Open 658 Making Friends and Enemies | Game Over

[Creature]

VOTE: MiniDeathStar

Notice how, as soon she was voted, she voted Burgerking, the other viable wagon.

[Creature]

VOTE: Transcend
I'm voting my mason partner.

I counterclaim, Transcend is my mason partner.

VOTE: MariaR

[Creature]

Welp, wanted to see if someone would whiteknight MiniDeathStar.

[Creature]

VOTE: Transcent

[Creature]

1) Transcend

2) Creature

3) Burgerking
4) Aristophanes
5) BK201
6) sad1492
7) MariaR
8) Aubrey

9) MiniDeathStar
10) oddmusic
11) Secret Agent Jin
12) doomfeathers
13) tojam2

[Creature]

HOLY **** This is how Transcend plays it's NAI calm yourself.

Still think you should let it go.

[Creature]

Thought your vote was on Transcend.

[Creature]

What's this?

It's a readslist with two tiers (town and null to scum). Can you guess which is which?

[Creature]

MariaR, are you townreading Transcend?

[Creature]

Okay, your whiteknighting has been noted.

[Creature]

Okay

VOTE: Ari

[Creature]

VOTE: Aubrey

[Creature]

Trans is good at scum.

[Creature]

1) Transcend

2) Creature

3) Burgerking
4) Aristophanes

5) BK201
6) sad1492

7) MariaR
8) Aubrey

9) MiniDeathStar
10) oddmusic
11) Secret Agent Jin
12) doomfeathers

13) tojam2

[Creature]

Also, I don't really explain my reads there because most of them are me scrolling their posts and having a town feeling from them.

[Creature]

Aubrey, MariaR and Aristophanes are my top scum guesses.

[Creature]

MiniDeathStar, if both Aubrey, Aristophanes and MariaR were at L-1 and you had to hammer one of them, which would you hammer?

[Creature]

BK201 is a scroller read

sad1492 is also a scroller read

MiniDeathStar is probably a scroller read, I was townreading her since her reaction in the beginning, just wanted to see who would townread her first

oddmusic should be obvious

Secret Agent Jin is his nolynch vote, I think I understand why and it isn't a scum reason

doomfeathers should also be obvious

[Creature]

Transcend looks town, but I don't put him as strong townread anymore

Burgerking hasn't posted, so no reads there

tojam2's vote on MiniDeathStar earlier looks reckless in a towny way

[Creature]

Aristophanes is that feeling when you notice he's less helpful, unlike his townplay where he's trying to coordinate town even if he's being lynched

MariaR whiteknighting Transcend was bad and reminds of Open 649

Aubrey looks like scum trying to look reckless, most likely a scroller read

[Creature]

Are your suspicions on MariaR and Aristophanes because they haven't posted anything meaningful yet or is it more than that?

Oh, you came in a good time, I was already typing these, see above.

[Creature]

Not talking about ongoing games.

[Creature]

I am talking about games like Micro 631.

[Creature]

Seems like you making reads while chopping onions.

[Creature]

Not so confident on town!tojam2 as my other reads, but I feel better about him than people like Burgerking, Transcend, MariaR, Aubrey and Aristophanes.

[Creature]

Actually, I am having a feeling that some of my townreads are actually NAI.

[Creature]

VOTE: MariaR

[Creature]

Fair

[Creature]

Well yeah where's sad1492

[Creature]

Nvm, he's usually like that.

[Creature]

1) Transcend

2) Creature

3) Burgerking
4) Aristophanes

5) BK201

6) sad1492
7) MariaR
8) Aubrey

9) MiniDeathStar
10) oddmusic
11) Secret Agent Jin

12) doomfeathers
13) tojam2

[Creature]

Wonder why MariaR and tojam2 want them lynched, maybe they want to bus them for town cred?

[Creature]

Wonder why MariaR and tojam2 want themselves lynched, maybe they want to bus themselves for town cred?

[Creature]

k I think Burgerking is town

[Creature]

Apparently it's NAI for you.

[Creature]

There are better lynches than you.

[Creature]

No, I just noticed you're a huge lurker (or at least low-poster).

[Creature]

Okay

[Creature]

Whenever someone disappears, it always makes me wonder.

[Creature]

Way to stall this game.

[Creature]

sad1492 still town, not confident as other but still town.

[Creature]

Aubrey is somewhere near sad1492's tier right now.

[Creature]

MariaR and Aristophanes are my preferred lynches.

[Creature]

The other scum will be harder, but it will eventually show up.

[Creature]

I just hope whoever gets later in the game is actually smart, or at least hits the right person.

