Mini Normal 2010 - Scientific Mafia [GAME OVER]

[Gustavo]

VOTE: mumble
Speak up. Can’t hear you.

[Gustavo]

Yes I’m not mafia. Are you not mafia?

[Gustavo]

I mean the user not_mafia, which should have been obvious by the underscore between the words.

If you spoke up, maybe we all would've heard the underscore.

lol

And no I’m not him

[Gustavo]

That’s a pretty obvious joke given your name.

[Gustavo]

That’s a pretty obvious joke given your name.

And, yet, it's only happened twice.

Surprising really

[Gustavo]

Dude the game hasn’t even been open for 24 hours plus a bunch of people decided to post like it’s going out of style. Easy on the inactive comments until 2/3 days have passed.

VOTE: byron

Appears Over eager. Doesn’t feel natural to me. Plus he has an unrealistic expectation of activity

[Gustavo]

See what I stated above, I'm not expecting you to have posted until now, but it's more of a warning to say that if you continue to not say anything for another few days I'm gonna be super sus.

Challenge accepted.

See ya Monday.

[Gustavo]

See what I stated above, I'm not expecting you to have posted until now, but it's more of a warning to say that if you continue to not say anything for another few days I'm gonna be super sus.

Challenge accepted.

See ya Monday.

Ok if you're actually just gonna avoid participating in the game for 4 days for no good reason other than to spite some guy who thinks not posting for that length of time is inactive, then that's just either plain scummy or plain childish. Idk if you're gonna go through with it but if you're going to just act like that, which is going to help the town in absolutely no way at all, then you're a lot more deserving of my vote than anyone else.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Gustavo

No I actually am going to be busy this weekend and wanted to fuck with you and that was seriously the best way to do it. If you are town you need to SERIOUSLY lighten up. If people don’t post for a couple of days it doesn’t mean anything at all. You can’t scum read people for not posting. You can hate them, you can bitch about them, but unfortunately inactivity isn’t a scumtell.

[Gustavo]

Just checking in to say high. I’ll ketxhup tomarrow.

[Gustavo]

VOTE: Garuga

[Gustavo]

I had a gut read on Garuga before I went on v/la. I searched my name and he looked bad for his vote on me. Misrepping my joke into something else and using that as a reason to vote is scummy as shit.

I see 2 quick votes on this page so I start reading backwards and see the claim. That’s all I know. I don’t know anything else cause I haven’t read anything.

If that doesn’t satisfy your request. Vote me.

[Gustavo]

I was on v/la dude. Don’t call me dead weight. I haven’t been here. Now piss off

[Gustavo]

That's all I was asking for. You hadn't commented on anyone besides Byron up until this point, I didn't know how much of the thread you'd read, and I don't like naked votes.

When scum gives up. Naked votes are inevitable

[Gustavo]

Nobody voting for shoshin is saying that garuga is town. Garuga is day 2 lynch if shoshin flips scum. So assuming he is scum, and shoshin is his partner why would he sacrifice himself?

You want to lynch an unknown first instead of a known? Why?

I don’t really care why he did what he did. He claimed scum. Barring him being a troll, I’m willing to just roll with it and we can discuss Shoshin tomorrow. Hopefully both are scum and town is in an excellent position.

I’ll do whatever the majority decides ultimately but for now I’m fine with my vote.

[Gustavo]

well it looks like majority is on shoshin and I really don't care either way. Anything that buys me some time from having to catch up is a good thing

VOTE: shoshin

[Gustavo]

I seriously doubt I’d find anything that is going to make people look elsewhere. I probably don’t even need to read up. If both are scum the 3rd should be easy enough

[Gustavo]

Well, Garuga being dead definately makes things easier.

The problem is, he voted almost everyone in the game at some point.

We’re in pretty good shape though. Mumble being dead clears up some also. I was suspicious of him somewhat

[Gustavo]

I’ll go ahead and announce the scum team.

Shoshin
Garuga
Brawl

We lynch Shoshin.
Vig Garuga
Cop brawl.

Your reads are dead-on BTW.

So what do we make of this? Is brawl the last scum?

[Gustavo]

VOTE: brawl

[Gustavo]

Pretty sure that's a reactionary scum vote.

VOTE: Gustavo

Triggered

[Gustavo]

@screen. Nothing surprises me in mafia.

