Gameshow Mafia ~Rerolling~

[Taly]

@Mod

For example, we use an ability like Venge/Protect/Dance that can and does take away Mafia's ability to kill - would powers that involve a Mafia kill be forfeited? ((Ex. 8-Ball/Veto/Rank))

I want Mafia's killing ability to go away ASAP, but I'd like this clarified before I definitively cast a vote.

[Taly]

OH.

well fuck

[Taly]

yeah, gamestart is the highest time utility for this vote

majority of others are best used for PoE or post-flip information

VOTE: 8-Ball

im scared that this already has 5 votes but k



Game of Thrones characters are helping me with this game because I'm on a 5-game losing streak (and yes, theyre completed games ofc)

[Taly]

momo

, what power do you think is best used?

because if you think its 8-ball, the alignments of the people voting it shouldn't affect your decision.

this is not a read-based wagon, but a setup-focused one.

[Taly]

I honestly don’t know. I have just returned to mafia from a long break and even before, I knew jack shit about setup analysis

you said that 8-ball was best in 26, why? if you no longer think this, then what changed?
(encourage you to not share reads atm as that begins to defeat the point of the past page or so - keep this factual)

8ball option becomes less optimal the more reads and gamesolve information is injected into the thread, that gives scum a narrative to attach to and create a probable candidate to be lynched - thus being 8-ball.

thats why a quickvote out-of-the-gate is necessary for this option to work.

gtg, i need to study for Trig/Chemistry tests this week, ill be on later in a few hours.

[Taly]

on second thought, im with

kittybells

100% here

Don't even have that discussion just lock in 8 ball \o/

fuck. i need to do chem work now guys damnit

[Taly]

fuck, we cant protect the townie we use

reveal

on?

there goes my setup strategy post i got denied from posting 10 seconds after thread-lock yesterday



im serious, i DO read these powers, going to make a mental note to read them thoroughly before i post about them.

regardless

8ball

was optimal play and

Reveal/1of4

are exponentially stronger powers proportional to a smaller playerlist and an effective PoE pool.

also, we cant definitively confirm the

8ball

so i see no value in withholding any form of suspicion or scumread back on people.

will get to reads/people next post

[Taly]

i meant the

protect

power

[Taly]

VOTE: TemporalLich

I want to know why you're more focused with finding the

8ball

and not pushing reads. The point behind a quick voting of

8ball

was place much less emphasize on setup decisions and more on game content.

Also, why is

wisdom

obvtown?

speaking of

wisdom

VOTE: roster

why vote momo? it feels opportunistic

id like an answer to this from

roster

, too

i thought

Oka

made a good point in 68, why is that scum-motivated or am i misinterpreting 70?

VOTE: wisdom

omgus/chainsaw noted

so we're using buzzwords instead of actually outlining our ideas of a post?

[Taly]

So the thing is, doing reveal -> protect -> 8ball still doesnt let scum kill, and if we get an IC it let's them solely dictate the lynch so scum camt influence it around their 8ball. Shrug. We can do that tomorrow now.

cool, you gonna vote someone?

also, not keen on basing a 17p game decision around the alignment of 2 people - we should not just IC someone and find ways to consistently keep them alive via powers while compromising other strategies

@me

with reads

Nancy

[Taly]

VOTE: roster

why vote momo? it feels opportunistic

See Nancy Drew’s post.

Roster I know you like to be a follower but please help town by actually verbalizing your own ideas instead of pointing to others. This looks really scummy and does not help town

Please and thank you

Can you vocalize what's scummy about

roster's

vote because he did clarify in 64 and 65, that I've caught on to.

Plus, several people have said they dislike the post but there's only one person who has placed a vote with a reason. (

wisdom

)

p-edit

, including you

Temporal

, if you didn't like his vote

[Taly]

i made that post lul

im just trying to make a point

x d

That

Wis

is overreacting and... I forgot what chainsaw even means FFS.

So, you don't think it's plausible that

Roster's

vote is opportunistic 62 and that

wisdom's

reply 70 to your indirect response about it is valid? 68 73

Do you even townread

Roster

?

also hi

wisdom

i m alive

[Taly]

good talk guys gonna sit on these replies

i want to see more from

temp

but my fire on that vote 10 posts ago has cooled, especially in light of 91, id like him to elaborate on a little more

still havent seen any direct interaction with

roster/oka

so

*shrug*

also liking

bazeu's

thought process, seems a bit distinct and not forced

it would be fun to pull

mbaki's

punches but i wanna wait for his

"3 reads"

, since im a bit underwhelmed with his posts atm

wis

is probably scared i rolled town if hes scum because yknow
he hasnt replied to any of my posts and i think hes been in the thread on/off the past hour?

competent players make me hungry ttyl food

sansa

gets me