Exactly. Are you saying DDD picked someone to scum read before coming up with reasons because he was confident?In post 804, Accountant wrote:Scum!DDD knows he's going to get pressed on his reads. Why would he not have reasons prepared? Furthermore, why would he feel confident he could give decent reasons unless he actually could?You were likely hoping to get away with not having to explain them, and you probably felt confident you could give some decent reasons if asked.
Copper sounds pretty scummy. If you ask me.In post 35, Astyanaxx wrote:If i was scum i'm pretty sure i would be unmasked after less than 48 hours. I'm a terrible liar, but you only have my word for it. Actually, it's also a very different timing and thought process than in a live one, so maybe i'm better at it. Or worse, we'll see. Anyway for now i don't have much to share with you guys ; i've skimmed through some of the other games and i'm impressed with how little people seem to work with when trying to figure out who's scum. I don't feel that in this domain i have a lot to share but i'll try to be as active as possible to not be a deadweight in the debates.copper223 wrote: Don't knock yourself down, your opinions are as important as everyone else's.
Ofc if you happened to draw scum I guess it sucks to be you and I'm coming for ya. Don't knock yourself down, your opinions are as important as everyone else's. Ofc if you happened to draw scum I guess it sucks to be you and I'm coming for ya.
I know.In post 853, Accountant wrote:No such thing
I'm not quite as black and white on things as you are. I don't believe they're impossible. I believe they can be staged. I'm worried that might be happening. What's your opinion of how Dragon jumps in to agree with copper so often, or at least was where I've been reading?In post 853, Accountant wrote:Why do you feel that convoluted natural arguments are difficult/impossible? What about the argument between DDD and copper?
Accountant's being pretty convincing.In post 712, copper223 wrote:I'd rather kick your ass today, I don't trust the rest of the stooges enough to forfeit a possible future mis-lynch and to follow through when I flip.
I have, I have, and I have. It's all in my meta.In post 890, copper223 wrote:I have never been lynched as town, I have never reached lylo as town (other than as a tree-stump) and in a newbie I have never survived past D2 as town, this is how bad some of you are, read the flip and weep at your ineptitude.
Your compass still didn't give you what you want. If you're Town. Why DDD?In post 905, ironstove wrote:The jon slot might be scum. People town reading that slot don't make sense.
I think trying to figure out alignments this early in the game is dumb, but I'll go out on a limb and say if DDD is scum, his partner is jon.
Tbh I've kind of ignored you. I've carried out crusades on trolls just to find them Town almost every time.In post 889, ironstove wrote:Jon, what are your reads of myself and guiltylion? Are we null or...?
Your biggest scum read is copper, but why did you say you're sheeping Accountant? Why do you have to say it's sheeping if you're voting for your biggest scum read?
Accountant is your strongest town read? Is that right?
So you're saying I'm playing a good scum game? Do you mean I just look like I'm scum hunting? What big revelations(besides you being town) would I have found as Town!In post 921, copper223 wrote:I do not hope to play with you anytime soon unless you flip scum and for the record I still don't think that's the case
who pointed out what? How do you know they were Town, and how are you going to go back and check?In post 236, JaeReed wrote:I wouldn't put it past copper to buddy the fuck outta me tbh. Like him saying that I wouldn't call the scumteam on pg 5 is bs as you know because iraon did the same shit and got townread for it. HOWEVER the person who pointed that out I think was town weren't they? idunno I'm not looking that up atm but that's my thought process there. Basically, what he pointed out was not a towntell b
How does you misreading Jae make accountant more likely scum?In post 254, copper223 wrote:This vote has a higher probability than average of coming from scum, if I am screwing up by misreading JaeReed (in which case I deserve the heat) this is where I'd look for their partner.
Mushroom food. What does this even mean?In post 282, copper223 wrote:Not for the point I made above I don't.In post 281, Accountant wrote:P -> Q by itself isn't an obvious statement at all so you need to justify that first.
Why is town less likely to be opportunistic compared to scum?
Because scum have to mislynch a townie so they are on the look-out for opportunities to do so, sometimes they take them and sometimes they don't depending on many factors but on average it's more likely to reflect their behavior compared to a townie that has very little incentive (some cases exist where they are also at risk or we are getting close to the deadline and they believe that a lynch is better than none but they are mostly irrelevant at the moment) and will mostly only do so by happenstance.
Speaking of justification, you have as yet not told me what good arguments there are that you are aware of for my wagon, nor why scumGL would more likely side with Jae in his opening post (see 267), according to you ignoring requests to clarify reads are an indicator that you are scum coasting.
In post 1123, ironstove wrote:Yea forget this I'm lynching DDD and I don't care what you say GL
Your agreeing with copper's case on DDD was what made me initially scum read your slot. It looked (s) like scum agreeing with a bad case on nothing. Even after re-rereading, I don't find the case credible.In post 1128, Dragonfire wrote:Why don't you give us some reasons why he's town? If you want reasons why he's scum, read most of what copper and I said yesterday with regards to him, then ask yourself why there would be two L-1 wagons on D1, both on townies, and nobody switching for ages until GL delivered the hammer.