[Gustavo]

Saudade seemed sketchy to me and musicbox's entrance was pretty bad.
VOTE: musicbox

I could get behind that vote. He definitely could have replaced out knowing his chances of winning were fucked.

I’ll stick with brawl for now though. Omgus normally a scumtell but this one stands out as desperation

[Gustavo]

Normally isn’t a scumtell*

[Gustavo]

Why can’t we start with brawl? I mean he took issue with somebody else omgusing and they flipped scum. Now he’s doing the same thing.

Coincidence?

[Gustavo]

Plus he was acting like a dick yesterday and kind of today to me

[Gustavo]

What are you referring to?

In regards to what exactly?

[Gustavo]

I'm not voting you - TiaM is voting you. Are you even paying attention?

Damn my bad. I didn’t realize that

[Gustavo]

Brawl

[Gustavo]

I’m glad the vig was Mumble and not someone bad.
Gustavo or Voyc top two picks for last scum I guess.
Let’s stop debating dumb setup stuff.

It’s not me.

[Gustavo]

You were already voting him. What was the point of that little act?

[Gustavo]

I'm legitimately interesting in how you thought this seeing as it's not possible to reach that conclusion even if you mixed me up with anyone else, or a mixture of people.

Nobody was voting him.

Confused you with bujaber who is voting him. My bad

[Gustavo]

I would rather lynch Gustavo than Brawl myself. Will consider switching.

You have no reason to want to lynch me. I’m town so you are either scum or bad town

[Gustavo]

I would rather lynch Gustavo than Brawl myself. Will consider switching.

You have no reason to want to lynch me. I’m town so you are either scum or bad town

You have no basis for saying this.

I absolutely do. You gave your reason for voting me and your reason implies you are scum or bad town.

[Gustavo]

I want to lynch you because you have been no help to the town and there are no obvious scum.

and your secondary reason is just as bad as your primary one.

Let the record show I voted to lynch both scum day 1, not to mention I WAS FUCKING V/LA FOR MOST OF DAY 1.

so yeah, you are scum or terrible fucking town.

[Gustavo]

I would rather lynch Gustavo than Brawl myself. Will consider switching.

You have no reason to want to lynch me. I’m town so you are either scum or bad town

You have no basis for saying this.

I absolutely do. You gave your reason for voting me and your reason implies you are scum or bad town.

You can say that as much as you want but you are digging yourself a deeper hole.

oh i'm so scared. I am not digging my hole deeper because nobody else is voting me, and if they do i'll flip town and my words will still hold true. You are scum or bad town.

[Gustavo]

It's a pretty shittty thing to do to hold somebody being v/la against them. like it's just as bad as cheating imo. If you are actually town, Get some fucking morals and until you do piss off

[Gustavo]

Provide actual reasoning and I'll listen. Oh wait, you have none.

reasoning for what?

You know who doesn't have any reasons to scum read me? you.

I'm done talking to you. You are either scum or scum of the earth town who has no morals.

[Gustavo]

I'm not holding being VLA against you. I'm holding the fact that you're not actually trying to use reason to find scum and there are lots of players that are acting more townie than you.

don't fucking talk to me anymore. you are using my v/la against me.

I gave my reason. You have 1 scum basically admit to the entire scum team. 2 flipped scum and 1 is left. Sure he could be trolling, but he could not be. We have a mislynch so THE SMART FUCKING PLAY. is to test that shit out.

now stay the fuck away.

YOU aren't trying to use reason to find scum actually so that makes you a fucking hypocrite. I'm scum cause I want to lynch from the last person on that list and I was v/la. that is not using reason, that is being a bad player.

[Gustavo]

He's straight up just not paying attention.

I’m paying attention. I was a little high and there are 2 people with gray avatars. He’s wrong that nobody was voting him before he did. If YOU and HE were paying attention you’d both know that.

Let's start with voyc. I don't want us to start reading too much into saudade's replace out. And it gives music box some time to maybe change our mind. Also if anyone has any experience with saudade -- is his personality always this... 'charming'?

VOTE: voyc

Oh, must be Voyc then.
VOTE: Voyc

[Gustavo]

Nobody was voting him.

This is a lie

[Gustavo]

That’s the issue. You don’t know if Garuga was fucking with us or not. We have a mislynch, a couple probably. I’m not comfortable leaving him alive til lylo, and he will survive if he’s town. If this wagon falls apart the only other person I’ll vote is Tim. He’s either scum or really Fucking bad town. I don’t think I’ve seen a worse player ever if he’s town.

