Newbie 1735 - Banana Split (Game Over!)


Forum rules
CrisP
CrisP
Goon
CrisP
Goon
Goon
Posts: 146
Joined: October 10, 2013

Post Post #352 (isolation #0) » Fri Aug 26, 2016 5:12 am

Post by CrisP »

In post 351, goodmorning wrote:I'm getting pretty annoyed by copper saying he was going to reaction test DDD without actually giving any specifics as far as I can see.
I don't have other big specifics to add.

I was not a fan of either of the main arguments at the time (Accountant vs Drealmerz and GM vs Jae) and prior to that I remember thinking I liked all of the newbies in the game, so I re-read the thread to see if I had missed something and Serra's comment about newbscum selectively picking what to mention as opposed to linearly going through the thread and trying to game solve everything popped up while I was reading Oncilla, so my focus shifted there.

Soon after he made his replacement post and that's when I decided to call whoever replaced scummy in his entrance post and see how he and everyone else would react to it (initially it was going to be something like: sucks to replace into a scum-slot eh?).

But GL was replaced before him and I've already stated what I did not like about his catch-up multiple times, the tone I used when claiming he was caught scum was totally off the top but I genuinely believed he was a likely candidate and when I read DDD's entrance where he fails to mention GL despite ending up voting for the same player the connection jumped up to me so I continued that line of inquiry.

It could still be valid, the problem (like any kind of associative) is that it relies on Jae being town, something I believed at the time, but I really have a problem with the way they reacted to GL's case and how they justified not being up to date nor reading the thread with being bummed town.

I call BS on Accountant thinking that I made all of that up, both the tone I used when scum-reading GL/DDD and the way I replied to him when he asked me about the scum-slip are pretty clear signs that I was up to something, now I understand someone may believe it was some weird scum gambit to demonstrate that I was doing something and not coasting, but not that I made the whole reaction test up after the fact.

@GM: Nope, wrong game, you self-hammered and mind gamer won the lylo after I replaced out.
Locked