Newbie 1934: Tundra (Game Over)

[Uncle Bob]

I guess your reactions are NAI since you all ignored it

Vote: Irrelephant

And one of his partners is among the people who didn't comment.

[Uncle Bob]

Bob, why did you say "one of his partners"? What did you mean?

That was a mistake.

Vote: Flavour Leaf

This is better. I'm concerned about how he's keeping his options open.

[Uncle Bob]

I’m not silly enough to think I can solve so early, so i dont get manipulated by the gamestate.

I was also thinking of your one of these two must be scum post.

Why am I expected to have solid and confident reads on page 4?

You're not. I'd say your unnecessarily laying the ground work to move your vote.

[Uncle Bob]

They're reasonable.

[Uncle Bob]

I voted Flavour then because he'd just posted and I was hoping to get a chance to hear from him quickly. I'm not sure if he's scummier.

[Uncle Bob]

That was for Menalque.

[Uncle Bob]

What do you mean by unnecessary? Why would I ever do unnecessary work as either alignment, let alone scum?

I mean, you're not expected to have the solved the game already, so explicitly keeping your options open isn't necessary.

Bob is going in an interesting direction even if I disagree with most of what he's saying.

What part of it?

FL's poking around seems pro-town. However

posting style seems to be more towards disconnected arbitrary statements rather than fully explained thought processes

so I'm finding it harder to get behind (and probably easier to fake).

I feel like this should bother you more than it does.

if not that I would also start looking closer at my fellow SEs

You should probably get to work on that.

@bob: mafia experience generally?

I've played in person.

I think people should explain why they are voting me.

[Uncle Bob]

Menalque seems quite earnest to me, and I am inclined to think that he is town.

I want Flavour Leaf to explain how his read on me changed.

Eggs is questionable.

[Uncle Bob]

I feel like I should have a better read on cinnamon, but he's voting flavour so he's okay with me.

Eggs error feels honest, but he is being way more active early here than the game I modded (newb 1930).

So what is your take on eggs?

[Uncle Bob]

Sorry, also, I'll try to find an avatar later today.

[Uncle Bob]

Menalque seems quite earnest to me, and I am inclined to think that he is town.

I want Flavour Leaf to explain how his read on me changed.

Eggs is questionable.

Simple. I started to see Cinnamon as town.

So why do you think there is one scum between me and cinnamon?

I don't disagree with the caution about groundwork

Then it seems like you agree with the most important thing.
quote="In post 154, Cinnamon"]His thought process through his posts makes a lot of sense to me.[/quote]
Which ones? Maybe you can tell me why he thinks one of us is scum?
quote="In post 166, Eggs"]By 136 he's townreading someone purely on the basis of voting FL[/quote]
Not town reading so much as happy with. quote="In post 166, Eggs"]where did 135 come from?[/quote]
quote="In post 80, Flavor Leaf"]I think that’s a townie play by Uncle.1[/quote]
quote="In post 166, Eggs"]Not explicitly giving any opinion. Instead of saying he's scumreading FL for it he turns it into a point against me[/quote]
I did not intend it as a point against you. It's a point against FL, and I think you should be scum reading him for it. quote="In post 166, Eggs"]he hinting at me + FL scumteam?[/quote]
I am not hinting at that.
quote="In post 182, Voted"]Also, active scum can help town more than lurking town.[/quote]
Why do you think this?

[Uncle Bob]

Fixed

Menalque seems quite earnest to me, and I am inclined to think that he is town.

I want Flavour Leaf to explain how his read on me changed.

Eggs is questionable.

Simple. I started to see Cinnamon as town.

So why do you think there is one scum between me and cinnamon?

I don't disagree with the caution about groundwork

Then it seems like you agree with the most important thing.

His thought process through his posts makes a lot of sense to me.

Which ones? Maybe you can tell me why he thinks one of us is scum?

By 136 he's townreading someone purely on the basis of voting FL

Not town reading so much as happy with.

where did 135 come from?

I think that’s a townie play by Uncle.1

Not explicitly giving any opinion. Instead of saying he's scumreading FL for it he turns it into a point against me

I did not intend it as a point against you. It's a point against FL, and I think you should be scum reading him for it.

he hinting at me + FL scumteam?

I am not hinting at that.

Also, active scum can help town more than lurking town.

Why do you think this?

[Uncle Bob]

Because nobody else jumped on me.

So you think wagons of two town are rare?

[Uncle Bob]

Can you show me some game where you've used this line of reasoning before?

[Uncle Bob]

And how does cinnamon voting you have any bearing on your read on me?

[Uncle Bob]

Family stuff this long weekend. Will be back tomorrow.

[Uncle Bob]

Back!