Mini 2011: Partition Mafia (Game Over)

[BlackVoid]

I really wanted to replace into realmans's slot but by the time the prod timer expired, they prod-dodged, lol. BuJaber played particularly well from the town side being so, so close. Just replace Eddie with Fitz and you had it. I was suspecting pretty much the same team with Fitz as an outside shot. I don't really understand Eddie switching Kokichi to a larger group. Just straight up lynching group 2 would have been the smartest plan and the obvious choice for a lynch. Even if zMuffinMan wasn't scum, that would have put town in 5P lylo which is the worst case scenario (and he was scum). It seemed rather self-preservationist at that point. Also, in hindsight, the role Kokichi fake-claimed would have been broken (it's basically a variation of a sensor which is an incredibly OP role).

[BlackVoid]

I was really curious to see why this group was eliminated as it turns out this was the reasoning.

muffin/Kokichi/fitz
muffin/Kokichi/Realmen
Eddie/Bu/muffin

Slightly more probable than muffin/Kokichi/Eddie but still, it's unlikely muffin chooses to group himself with Kokichi and Eddie. It's a group that gets lynched most of the time and losing two scum is not a good idea.

It would be good reasoning if scum knew N1 that Kokichi would basically be considered confirmed scum on D2. But you doing a 180 on Kokichi and holding on to your BuJaber townread wasn't something scum could have predicted N1. I didn't know which way you'd go when I was spectating. If they thought D2 would play out as Wisdom vs BuJaber, then Kokichi wasn't necessarily persona non grata at that point.

Just pointing this out because a lot of the assumptions made on D2 seemed to assume that scum had knowledge of how town's reads would change D2 when there was no indication towards the end of D1 how those reads would end up.

[BlackVoid]

So, you and Kokichi put yourself in Eddie's group because you predicted that he would want to preserve himself somehow?