mini 2126: the game is OVRE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[iDanyboy]

Why do we have to turn it into a 1v1? If we leave them both alive won’t it resolve itself?

[iDanyboy]

Good
Comical (Mechanical)
RCE (Mechanical)
Alchemist
Dann (Weak)

Bad
Auro
OkaPoka
Luna (Weak)

Can't Read
Eddie
PP
Clidd

Roughly where I'm at, The higher they are the more I like the read.

VOTE: Auro

[iDanyboy]

Comical (Mechanical)
RCE (Mechanical)

Can you explain how Mechanical -> Good?

They will sort them selves out, But I put it in the town section because I don't think they are lying.

I like Alchemist because of his push on you, I found my self agreeing with it. I din't like you trying to POE people who played with fire, along with you trying to find people who fire could easily read. It's things that are easy to manipulate to who ever you want to push, I also didn't like when RCE was doing it but he will sort himself out.
I didn't like Auro's vote on luna then the flip to Cidd, and I didn't like his push on Alch either.

I skimmed through day 1 and have read properly form day 2. Didn't get anything from his day 1 and he hasn't post today has he?

[iDanyboy]

Spoiler:

I din't like you trying to POE people who played with fire

1.What do you make of people offering the same reasoning as defense when pushed? ("Fire LITERALLY invited me to play, I can't have done the NK") etc.
2. Why is it more likely to be

scum manipulating reasoning

than

town taking a starting point

?
3. The metric that scum would want to go for "easy lines of reasoning" to arrive at scumreads seems more applicable to newbies and far less to experienced scum players - would you agree?

If it really was just because you don't have much experience with FB, then fine I'm wrong.

Alch concedes here that my questioning could indeed be genuine if I don't have experience with FB - and this can be easily verified to be true.
In the few games I have been with Firebringer in, we've had minimal interaction. So,
4. What do you make of this?
5. How do you believe RCE v Comical will sort themselves out? They're both gunsmiths and will get positive results on each other.

Both of you ignore that I was PoE'ing

myself

based on that reasoning (which as unbiased town I would find scummy, on a surface level at least).

1). I would say it's not a defense
2). It's not a starting point, it's a waste of time that will take us nowhere.
3). Disagree with the second half

4). Doesn't matter, it's a vapid point that doesn't do anything.
5). They'll die or they'll give us enough info to to sort everyone.

I don't get what POE'ing yourself means? Your using it as a case to prove you are a townie?

[iDanyboy]

If Dann Eddie is the scum team we kill a rando, not fire. Move on.

iDanyBoi, would you agree with this?

If his scum he could easily say this so I wouldn’t use it to form a read.

[iDanyboy]

I just caught up and I'm still as lost as I was before, don't feel like i've gained anything from before, I don't like Eddie's vote. I don't get why Comical thinks Alch is scummy.

[iDanyboy]

You basing your vote on VCA that there must be scum on the pine wagon, but the wagon could easily be all town or all 3 scum, I don't know how you choose how much scum or an a wagon. sounds like a shot in the dark.

[iDanyboy]

I just caught up and I'm still as lost as I was before

Really? Didn't you have a pretty reads list and a good amount of confidence I'm scum?
VOTE: dan

Yh, I'm pretty much in the same position as before.

[iDanyboy]

It's because than been a lot of content in-between and I haven't been able to get a lot out of it. which is making me feel lost.

[iDanyboy]

I haven’t played since 2017 so I have no idea if iv’e done it before.

[iDanyboy]

It’s meant to answer Auro’s question, I don’t know if iv’e done it since I haven’t played for a while.

[iDanyboy]

I’m a VT.

[iDanyboy]

I haven't disappeared, but the sites is lagging for me, so I'm struggling to read. I'm also surprised my wagon broke up so quick, I think it does mean there were probably 2 scum on my wagon and they didn't want me lynched yet.

[iDanyboy]

The lagging is inconsistent, as I was typing up my previous post it was bad but now it's all ok. To answer your question about my activity wouldn't I have to say something about that game which I can't do. I'm still finding Auro scummy I think Alch is town, and I feel like Oka and SS could be town too, and I don't think Comical is fake claiming and his action's seems consistent with his role and I think leaving RCE alive and getting his information tomorrow will help to determine if his being truthful about his role so I don't want to lynch him either.Which by process of elimination leaves me with <Eddie Cane, Luna Fox, PenguinPower, Dannflor>.

[iDanyboy]

I'm down for an eddie wagon.

[iDanyboy]

VOTE: eddie

[iDanyboy]

I like Eddie's recent post and I think Oka is town too, so I don't want to vote either, I don't want to be lynched either.
UNVOTE:

I also think Dany is >>> rand scum, and that despite your arguments the two of you do make sense together.
I would be more than willing to go back to voting Dany today.

What's your case on me again? Because going through your ISO I can't see one more than lurker, and that doesn't make sense with your >>>.

[iDanyboy]

1). I don't understand why you would hop on the Eddie wagon without even considering the fact that he could have hammered you and didn't.

2). I also feel like the confidence you've been showing in your reads conflicts with the confusion you've been claiming when people ask you to contribute more.

1). I don't really get how that makes me scummy.
2). I don't think It's any different than when you made Post 1739, than it wasn't a big deal but know it is?

[iDanyboy]

VOTE: Auro

I’ll rather my vote was here than RCE, I don’t get why we can’t get his results and get a potential clear or if his scum we’ll still get some info from it, and I’m not sure how a town vs scum gunsmith would make sense with the claims we have.

I think Luna’s interaction with Oka makes Luna is town and I read Oka as town outside of the interaction too.

I’m getting a stronger town read on Alchemist and I’m feeling less sure of Eddie than I was before.

[iDanyboy]

Hello again, I thought I posted yesterday but I must of been imagining things. Scum team is probably within Auro,SS, NSG and maybe PP if one of those is wrong.

I don’t know how Comical is being scum read is when the way he went about his claim was townie, and I don’t think he was the one who put a lot of pressure on the RCE wagon, why claim and put no pressure on your counterclaim? If your scum. I find it hard to believe RCE is a scum gunsmith, who’s only purpose is to find a town gunsmith which would be very little power for a mafia team which so many roles claimed and not all roles have been claimed yet.

[iDanyboy]

VOTE: Northsidegal