[Creature]

1) Transcend

2) Creature
3) Burgerking

4) Aristophanes

5) BK201

6) sad1492

7) MariaR

8) Aubrey

9) MiniDeathStar
10) oddmusic
11) Secret Agent Jin

12) doomfeathers
13) tojam2

[Creature]

Well we have 11 days (-4 hours), so it's a good time to see if someone can change my read.

[Creature]

sad1492 still town, not confident as other but still town.

Aubrey is somewhere near sad1492's tier right now.

[Creature]

VOTE: Aristophanes

[Creature]

Hi Gamma Emerald, hopefully you don't mind playing scum.

[Creature]

So far not feeling the town word to put before !mhsmith0

[Creature]

*she

[Creature]

lol

I wonder if MariaR is still reading this game

[Creature]

Okay, you're striked out.

[Creature]

@ Creature sell me on Transcend town.

If you ever played with Transcend, you wouldn't townread him.

[Creature]

Here I go again:
1) Transcend

2) Creature
3) Burgerking

4) Aristophanes

5) BK201

6) sad1492
7) Gamma Emerald MariaR

8) Aubrey
9) mhsmith0 MiniDeathStar
10) oddmusic

11) Secret Agent Jin
12) doomfeathers
13) tojam2

[Creature]

Also, why everybody forgot about Aristophanes?

[Creature]

Because you could be scum wanting to stay under the radar.

[Creature]

Wow we're stuck good.

[Creature]

Transcend, what do you think about mhsmith0?

[Creature]

aka I didn't get any conclusions.

[Creature]

Since my last reads.

[Creature]

Hi Dunnstral

Who are your friends?

[Creature]

You never played Micro 612

[Creature]

Welp, not sure if this game is on the right track or not anymore.

[Creature]

Also, Aristo replace out is NAI.

[Creature]

VOTE: mhsmith0

We'll have to wait 2-26 hours, but at least he should come catching up.

[Creature]

Some players make me paranoid, but BK201 isn't one of them.

[Creature]

Case: If you played Open 646 you should know.

[Creature]

I saw his townplay and scumplay are transparent.

[Creature]

The latter

[Creature]

Thought Flubber replaced doom

[Creature]

i tr sad

[Creature]

6 days, 16 hours, 39 minutes

What time is it? Time to start deciding a lynch

[Creature]

Sad's town

[Creature]

mhsmith0 didn't seem town when he was posting, and it's not his lurking.

[Creature]

I'd also go for a Flubber lynch.

[Creature]

tojam2 looks like a very juicy mislynch.

[Creature]

sad1492's wagon is also smelly

[Creature]

mhsmith0
Flubbernugget
Gamma Emerald

Take your pick

[Creature]

Burger is town

BK201 is town

sad1492 is town

Aubrey is probtown (except when he votes tojam2)

oddmusic is town

SAJ seemed pretty town before, now not so much

tojam2 is scum D1 mislynch

Dunnstral's gut town

Transcend might be town or scum trolling

[Creature]

Sure, what's your opinion on all these?

mhsmith0
Flubbernugget
Gamma Emerald

Take your pick

[Creature]

I don't think tojam2 has scum motivation, just a weird play.

[Creature]

VOTE: Gamma Emerald

[Creature]

If you know tojam2 is town, why do you want to mislynch him?

[Creature]

BK201's still town.

[Creature]

Next to go:
Fluffnugget or SGsmith0

[Creature]

Burgerking is also pretty much town.

[Creature]

Rest Io Piece

[Creature]

Hi Io

[Creature]

VOTE: mhsmith0

[Creature]

Hey mhsmith0, you've been posting elsewhere.

[Creature]

[Creature]

Aubrey kill points towards scum!Transcend.

Not NKAing, I believe there's scum in the Gamma Emerald wagon and I am townreading everybody but you and Transcend there.

Not VCAing, I have a gut feeling he's scum.

Discounting gut feelings, I'm not sure.

[Creature]

She could be one of these players that get emotional so their wagon dies.

[Creature]

Oh nvm, she doesn't act emotional.

[Creature]

Scum Meter
oddmusic
BK201
Secret Agent Jin
Creature
Transcend
doomfeathers
Burgerking
Aristophanes
Aubrey
tojam2
sad1492
MariaR

town

|

~town

|

null

|

~scum

|

scum

I don't really like how MariaR reacted to being voted, but I can maybe see town MariaR reacting the same way.

Sad1492 on the other hand has passed under the radar for too long.

VOTE: sad1492

[Creature]

Fair

[Creature]

Damn, thought I could use post icons.

[Creature]

If you say nothing, we can't sort you, so you could use "me lurking is NAI" as an excuse.

[Creature]

It's multiball.

