Newbie 1730 - To The North (Game Over)

[fiddlercrabontheroof]

Hello, I'm fiddler, replacing Mori. Just going through the game now, will post a read soon!

[fiddlercrabontheroof]

Well, this has certainly been an.... interesting game to replace into.

After reading, I have to say no one particularly jumps out as scum to me. I know this is D1, so there's not a lot to go on. A lot of the scum reads are based on some odd reasoning, like voting the IC for explaining theory (?????) or not having same reads, but a lot of it seems to be noob behavior so that in itself doesn't lead to too much of a scum read. Like countless players before have said, just because a post is anti-town, doesn't mean the player is scum, so that's why my reads aren't solid now.
Here are my thoughts so far on the players:
Skold- nulltown, I like his posts, but ISO shows they're shallow in terms of actual scum hunting so far.
EnT- null, posts like a dickhead, but that alone isn't scummy. almost no content, but stimulates a lot of reaction. Could be intentional, which would makes me lean town, but not sure yet.
Karnos- null, dislike the vote with little reasoning (common thread so far tbh) but nothing seems super scummy yet
Joushi- town, i like his posting, his point by point/referencing style is very town to me, although i realize play styles aren't a great indicator.
Stove- still mulling about him, tbh. seems townish to me, but that abrupt shift in play style is odd to me. curious for other's thoughts.
Transend- same as karnos tbh.
Soula- their voting habits makes me think on the scummy side, she seems to shift it very quickly for arbitrary reasons

IMO, if we can't decide on a solid lynch, I think we should vote the lurky players so we can at least get a flip and hopefully figure out if there's a scum PR or not. Although, my slot looks to have been the least active, so maybe I shouldn't be pushing that lmao