Baaaah↑ Firebringer wrote:I didn't get first post!!!
VOTE: Jeanne11
YOU THIEF!
I should also vote Sir and Guilty lion.
VOTE: Jeanne
Baaaah↑ Firebringer wrote:I didn't get first post!!!
VOTE: Jeanne11
YOU THIEF!
I should also vote Sir and Guilty lion.
But they aren't even here yet!
Surprise and Cake?
This post in particular is disgusting.
Talk to me about your GL read. Why is this a good place for your vote, and why are you not exerting any pressure on the slot?
Jeanne11 wrote:That depends on your perspective. What's rational to one player may not be rational to another. For instance, this
Spoiler: window attack
to one player this might be seen as relatively normal, to other it's suicide. Just like letting myself be killed is suicide.
Ah, gotcha. That's why I didn't get it.
True. Ohay cool.
I haven't gotten a scumvibe off a single one of their posts.
It's not that you changed from your RVS vote that I dislike, it's the way you did it.
I reread their posts and I don't see how their arguments are unreasonable.
NH/BBT/FB all have town motivations. I can see FB/BBT at a TvT easily. Their interactions screamed that to me. NH I think is also clearly town at this point.↑ ɀefiend wrote:↑ Aristophanes wrote:Alright! I have officially caught up on the game!
Reads thus far:
Scum Leans: Cake, ToJam, Zeif
Town Leans: NH, FB, Shadow, BBT
VOTE: Cakey
Would you like to talk about these reads in more detail?
I can understand why you lean scum on SirCakez, although I do not agree. I definitely agree with your scum-lean on tojam. However you are the first person to openly read me as scummy if I'm not mistaken. Please expound.
How are you arriving at NH, Firebringer, and BBT all at town-leans given the current dynamics of the game? Namely, BBT has called out NH, and Firebringer seems to think there is one scum in NH/BBT. Also, given that GuiltyLion is a large part of the current focus with these players, where do you lean on him and why?
It came up in my Ego. I am behind in reading the game and need to set time aside (probably tonight) to rectify that so I can be relevant to the game again.
Because I knew they were sifting a PR from the get go with their "Mom" and "Dad" post signing. I had them as a strong townread because of this and due to their play!↑ Thor665 wrote:↑ Aristophanes wrote:Are we seriously going after another pr!?
Why does them claiming a PR matter in any way at all?
Because that's totally a question the Mod will answer...
Got it.↑ GuiltyLion wrote:↑ GuiltyLion wrote:"giddy to kill a PR"? Where was the giddiness in tojam's posts?
I want Ari to address this. Why did you say choose to say that he was "giddy" to kill a PR?
VOTE: Aristophanes
From what I gather, we either have 2 JK, (yourself and whoever blocked shadow), or yourself and a secondary roleblocker. 3 is too many, as was mentioned. The scum JK would have to have targeted Shadow, which makes little sense to me, as NH was a prime target, and 2 JKs seems unlikely.↑ Firebringer wrote:↑ Aristophanes wrote:I will not support an NH lynch.
This is ridiculous.
VOTE: Shadow
GL, one sec. I gotta find that question again.
You are following Night Hunters logic on this? I don't understand how the mod error confirms anything. Even Shaddowez attitude could be seen as town by using same facts presented in different way.
Right.↑ GuiltyLion wrote:↑ Aristophanes wrote:
That seems like way too much blocking power if it is a regular setup.
So either FB lied, GL is Ascetic, or we are in full multiball.
I don't think FB lies right now. So we need to flip GL and find out wtf is going on here!
Why aren't you considering the equally likely possibility that NH lied? Like they're claiming a tracker with no results that lived into D3
Hmmm
K, I'll be back with that.↑ GuiltyLion wrote:Like try to quote one of their pushes that is clearly town motivated
Why didn't they vote them then and try for a counterwagon?↑ GuiltyLion wrote:
Oh and look, here's a chainsaw against town voting scum
Scum have literally no reason to avoid my wagon.↑ GuiltyLion wrote:
Would this change your read? What new information does this bring?
I think the game is stalling because scum is avoiding the Aristo wagon. If he were town he'd be (mis)lynched by now. His role is literally a counterclaim to a flipped town role.
I'm the University Acapella Group!
I assume I'm a group as I neighbourize more than one person at a time..
↑ Night Hunters wrote:@Ari, not really buying the whole you're a choir thing. Possible, yeah but a floor party doesn't sound like something a choir would throw.
No worries Nahdia!↑ Nahdia wrote:So town massclaimed? Is there somewhere the claims are collected? I've seen a couple here and there but having a list would be really nice. I see this big thing about GuiltyLion possibly being an ascetic or there maybe being multiple blockers? Sorry I hate being such a burden. Trying to reread everything but I feel like I'm missing lots of little details...
So, you think Our Parents are aligned with Crippling Debt??↑ GuiltyLion wrote:↑ Aristophanes wrote:Shadow is a flipped neighbourizer, I am a neighbourizer as well.
NH is a claimed Tracker
FB is a claimed JK
GL is assumed to be scum due to night action results.
N1 NH was blocked. Fire JK'd Jeanne (you). Shadow claims to have been blocked.