[Creature]

Okay, show's over.

VOTE: Transcend

[Creature]

The mason is an evil faction that wins when all mafia goons are eliminated.

[Creature]

I actually don't think it makes sense scum would see two townies fighting and go like: "We must kill one of them"

Maybe they were mason hunting though.

[Creature]

Will be only bothered if Transcend flips town.

[Creature]

Transcend, this will be your counterwagon.

VOTE: Flubbernugget

[Creature]

Congrats Fitz, you're in a town slot.

It fitz.

[Creature]

For anyone who played with Flubber, does Flubber usually play like this?

[Creature]

I might go back for Transcend.

[Creature]

Alright pick a lynch:

mhsmith

Flubbernugget

Creature

Dunnstral

oddmusic

BK201

Burgerking

tojam2

sad1492

Secret Agent Jin

Too many scum

[Creature]

Oh right, it's the list of players but yourself.

[Creature]

VOTE: mhsmith0

[Creature]

I'm still not feeling town!mhsmith0.

[Creature]

For anyone who played with Flubber, does Flubber usually play like this?

Play like what?

You literally just saw my scum game. You should offer your own input here.

Don't be an asshole creature

Pls respond

I'm yet not sure.

[Creature]

I think we should've lynched Flubber.

[Creature]

Also, why did we let Burgerking slot not talk anything?

[Creature]

Mod

Can you replace Burgerking out anyway?

[Creature]

UNVOTE: mhsmith0

[Creature]

Okay, won't mind a Transcend lynch.

[Creature]

Nor Flubber.

[Creature]

Acting like "lalalalala you're scum and what you say is scummy" in twilight is like so bad.

[Creature]

I need to look at oddmusic.

[Creature]

I think we discounted him too early because of his early town cred.

[Creature]

Wow so many fluff

So many things easy to say

[Creature]

Reads in no particular order

Townpile

Transcend
SAJ
BK201 – forgot to note it in my catchup but I did like his entrance
MDS – made me nervous at the end there, but the rest of her game is still town.

Nulls

BugerKing (need to see more)
Creature (I have no idea how to read this one)
MariaR (I think I need to see her interact with people who aren't Transcend…)
Aubrey (See the above)
Doomfeathers (Had an early scumread on this one, but there are better candidates now)

Scum

sad1492 – don't buy his excuse for Masonfishing
tojam – Dropped into the thread, said nothing, and left.
Ari – Leaving my vote here for now. Hasn't posted since I was last here and my reasons for voting him still stand.

Also, his scumreads look all lynchbaits.

[Creature]

Updated reads:

(This time actually from towniest to scummiest)

Townpile

BK201
Aubrey
SAJ
MDS

Nulls

Burgerking – Hasn't posted much yet, but I like fine what I've seen from him so far

Transcend – I'm still taking into account my earlier townread, it's just a lot less strong than it used to be.

Doomfeathers
Creature
MariaR

Scumreads

sad1492 – Hasn't posted anything yet to make me change my read
Ari – Waiting for that catchup
tojam – My vote feels well-placed

[Creature]

Hey, Transcend, what do you think about this weird read change?

[Creature]

VOTE: Transcend

[Creature]

The other scum candidates are sad1492 and havingfitz

[Creature]

I'm not leaning on NKA.

[Creature]

Let's get real, you're a huge question mark right now and your death might open the game.

[Creature]

I have no idea on the other scum right now.

[Creature]

Tomorrow we should lynch a townie, so the lynches are ordered like this:

Day 1: Scum
Day 2: Town
Day 3: Scum
Day 4: Town
Day 5: Scum

[Creature]

(They're playing really well )

This is false, I'm not scum.

[Creature]

VOTE: havingfitz

[Creature]

Hell idk

[Creature]

If scum knew Transcend was flipping town, why would they act like they knew?

[Creature]

Also, idk who's scum, I think you're town. Maybe Titus is also town (or at least Burger was).

[Creature]

Actually fuck any townread I had before.

VOTE: BK201

[Creature]

I'll ISO Dunnstral, maybe I can trust his reads because I think he was the voice of the masons.

[Creature]

VOTE: Transcend

Yeah okay i had awful night kill choices.

Partner: you're universally townread but don't towntell so hard that you get masoned.

I'm positive that the person mentioned in post 53 is one of the original masons.

Peace out.

The town saw Dunn and knew there could only be one culprit. There was just no other choice. As quickly as they could they dragged Transcend up to the noose to kill this traitor once and for all. However, Transcend realizing there was no way out of this pulled out a gun and ended his own life. Everyone was kind of stunned by this. Why would an innocent man have a gun? They must have made the right choice. Well there was only one thing they could do to check.

