he's in my scumpool (maybe i'm not up to date on how good mangoes are for your health), but i guess i'll go a bit more into my thoughts
i've already talked a little bit about why i townread oka but i guess it was only one post, so if you want more elaboration on that let me know and i guess i'll try to go back and grab some quotes. fair warning though, outside of the one that i already talked about i think that compared to other players in the game my read on oka isn't really one i'd be able to go back and give you specific posts that lead to the townread there. if you still disagree i'll try, though.
early game i townread clidd and so far i don't think SS has given me any reason to doubt that. there was something of a consensus early game that clidd's early posting was town – that opinion came from multiple sources that i both know to be town now (dannflor, firebringer) and people whose reads i trust. that's not
why
i have the read—I came to the read myself—but it certainly makes me feel better about it.
I know you disagree with me on this one, but I think Luna is town. I liked her very early interactions with Firebringer, I think that
371 is a unique combination of indignation and self-meta that comes from town more often than it comes from scum, and I think almost all of page 66 is town indicative for her. Yes, I know the irony of saying that I think self-meta is towny in a game with flavor leaf in it, but I guess I consider it on a person-by-person basis. She's probably the weakest of my townreads, but I still think she's town.
Comical and RCE are out of my lynchpool right now pretty much only because of their claims.
so that's something of how i arrived at the pool of {eddie, RCE, alchemist, auro}.