This is too much blocking power, thus the assumption of both multiball and GL or FB scum.
Either FB lied about his block, GL is Aescetic (thus no neighbourization), or an unknown third blocking role blocked Shadow.
This means we can assume the blockers to be at least partially scum aligned, as there are too many of them to all be town.
Or here's the explanation that accounts for the fact that I'm not ascetic:
NH is lying scum
FB is town JK
N1 NH was not blocked, Shadow was blocked.
(as an aside, LOL at Ari saying Shadow "claimed" to be blocked when shadow is flipped town)
N2 NH was not blocked, Fire was blocked - which is why Thor was killed.
The only reason there is all this confusing crap about ascetics and multiple blockers is because NH is claiming to be a D1 outed Tracker with no results that is still alive in D3.
Town!JKer Fire and scum!NH is a tremendously simpler explanation than a world with two scum blockers or one scum blocker in addition to me also being ascetic-scum that lied about it the whole game.
The wrench in my thinking here is I have literally no idea what the fuck SirCakez is doing.
No, and I started doubting their alignment in that post, as I can see some corrrelation.↑ GuiltyLion wrote:↑ Aristophanes wrote:So, you think Our Parents are aligned with Crippling Debt??
Why not? Is there some rule in Aero's posts that I missed that proves that they can't be?
Sure it does!↑ GuiltyLion wrote:↑ Aristophanes wrote:I believe 100% that they are a PR.
Which you've never explained, btw. You've been pressuredrepeatedlysince D1, to answer for this:
↑ Aristophanes wrote:Because I knew they were sifting a PR from the get go with their "Mom" and "Dad" post signing. I had them as a strong townread because of this and due to their play!
Signing posts with "Mom" and "Dad" is not at all a reason to believe that they are a PR.
So what?↑ GuiltyLion wrote:↑ Aristophanes wrote:Scum have literally no reason to avoid my wagon.
The counterclaim rhetoric is too easy to push and is a legitimate concern. I'd expect they would be all over that! It lets them legitimately look like they're scumhunting and they can always go "but he should have flipped scum!" as a defense when I don't.
This post makes no sense considering I feel like I'm fighting tooth and nail to get him lynched
Look at D1 and D2 again. NH and Thor avoid his wagon like the plague.
Wagon is you, GL, Massive.↑ Firebringer wrote:↑ Aristophanes wrote:So what?
Thor obviously didn't see me as a threat, and if NH I'd scum, they know how easy I am to mislynch. It's far better to save that for later phases when the going gets tougher.
I am not scum so scum have no reason to avoid my wagon.
So who is scum on your wagon besides Guilty?
What would you propose in that situation?
I'm not.↑ Night Hunters wrote:Why are you lining up lynches. -wtf-
Cake, do you think two town neighborizors is possible?
But it confirms GL scum and GL & I are clearly not aligned.↑ Night Hunters wrote:Us flipping town doesn't confirm your alignment, at all..
Okay, it confirms GL/FB scum.↑ Night Hunters wrote:↑ Aristophanes wrote:But it confirms GL scum and GL & I are clearly not aligned.↑ Night Hunters wrote:Us flipping town doesn't confirm your alignment, at all..
No, because then fire could be one of the scum roleblockers, and you not being aligned with gl means nothing in multiball.
Well, if they flip a secondary scum party, it has no bearing on either of our alignments, so we would have to cheer and reevaluate. In theory I would still be the lynch as people are assuming associatives between us.
Okay then, join me.↑ GuiltyLion wrote:↑ Aristophanes wrote:GL, FB, I've got a deal for you.
I'll compromise on an NH lynch today.
If they flip town, we lynch GL tomorrow.
If they flip scum, we lynch me tomorrow.
Thoughts?
If you can get the votes on NH then I'll go there but I'm thinking this is just wine for after your flip
And you did the same thing as soon as there was any argument to be made against me, knowing I'm easy as hell to lynch. As I say, those pushing the double neighbor rhetoric are likely scum.↑ Night Hunters wrote:LOL
VOTE: Ari
You went from town reading us to leading a wagon on us just to save your own skin. lol nope. You know we're flipping town and are going to use it for town cred. lol nope
L-1
No, I am saying that despite my townread on you, I can see your flavour being Scum aligned. I am willing to take a chance and am putting my neck on the line by suggesting this course of action.↑ Night Hunters wrote:↑ Aristophanes wrote:And you did the same thing as soon as there was any argument to be made against me, knowing I'm easy as hell to lynch. As I say, those pushing the double neighbor rhetoric are likely scum.↑ Night Hunters wrote:LOL
VOTE: Ari
You went from town reading us to leading a wagon on us just to save your own skin. lol nope. You know we're flipping town and are going to use it for town cred. lol nope
L-1
I am not scum.
Nobody hammer without intent please. I have more words to say.
uhm no? I am saying you are scum, you are saying that we should lynch titus' and I's slot to confirm one of fb / gl as scum and to give you town cred.
But I have so much to offer still.↑ GuiltyLion wrote:i'm just waiting for Ari to get hammered
I mean, it has to be one of the two.↑ Night Hunters wrote:Hey, Firebringer or GuiltyLion, which is scum?