They went into his house to check for any connections they could make.
Nothing. He was a

Vanilla Townie

!

The town cut their losses for the day and just went to bed early. Maybe they can find something to take this tragedy off their minds.

Transcend was lynched, he was a

Vanilla Townie

!

[Creature]

BK201 and havingfitz are fine lynches, maybe tojam2 too.

[Creature]

Oh, and also Titus, she'll have to do more.

[Creature]

If sad1492 weren't killed, he would be my first vote there.

[Creature]

This is such a bad misslynch.

???

[Creature]

I don't celebrate Thanksgiving yet it looks like I am.

[Creature]

Very useful performance from Titus.

[Creature]

Okay

UNVOTE:

[Creature]

Titus can't be the only scum, who else is?

[Creature]

VLA until Friday

Happy Turkey day

Hi Titus, today is Fryday

[Creature]

Aubrey is dead.

[Creature]

Currently alive:

2) Creature
3) Titus Burgerking
5) BK201
10) havingfitz oddmusic
11) Secret Agent Jin
12) Flubbernugget doomfeathers
13) tojam2

[Creature]

Vote 1.99

Gamma Emerald (Lynched): Creature, Dunnstral, tojam2, Burgerking, sad1492, Transcend, Secret Agent Jin

Transcend (L-5): Aubrey, Gamma Emerald
Burgerking (L-5): Flubbernugget, BK201
tojam2 (L-6): oddmusic
sad1492 (L-6): mhsmith0

Not voting:

13 players alive majority is 7.

Day ends in (expired on 2016-11-16 12:00:00)


Gamma Emerald will be lynched!

[Creature]

I believe one of tojam2/Titus/SAJ is bussing.

[Creature]

I think Titus is the one bussing.

[Creature]

I said "one of", not you.

[Creature]

Okay, so the wagons are both L-1

[Creature]

SAJ: Flubber, Titus, havingfitz
Titus: BK201, SAJ, tojam2

[Creature]

Bonus 1539 looks copied from a scum pt.

lol

[Creature]

L-3?

I can count...

[Creature]

Also, maybe we should not leave wagons to L-1, it wouldn't be nice if someone pulled a sad1492 (or possibly a Transcend).

[Creature]

Someone will have to counterclaim mason if you want me to lynch SAJ.

[Creature]

It's way better to sacrifice one mason to get scum lynched than outing the entire masonry to confirm one mason.

[Creature]

So far no counterclaims.

[Creature]

What's better? One mason out with a regular chance of scum finding the other mason or two masons out?

[Creature]

Your plan is good if SAJ is scum, but not if SAJ is town.

[Creature]

My plan:

SAJ telling the truth: Only one mason out, no counterclaims.
SAJ lying: Scum dead and only one mason out.

Your plan:

SAJ telling the truth: Both masons out.
SAJ lying: Scum dead.

[Creature]

Also, another downfall of your plan is that, if SAJ is lying, even if no mason outed scum might still kill one of them.

[Creature]

Okay then, give me time to think.

[Creature]

What if we try to lynch the other scum?

[Creature]

I don't think it'd be nice to go for 3p LyLo with no confirms.

[Creature]

Why are you talking about lylo Creature?

If someone vouches for SAJ, we get two confirms.

We'd have to mislynch twice in a row to get to 3p lylo and the masons would have major influence.

Who are then going to die the next two nights.

[Creature]

Don't hammer yet.

[Creature]

Get out of SAJ.

[Creature]

No, I don't.

[Creature]

It doesn't really make sense scum would claim VT then mason.

[Creature]

It's an hypotesis. If SAJ were scum, he'd have another scum out there.

[Creature]

Titus plan turned out to be a fail.

[Creature]

Counterclaims?

[Creature]

That's enough shade.

[Creature]

Flubbernugget, havingfitz, Titus

Scum are there

[Creature]

Anyone counterclaims mason? If not, then SAJ shall no longer be lynched today and whoever pushes him will be autolynched.

[Creature]

Anyone counterclaims mason? If not, then SAJ shall no longer be lynched today and whoever pushes him will be autolynched.

It's been pointed out already how masons have no reason to cc SAJ if he's fakeclaiming.

You paying no attention could mean you're scum (seeing Aubrey and sad1492 nightkills).

[Creature]

I vouch.

[Creature]

Anyone counterclaims us?

[Creature]

You can't be that bad.

[Creature]

Would've probably voted Titus anyway.

[Creature]

If I didn't out myself to save SAJ, maybe I would still be there and could do something.

[Creature]

I need to analyse the players joining the game before joining myself, there were a lot of unreadable/lurker players.