Firebringer's Mini Normal Review Deux

[Empking]

You have too (two) many abnormal roles, don't you. I think the set up probably is balanced, with the full ninja being a swingy element. I didn't spy any problems with the PMs or rules, but obviously that first point is a big one.

[Empking]

I don't think Loyal is normal, either.

And yeah, the Auto-Doctor name is misleading in what it actually does.

[Empking]

I don't think Loyal is normal, either.

And yeah, the Auto-Doctor name is misleading in what it actually does.

Loyal is a normal modifier now.

I'm not saying you're wrong, but why do you think that?

Yeah should I call it "Surgeon" or something?

Surgeon works. The important think is that the PM is flipped with the player.

[Empking]

I think that rather than 'heal' in the Surgeon's role PM it pught to be explicit: protects against one-night kill each.

However, other than that it looks a little town-favoured - I think changing a Goon into a Ninja-backup would be something - , but I'd still aprove it.

[Empking]

not to nitpick but this is what Macho says for normal guidelines:

This role modifier is considered Normal on mafiascum.net. It negates the effects of a Doctor or Bodyguard protecting it, although both would still be seen as having visited a Macho role.

If I changed it to "protect from 1 kill" would this still fall under classification? I could just get rid of the macho part, but part of this was balanced so that Surgeon can't protect Watcher.

I feel confident that it would.

[Empking]

/approve