

[PeregrineV]

Unvote:

Sorry, I started reading and it turned to skmming then to scrolling.

Thinking I'll just start over.

[PeregrineV]

I haven't read anything but I see spifflop votes and when I come back tonight those shitty votes better get off Spiff and on Kling. Spiff is the towniest town that ever towned.

Too good to pass up.

Vote: Spifflop

[PeregrineV]

Monday post- no prod needed.

[PeregrineV]

VOTE: Errantparabola

Man of action.

Vote: Errantparabola

Also,already told Jason,but

Limited Access through Jan5. Will try to post daily.

[PeregrineV]

My activity is my vote today.

Vote: Alchemist

[PeregrineV]

Dropping in for Monday post. Read this page, and kind of looked at Gwen's ISO for cluse to who she may have hid behind on night2, but her biggest suspect (Dapper) was lynched day2.

[PeregrineV]

@Stormy: A reread of Alch wouldn't hurt. I know I haven't gotten much from his play. You might be able to see things I can't.

this post says, and i quote

"I will be hiding behind alchemist tonight"

It could have been more clear IMO, but it's a start.

Vote: Alchemist

[PeregrineV]

That's getting nominated for Kodak Moment, Peregrine. That is so fucking rich.

So you do or do not think she hid behind scum on night2?

[PeregrineV]

Well, consider the facts, Peregrine. Either she hid behind scum, or her death was the result of a tinfoil hat-style conspiracy where the person she believed was scum was actually targeted by a Doctor and was also the target of the nightkill.

Then considering she is not a blithering idiot, she crumbed, in some manner, her target for the night. If it's not alchemist, then who is it?

[PeregrineV]

Well, consider the facts, Peregrine. Either she hid behind scum, or her death was the result of a tinfoil hat-style conspiracy where the person she believed was scum was actually targeted by a Doctor and was also the target of the nightkill.

Then considering she is not a blithering idiot, she crumbed, in some manner, her target for the night. If it's not alchemist, then who is it?

Nevermind. I should do more reading....

[PeregrineV]

I doubt you forgot.

Awww, thanks for the vote of confidense.

But you would be wrong.

[PeregrineV]

Jason

If a hider hid behind a person who was targeted for the night kill and the person she hid behind was doc protected, what would happen to the hider?

I think this will answer it.

[PeregrineV]

not really?

her kill flavor isnt "i died because i found scum"

so if she did hide, smart money is on it being behind alch, who would then be conftown if we hadnt already lynched him.

i think theres no value here.

Final word from Jason will confirm, but I think it's some form of this.

[PeregrineV]

reading gwen ISO

Her top scumreads other than dapper were

Random,Anen and Eagle

She said that anen can be sorted later so we can strike him out I think.

Any chance he hid behind eagle or random?

Your better off quoting the posts.

[PeregrineV]

There's so much wifom with the hider claim unless someone finds a crumb on who she his behind we should lynch scum aka eagle I have the best case on him out of any cases present today. Also his a common scu m 4ead but always side lined. We should of lynched him before but you guys were like nooo

what about 2944?

[PeregrineV]

PV talk to me. How about lynching errant today?

I'll look at him tomorrow.

[PeregrineV]

PV talk to me. How about lynching errant today?

I'll look at him tomorrow.

He gave a reads list earlier, which I like. Glanced at day1 stuff, but not drawing any conclusions from it.

ISOed Klingon and Errant together. Some back and forth, but didn't seem overly adversarial.

However, Errant did hammer Klingon with 9 days left in the day. And didn't seem to try to gain any towncredit from the hammer or the flip.

Probably not my first choice for lynch today.

[PeregrineV]

On page 120

[PeregrineV]

Mmm. Look at his interest in the Elyse wagon when Klingon becomes viable lynch. And then his sudden forgetting of the topic. Also watch how is reads on people flip back and forth literally from post to post.

He seems to mostly have a townread on Elyse that matches yours. Other than a post or to, it doesn't seem like much disagreement between you two.

