[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/ext/alfredoramos/seometadata/event/listener.php on line 114: Undefined array key 8323837 [phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/ext/alfredoramos/seometadata/event/listener.php on line 114: Trying to access array offset on value of type null Survivor Mafiascum Rankdown (Properly Dead. Leave it dead) - Mafiascum.net
I'm sorry, no offence, but Survivor: Mushroom Kingdom was way too fucking big. Like, thirty players is literally ridiculous. Here I'm sitting, looking at the player list, and I can't even comprehend how this was supposed to go, because what the hell are you going to do with thirty people? How is that even a little bit conducive to building characters and a good game?
I'm joking I love you Scopey and it was the first go around so like, of course things were a bit out of whack. But, honestly, this character was a total flop. No posts in their confessional, literally I can't even find their profile, and they quit. We had Hammer Bro who was actually contributing and this dude quit. And I'm actually pretty damn surprised that this character was played by this person, because they turned out to be basically amazing, but this time? No no no.
"It feels oh so good to be in a survivor game again. I am really glad that I finally have the availability to commit to this game."
- Riddler
to be honest, like, dude came 13th, but still, he did literally nothing all game, and that kinda offends me more than just being booted as an inactive. because he WAS an inactive yet still coasted. like. no. sry aeronaut i love u but be more active next time
well, ani, you weren't joking! controversial is the right word for that cut. and to be honest, it doesn't sit extremely well with me. so.
i think zilean was definitely a low point of LoL. i think the nastiness involved with that character was pretty lowkey gross, and i did end up feeling pretty crappy second-hand just watching that. so like, most of the post i can definitely agree with. but, something i really can't agree with is the explicit positioning of ani vs flameaxe in this cut, and--maybe it'd be better if it wasn't ani making the cut--but it just feels vindictive and petty here. i don't know if i can let it stand.
should zilean and whoever panzer was be the next two out from LoL? i wouldn't disagree with that, since they were actively not fun, and that's a big criterion for me. should this cut be made now, by this person? nah, don't really think so. let's not descend into acrimony and elitish cliquey yelling at the outside.
so, without further ado, i'm
using an idol
. all votes cast for zilean will not count. i'll read the votes.
hello friends! the survivor mafiascum rankdown google sheet has a bunch of new features!
Remaining?
is the full list of every character still in play
BySeason
is the rank of every eliminated character thus far, by season
Links
is your one-stop shop to every forum
Final List
is the bare-bones rankdown, from 479 to 1
Extras
has details of Idols played and still in play
CutsByRanker
has links to every single cut, organized by the person who cut them
RankersSeason
lists the impact each ranker's had on each season
Stats-S
has how each season's doing in the rankdown, including averages, cuts, and percentages left
List
is a full list of how the rankdown started, please don't touch it
in the next couple days we'll also hopefully have
Stats-P
for how each position, merge boot, first boot, and finalist cohort are doing
Stats-T
for how each tribe is doing (if you have an organized list of players w/ tribes, i would really love that about now)
ok so basically, don't touch it unless you're a ranker, but do feel free to look @ all times!!!
rankers please follow this procedure when making a cut, you're already basically doing this but i'm writing it down anyway
if you play an idol please do this
Last edited by Drench on Tue Sep 13, 2016 9:37 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Look, flaking is probably the worst. It just disrupts the game flow, it's generally bad, eugh. Sure, Cybele probably had good reasons, but there was so much potential in Agitha and for it all to peter out in a flake is honestly a bit more disappointing than someone who just flaked off the bat without that promise. So, time to go.
In post 139, xofelf wrote:Why, it if weren't for Agitha Navi/Epona never would have happened nearly as fast or as solidly! Also, PMs all about cheesecake. How could you say no to those?
i can think of many ways i could say no to that but i'm just your local rp hater never mind me
is the rank of every eliminated character thus far, by season
Links
is your one-stop shop to every forum
Final List
is the bare-bones rankdown, from 479 to 1
Extras
has details of Idols played and still in play
CutsByRanker
has links to every single cut, organized by the person who cut them
RankersSeason
lists the impact each ranker's had on each season
Stats-S
has how each season's doing in the rankdown, including averages, cuts, and percentages left
List
is a full list of how the rankdown started, please don't touch it
in the next couple days we'll also hopefully have
Stats-P
for how each position, merge boot, first boot, and finalist cohort are doing
Stats-T
for how each tribe is doing (if you have an organized list of players w/ tribes, i would really love that about now)
ok so basically, don't touch it unless you're a ranker, but do feel free to look @ all times!!!
