schadd_ 12p pre-designed setup, etc

[mastina]

Given 12p is slightly more scumsided, I'd remove the multitasking from the mafia tracker, but then pass it. The information gives a conftown; the cop gives another town; there's a ton of kill-stopping power to be had.

[mastina]

the informed can confirm itself as well with a crumb like "ugh ive been sneezing all day today, [doc] do you have any allergy medication" and point out that a scum role informed about a town PR doesnt generally pass the nrg

Towns are too stupid to think that.

But in theory, yes.

[mastina]

i can make the rolecop novice & multitasking if you'd rather, i don't like non-multitasking roles when you can claim them and when there's kill-sensitive roles like jailkeeper

Not quite sure I'm parsing the setup you have in mind; can you post this so I can visualize it?

[mastina]

That works. By the time N2 rolls around, there's a significant chance scum are down a member--even if not, there's a large chance that they only get a single night's utility out of the role before it becomes redundant. So, far less overpowered.

Just need the role PMs/result PMs.

[mastina]

I'm second-guessing how balanced it is (think it

might

still be scumsided), but even IF that second-guess is correct, then balance is within the 10% margin of error.
Basically, my second-guess is that it might be scumsided to be like 57.5-42.5 scum-town, but that's still within acceptable balance perimeters, and again, this second-guess might not have merit. (I could be second-guessing what is actually a balanced setup and my second-guess would cause the alteration to be townsided.)

So assuming you don't second-guess the balance, has a /pass from me.

[mastina]

Nahhh I think that def makes it townsided--any change I could think of pushes it into 100% townsided territory, which is probably a sign we're at the balanced mark.
Soyeah, pass still stands.