And flipflopping on people is, recently and unfortunately, pretty often town behavior.

Unless you got specifics, still not my first choice for lynch today.

(Who is, you ask, if you haven't yet?)

Not sure. Want to actually ISO Kling for leads, but need to finish this close week.

[PeregrineV]

Invalidate my premises, and my confidence wanes.

Yup. I still think scum piled on Spifflop and itlepipitlepip and alchemist. EE fits that bill.

PV also fits due to vote pattern.

Is this like the third random jab for the third random reason?

@Jason, If a Hider hides behind a Mafia Godfather, and assuming no other action on the Hider or GF, will the Hider die?

[PeregrineV]

@TSO

- Currently thinking that Eagle doesn't seem like scum. I saw your giant post on it, and will have to go back and analyze and argue before I vote for him.

[PeregrineV]

Invalidate my premises, and my confidence wanes.

Yup. I still think scum piled on Spifflop and itlepipitlepip and alchemist. EE fits that bill.

PV also fits due to vote pattern.

Is this like the third random jab for the third random reason?

@Jason, If a Hider hides behind a Mafia Godfather, and assuming no other action on the Hider or GF, will the Hider die?

Hiding behind any mafia, regardless of their role will result in death, as well as leave the hider open to night actions.

@Jason- thx!

@PS- Talk to me if you want a response. Or not.

[PeregrineV]

Prodded. Sorry for the delay, I thought I was here before.

[PeregrineV]

What's the short version case for Eagle scum? because I'm not feeling it.

[PeregrineV]

How well do you think you've read the game?

It could be better. Not allergic to digging, just would rather know what kind of treasure you think is there.

[PeregrineV]

See, Peregrine, there are people calling for your vig. I'd prefer ZZZX to be vigged, since I think AJ can read you well, and she said you were town. I myself have practically no reason to believe it, but it's better than none. I don't expect groundbreaking content, but I just think you should try to do ...something, so that the vig can compare that to ZZZX-slot, which has had two players doing nothing, and shoot the latter.

I'm only mildly interested in not being vigged, but I get your point. I'll try to do some researching this week.

[PeregrineV]

Dropping by- I'm off tommorrow but may have to work anyway. Either see you tommorow or Tuesday.

[PeregrineV]

also pv is like pretty obviously scum i think.

so like he should start our mass claim probably?

I'm not, but will start.

I'm VT.

[PeregrineV]

I haven't been following the game as closely as I like, but I've been mostly skimming and come to these conclusions.

TSO is town
Varsoon is the SK
XXZZY is scum

Vote: XXZZY

[PeregrineV]

im a cop.

i have innocents on
mohis
errant
varsoon

Can you go over briefly why you picked each player to investigate?

[PeregrineV]

I haven't been following the game as closely as I like, but I've been mostly skimming and come to these conclusions.
TSO is town
Varsoon is the SK
XXZZY is scum

Vote: XXZZY

UNVOTE:
VOTE: PeregrineV
Because of
(1) picking a couple of names without any logic (why eg. Garmr, Elyse or me not there?)

I can later give more opinions on people that I have less of an opinion on.
Early are slight-town, slight-town, and none

(2) giving no reasons

As if to indicate that if I do give reasons, it adds legitimacy?
I mostly do, but probably not this game. unless I need to.

(3) sheeping my vote and it's clear that I'm not the one here who's worth being sheeped

I guess I'll distinguish for you. I'm voting the same person (or was). But, since my reasons are not your reasons, it's not a sheep, now is it?

(4) misspelling ZZZX, although his name was spelt correctly in the vote above.

I would only know it was spelt correctly if I researched the correct spelling. You could have spelled it wrong.
Why would this be an issue to you?

[PeregrineV]

im a cop.

i have innocents on
mohis
errant
varsoon

Can you go over briefly why you picked each player to investigate?

i could.

im not going to.

but i could.

OK.

If you do, I'm looking for something beyond, "I thought they might be scum".

You know, in case you do.