rankers please follow this procedure when making a cut, you're already basically doing this but i'm writing it down anyway
if you play an idol please do this
i have done some really hectic bonkers work over the past day and can now bring you:
Stats-P
which sorts by position
Stats-T
which sorts by the one hundred and eighty fucking one tribe compositions we've had in anon games*, and
Stats-U
which sorts by usernames for people who've been in at least 3 games (with some extra ELO vs rankdown comparison to boot)
the great thing is that those three are all automated, so basically, look your heart out, and don't touch otherwise i will murder you**
*if anyone has detailed tribe compositions for doctor who that'd be great because i spent five minutes trying to figure out how and what happened and i gave up. looking specifically for details of any tribe changes no matter how minor, excluding vote-offs ofc but including time travel vote-offs that result in a change in tribe composition
**if you're a ranker and you notice that your cut has struck the first blow against a category in any of the stats pages, feel free to put that cut where it says lowest member/placement/whatever. likewise, if you notice that any of the stats page rows has 0% remaining, feel free to slap what killed it off in the highest member/placement/whatever thing. if the latter happens, you can also go ahead and figure out the average of the group and put it in
[4:19:23 PM] Chill Nye the Netflix Guy: drench what did that post mean
[4:19:31 PM] Chill Nye the Netflix Guy: sry I'm dumb
[4:20:57 PM] Daniel: you know that part in every anon game where i start trying to Define How Survivor Works like an absolute ass
[4:21:06 PM] Chill Nye the Netflix Guy: ohh okay I get u fam
we found the dumbest ranker every1
(this is another joke)
432. Cookie Dough (Ciara24) - Pretty Super Vanilla
"Wasabi said they're all voting for me. guess I'm not too good at this!!!"
you know i FUCKING LOVE NEWBIES because they come in and they're always so amped to play and survivor just. crushes them. god it's so depressing. this is a fucked game. anyway like cookie what is there to say about you cookie dough. your confessionals were sweet and you had no idea what you were doing. i love you
In post 205, xofelf wrote:She ended up confused with another player, Miranda, a lot due to avatar similarities and Miranda being the more memorable of the two.
[extremely twink with bony ass voice] get a load of this cake hunty!!!! [slaps ass bone]
i disagree strongly with the tingle cut but alas i don't have an idol
no image or anything but basically, i'm cutting hammer bro from mushroom kingdom
i don't know why we've held on to this bloke for so long? there's really nothing interesting here at all tbh. like, you lost the numbers, and didn't really get anywhere towards stopping that. maaayyyybe you earn points for being the first anon boot like ever but like, what is there to work with here? love u
413. Strawberry (Salamence20) - Pretty Super Vanilla
"I didn't notice a change [in tribes]............."
controversial opinion: self-voting is literally the single most rude thing you can do in a game of survivor. you can't even be bothered to do the main thing in a game about voting? you take a spot in an already small game and u can't even be bothered voting???
m8
what makes strawberry different? ok well a few things. firstly salamence is just not a very interesting person to watch. sorry man but it's true and also you're banned. second you literally didn't do anything. this isn't a case of doge where it was like, you self voted and UGH but also had a major effect on the game. this is a case of strawberry? wow u voted a unanimous vote and then went out unanimously.
groundbreaking.
and it's pretty clear strawberry had no idea what was going on, and not in the clueless midna way where it's literally amazing and a trainwreck. i just mean in a boring, non-contributive way. not even a hint of alliances, nothing in the way of piquing anyone's interest, just a general bleh.
406. Flamboyant Flint Roller (orcinus_theoriginal) - Names Are Hard
"idk if i've said this but i'm irrevocably fucked"
so we're at the point where we just can't cut inactives, just the generally eh people right? because flint is a generally eh character. like, name one notable thing. first boot, blah blah blah, no outbursts or anything like that, you know what the drill is
one thing that actually is kinda cool though is he replaced in so good 1 for having a go m8 now bye
"How I'm going to win?: By actively engaging everyone as much as possible as early as possible and then backstabbing when appropriate. However, I want to keep that to a minimum, and when it'll will make the most difference."
you certainly kept your active engagement to a minimum, that's for sure
"I hope this the right place to cast my vote, but Dobby gives a vote for himself, as punishment, ooooh dear"
for SOME reason we get hints that something happened between ol' dobs and voldy but the edit (read: the confessionals) literally show 0% of it. like, voldy's angry. oh. great stuff guys. that's real great confessionalizing. anyway dobby contributed nothing was a bad pm'er and got booted bye
literally the only interesting thing is that he tried to vote for himself out of some weird krakt RPing thing. and y'all know how much i love RPing
In post 428, CuddlyCaucasian wrote:Dobby was someone I went to school with that I recruited to play and she didn't realize Survivor involved voting people out, so she just wanted to write fanfics with Stan
378. Carrie Underwood (ForWhomTheJellyRolls) - Battle of the Bands
"I wonder if Tove Lo and Of Monsters and Men lost my PM address. It's Carrie Underwood."
She was driving last Friday on her way to Cincinnati
On a snow white Christmas Eve
Not being social with Mama and her Daddy, her tribe getting on without her
Fifty miles to go and she was running low on faith, also safety
It'd been a long hard week
this conceit of editing the lyrics to jesus take the wheel to tell the story of another character who just didn't connect with her tribe the way everyone else did is too much work for me at 4am but you can fill in the blanks on a rote elimination we've seen dozens of times before
In post 460, Klick wrote:this led to him being eliminated over Ralts, who missed the challenge but was somewhat more popular.
asdfasdf this still literally mystifies me 2 this day
yall know how cracked i am why yall keeping me around
I mean, if they hadn't, our storyline wouldn't have played out properly, so I'm not complaining!
i was in the game a whole week and still managed to a) get an idol b) literally send an idol along c) get eliminated like that is its own type of crackiness
"Everyone is so vanilla on my tribe, I hate it. Like, I love them, but I don't especially love or dislike anyone, you know?"
Deerling, you gotta let me know
Should I stay or should I go?
If you say that you are mine
I'll be there till the end of time
So you gotta let me know
Should I stay or should I go?1
1deerling was someone who failed to connect with their swapped tribe thus falling squarely into category a of early boots