[Gustavo]

Fine. If he did that, Tim is the 2nd worse player. Better?

[Gustavo]

I’m sorry. I retract the insults. I didn’t mean to cross the line. I just find his reasoning for scum reading me extremely poor and I expect better from experienced players.

[Gustavo]

tim may be a good player but you have to admit his reasons for scum reading me are terrible. I'm scum because I wasn't around day 1 and I want to test the list from scum. neither of those are reasons for somebody being scum.

I don't need you to keep me alive. If people think I am not helping find scum (I disagree) and they think I am scum (i'm not) then lynch me and learn from it. Make the people who voted me learn from their mistakes especially tiam. make sure he gets lynched tomorrow because him trying to spearhead my mislynch for those terrible reasons must be scum motivated.

[Gustavo]

looking through garuga's posts byron he town read and his reactions to tiam seem weird.

[Gustavo]

knuflanto could be scum also

so my lynch pool is brawl/tiam/knuflanto (I don't see he has been replaced despite not having a post since last saturday.

[Gustavo]

@Gus: if you're forming a POE pool then can you understand TiM doing the same thing and having you in it? You say you didn't do much d1

Forming a poe pool is one thing. Voting me for things nobody should be voted for is another. I can’t speak for other players but my personal belief is if you see somebody voting for bad reasons to say something.

[Gustavo]

Defending myself is scum like? Dude you can’t really be this bad at mafia.

[Gustavo]

Look. This game is weird. I was legitimately busy last weekend and when I came back both scum were caught with a potential lead on the 3rd. You can disagree with me all you want but there is no way I’m ever going to put brawl as confirmed town and I’m not comfortable leaving him til lylo. Clearly we don’t have an investigative or else they would have investigated brawl.

You can say I’m not scum hunting all you want but based on day 1, brawl is my desired lynch.

[Gustavo]

Defending myself is scum like? Dude you can’t really be this bad at mafia.

Focusing on one person scum reading you is scum like. You can call me names all you want but it doesn't make me wrong.

I’m not even voting you.

[Gustavo]

we are far enough ahead, why not mass claim?

Nah

[Gustavo]

I’m still hung up on brawl has to be lynched before lylo. That’s a fact.

So why not now when we have the mislynch instead of later? I’d rather know now than wait.

[Gustavo]

Fuck it, let’s shake things up.

VOTE: knuflanto

[Gustavo]

VOTE: tiam

[Gustavo]

If he had a guilty this game would be over.

[Gustavo]

If you are town and honestly believe that. Do something about it. Convince others to lynch one of us. But seriously if you are town stop being such a disappointment to me.

[Gustavo]

Brawl should be lynched when there's 6 players left if the game isn't over before that.

Why wait? Why not now?

[Gustavo]

VOTE: music box

[Gustavo]

[Gustavo]

It’s sad to say but I think saude replaced out after garuga claimed scum. I hope that’s not actually the reason but it’s very possible. I can’t blame him either.

[Gustavo]

Who did you replace?

[Gustavo]

If this is a town flip we are lynching brawl tomorrow.

[Gustavo]

If this is a town flip we are lynching brawl tomorrow.

I'm pretty ok with this actually.

VOTE: braw

[Gustavo]

You're right, I forgot that Brawl was in the neighborhood.

Unvote

Why does that matter?

[Gustavo]

If brawl isn’t scum it’s probably tiam. I went from his top scum reed to sheeping me

[Gustavo]

You definitely gave that impression

[Gustavo]

v/la until Tuesday

[Gustavo]

VOTE: tiam

[Gustavo]

Yeah I knew his push on me was bullshit. I’m already voting him

[Gustavo]

tiam flew utr for far too long

He was pretty obvious also.

[Gustavo]

I honestly don't know if I played this game great or awful, although I haven't played in 3 years so I'd say with that length of a break I did pretty well (that's if the game is over as we're saying it is)

i'm in the same boat, haven't played in a couple of years. I think you played good enough to get town read by just about everyone and scum didn't kill you. That's pretty good. This game was weird though, normally you don't have 2 caught scum so early in day 1

[Gustavo]

The fact that he waited so long to claim is indicative.

So he basically committed suicide to lynch you?

[Gustavo]

Thanks for modding. I’m glad I was able to singlehandedly win the game for town