implosion's Mini Normal Review

[Empking]

Need to see rules. Need to see PMs.

[Empking]

-Is there a standard for flipping converted backup roles? I presume flipping as "Town Rolestopper (previously Town Backup Rolestopper)" is fine.

Yeah, that's a sensible flip.

Rules and role PMs seem fine; although repeating FB that the Motion Detector doesn't seem quite a motion detector.

[Empking]

The Motion Detector should detect on Rolestopper targets.

And I think it would be most reasonable if that is true in the Loyal case, too.

But it isn't; loyally targeting a disloyal target is like being roleblocked so no movement.

Huh, I've misunderstood Motion Detector for quite a while. Your way is the right way.

[Empking]

I guess thats fine?
Implosion?

[Empking]

I think a strict reading of the normal guidelines would have failed-loyalists not act.

[Empking]

Clarify?

Loyal "It causes the role to behave as though it were roleblocked unless the target has the same alignment as the user."
Roleblocker "In practice, roleblocked abilities are simply considered to have never happened. Thus, roles such as Tracker, Watcher, and Paranoid Gun Owner do not work if they Track/Watch/are targeted by Roleblocked actions."

[Empking]

Rolestopper targets are treated like ascetics and actions taken again ascetics are supposed to happen (trackabe/watchable).

[Empking]

I don't disagree. I'll /approve