[PeregrineV]

I saw TWIE claim cop. Whos the vig?

[PeregrineV]

@TSO

- I see 2 vig shots and a nightly kill, which I would htink would be mafia. Why do you think there is an SK?

[PeregrineV]

See, Peregrine, there are people calling for your vig. I'd prefer ZZZX to be vigged, since I think AJ can read you well, and she said you were town. I myself have practically no reason to believe it, but it's better than none. I don't expect groundbreaking content, but I just think you should try to do ...something, so that the vig can compare that to ZZZX-slot, which has had two players doing nothing, and shoot the latter.

I'm only mildly interested in not being vigged, but I get your point. I'll try to do some researching this week.

I find it impossible to believe that you could quote this post where I tell you that you could be vigged, talk about being vigged, apparently read the whole of d5 which was

almost entirely based around vig claims

, come into d6 and ask me who the vig is, as town.

I picked up there was a vig, but that's about the extent of it.

The itlepip makes more sense as IaI's assassin kill. Either that or 2 scumteams. But, the way Jason does kill flavor, I think that's unlikely.

[PeregrineV]

You aren't this bad, Peregrine.

I think you're trying to exaggerate your badness this game because you know that it's basically the only reason anyone could possibly townread you. Perhaps I'm wrong, but I can't see any obvious answer to #3829 that would suggest otherwise.

It's all a matter of timing.

My badness is (to me) somewhat cyclical.

Townreading me is a rarity, and doesn't really affect how I play (although being confirmed masons really does take wind of my sails, persoanlly).

[PeregrineV]

I can later give more opinions on people that I have less of an opinion on.
Early are slight-town, slight-town, and none

Pigeon poop.

As if to indicate that if I do give reasons, it adds legitimacy?
I mostly do, but probably not this game. unless I need to.

How exactly this helps town?

What do you mean?

If you care about now, I would assume you would ask me.
When I'm dead, you can look back and go "That Peregrine sure (knew his stuff!)/(was sure dumb!)".

I would only know it was spelt correctly if I researched the correct spelling. You could have spelled it wrong.
Why would this be an issue to you?

Whut?
It's a pity that I used the pigeon poop expression above. Compared to that, this is more like Pteranodon Poop.
By the way, once I scumread someone because he misspelled me and I was sure he had been able to spell my name correctly. A pity that I dropped the case. Also, ZZZX is easier to be spelt than me.

lol...ok

I saw TWIE claim cop. Whos the vig?

errant claimed vig

I'm not the most useful player on the field but even I knew about that...

You aren't this bad, Peregrine.

Parrotting this.

We're lynching out of {Garmr, PV, ZZZX} today. I'm not interested in anyone else.

That's a good pool.

OK.

[PeregrineV]

You just flat-out didn't read d5, if this is true. I am attempting to decide whether this is something you could actually do, but... wow. How did you manage that?

You mean the day that started ona Saturday, and ended on Monday, MLK Day?

Pretty simple, really. If I'm not a work, I rarely play. (See sig#2)

[PeregrineV]

I'll post Dead thread, scum topic and night actions, after I make myself a massive chicken dinner

Thanks for the game, Jason!!

Good job scumteam, especially to Elyse and gamr, and to Kling for throwing herself under the bus day1.


Town having that many clears when TWIE outted himself was scary. For the most part, I don't think arguments of false positive's work, so it becomes a matter of NKing them while trying to lynch the active players.

Anyways, fun game, definitely up for your next one.

@Eagle, you did fine. Pretty sure I was up for killing you early on.

[PeregrineV]

I understand why Elyse and yourself are responding negatively. Have you noticed that no one else did, though?

YOu're upset that you got caught. It happens. Get over it.

Split milk. I think I get you are saying you "caught" Garmr and Elyse, but through either the luck of the gods, poor play on your teammates part, and/or brilliant play on their part, they escaped your net.

Learn what went wrong in general and fix it for next time.

Eagle was a lucky mislynch for us. They were very town IMO.