Gypyx's Mini Normal Review, August 2020

[schadd_]

yes it is scumsided - in dispersing the roles you've left none of them very powerful

to begin with i would describe mailman as nothing, neighborhood as nothing and role watcher as close to nothing - a good benchmark for these is that they can't really produce alignment-based info on their own (you would think that players are able to sort better in a neighborhood but empirically that seems to not be very true)

vengeful + suicide bomber, with their powers combined, resemble a 1-shot vig

and then theres a slightly gated doctor, which is still strong but not enough to carry here

if you turned the vigilante into just a full ungated vigilante, i'd think we town was still short. adding some other invest power (something small to combine with the mailman? sounds fun) would do it

[schadd_]

Idk if I'm supposed to keep my mouth shut until the primary has said his piece

the secondary reviewer has freedom of expression

[schadd_]

bothered by the fewness of vanilla roles here - it is generally preferred that at least half of town are VTs. you can solve this by putting the BP on one of the roles - vengeful would be a good idea. i'd pass with that change after i saw the role PMs

not really into UB for this setup, i think it is a more meaningful role when there are fewer PRs

[schadd_]

role PMs good

Q for implo: does rolewatcher give a full rolecop result on the perpetrator or just the component that did the action

[schadd_]

this is ready for signups