nancy's Mini Normal review

[Empking]

Scum PMs should say that they can only speak at night. Not sure what I think about the scum wincon or the three one-shots.

I think the JK neighbour should probably be told of his partner's encryptorness. Not sure what I think about the neighbouriser-encryptor interaction.

I think the game is also rather town-favoured. You could probably drop any two town power roles and have it be more balanced.

[Empking]

Why? I don't see why one player is entitled to that information; not like the encryptor gets to know the other is JK.

I'll rephrase that: The Jailkeeper needs to know that he able to post in his PT during the day.

That latest set up seems balanced.

You could certainly have a Town Dayralk Enabler to replace the Encryptor.

P-Edit: yeah, that last one is a fine win con.

[Empking]

I would just avoid doing full flips.

[Empking]

This was an earlier version that I liked fwiw. Seemed a bit swingy though.

2-shot Weak Neighborizer
Town Daytalk Enabler Neighbor
Town Jailkeeper Neighbor
Town Elite Bodyguard
Town Desperado

Too many abnormal roles there.

[Empking]

2-shot Weak Neighborizer
Town Daytalk Enabler Neighbor
Town Jailkeeper Neighbor
Town 1-shot Bulletproof Bodyguard
Vanilla Townie
Vanilla Townie
Vanilla Townie
Vanilla Townie
Vanilla Townie
Vanilla Townie

Mafia Neapolitan
Mafia Goon
Mafia Goon

I like it, but I'm unsure of how bulletproof and bodyguard are supposed to work in normal games.

[Empking]

Which may be a wrong assumption and only a doc would save that.

It would not protect from Weakness and nor would a Doctor.

[Empking]

Urgh, when did Gunsmiths stop getting guiltiest on Bodyguards.

However, more cruicially: Bodyguards are not Redirectors. They protect from a kill they don't redirect it.

[Empking]

Empking what do you think about replacing the neighborizer with 2 masons?

That could work.

Neighbouriser resolves at end of night, but replacing it with two masons could work.

Bulletproof ought not be told. I think that's the only normal way of doing it, although the Wiki does not specify.

[Empking]

Looking at it, I think town probably has too much protectively. Perhaps, moving the JK or BG to limited nights. But wait to see what the others say.

[Empking]

Looking at it, I think town probably has too much protectively. Perhaps, moving the JK or BG to limited nights. But wait to see what the others say.

I felt this was balanced in spite of that btw, simply due to there being no investigatives, and bodyguard will be really unlikely to last late into the game.

Anyway, no rush on this. Hope y'all are enjoying easter.

No investigative, but a lot of information.

[Empking]

If mh is cool with it, then I'll pass it. Better that if feels town-favoured to me than scum-favoured to RC.

[Empking]

Aye 6

/pass