12 pages overnight...I'm phone-posting and getting an unusuallly sh*t signal. Pardon the lack of posting so far this morning.
Catching up from my last post at bottom pg 26:
Is suicidal Pine a throw in the towel scum tell or could he just be town who is confident that whatever group he winds up in (2 or 3) will contain scum, and dying will still be for the good of town? I lean town on Pine btw.
@Dram...how does the Koki claim make Wisdom's role anti-town? I think the ability to swap players who are strongly read one way or the other to suit the best interests of the town majority is a pretty powerful tool for town. Not sure I feel the same way about the zMuff claim. That seems more self-serving as opposed to Wisdom's which feels like it's for the good of all. I believe the 3 claims in this order: Wisdom, Koki, zMuff. They might all be true and town but this is the order I trust them. (Dram addresses this question a few posts later but I still disagree).
@DV...your reads are cr@p. I am town. I don't get the sr on Pine. Wisdom is way too low. Dramonic is way too high. What's the saying...your opinion is like an arsehole...it stinks?
@DV...so basically you aren't feeling too good about any of the claims.
@BuJaber...this results in Wisdom and zMuff being in G3 with RMOJ and Dramonic. So you would then advocate a G3 lynch or a G2 lynch that contains you....Koki....that doesn't seem like a "best solution."
I think the best solution would be to POE the most likely scum from Koki's result in G2 and put them in G3 for the lynch. zMuff swaps with riku (or Pine) and Wisdom swaps Pine (or Riku) and whoever his strongest remaining TR in G3 is. This ends up with all three pr claims in G2 plus BuJaber and Wisdom's G3 townread. And G3 is left with Pine, Riku, and 2 of (RMOJ/Dram/SirCakez).
And depending on the outcome we might be able to confirm Koki's claim.
@DV...wrt to your logic on scum reading me. Do you not think zMuff's early opinion towards you came across as a policy lynch? I did and his refusal to acknowledge it despite practically calling it what it was seemed deceitful / evasive to me. And iirc I only discussed it over the span of two posts. And we are all in the same game. I am coming up with my own opinions/comments. If they mirror those of others that is not intentional and they should be looked at as a broader confirmation of whatever comment or opinion you are inferring I am basing something on. Point is...we're all basing our comments on the same shit as everyone else. There's going to be overlap or redundancies.
RMOJ's schtick is becoming tiresome. And
this suggestion is terrible. smh...
@Wisdom...I don't think my comment you are quoting has been "explained." Also...
- We risk losing 3 or 4 townies regardless of which group we lynch.
- My lynch scenario did not include Koki.
- My scenario was based on the hypothetical situation where based on Koki's result...G2 was the preferred lynch and you were unable to move yourself. With zMuff's claim later on this changes things.
- You don't call yourself locktown. Or Koki ftm... I believe you are town. Koki might be town. But neither of you is "locktown" imo.
@Wisdom...if you think there is such a high likelihood of riku or Pine being scum then the optimal play is to get them both in the lynch group. Winding up with 2 (or 3?) scum lynched D1 would be lights out for scum.
@Wisdom...I'm not scum. What about my play seems off?
@Eddie...swap Cakez with Koki and lynch which group? 3? So you think Koki is lying and you tr Cakez?
@DV...this is stupid. Then you ensure you lose Wisdom or Koki...or both. And pants on head agreement by zMuff in #876.
Caught up.
My current reads from town to scum are:
BuJaber, Wisdom, DV.......................Eddie, Pine, zMuff.......NSG (needs to do more), RMOJ..... SirCakez, dramonic, riku.
p.edit...and I've been trying to post this for a few hours and in the meantime the game has grown 5 more pages that I have not read yet. So not entirely caught up.