Open 795 | Noir | Game Over

[ManWithNoName]

VOTE: Battle Mage

I'm on to you, Balfruss

[ManWithNoName]

@mod could you add how many votes it takes to eliminate to your vote count?

[ManWithNoName]

Weak hiders should, at the very least, leave easy to interpret hints of whom they are hiding behind before the day is done.

[ManWithNoName]

Also I don't understand the whiny singer wagon. Anyone want to clue me in?

[ManWithNoName]

VOTE: Lost

You leave Desmond alone, brother.

[ManWithNoName]

Bumbi, Waswas and Battle Mage are town

I’ve been town in every game with you so far and you’ve never identified me as such. In fact you’ve often TR scum more than anything.
Why should your townreads be trusted?

Weren't you scum in our first game together? In the newbie. And I scumread you

What the fuck is going on?

[ManWithNoName]

Geniusgamer Townlocked for seeing how bad Not_Mafia's play truly is.

This is bad.

[ManWithNoName]

Geniusgamer Townlocked for seeing how bad Not_Mafia's play truly is.

Good read. Townlock

Worse.

[ManWithNoName]

(Yay, pagetop)

So anyway, this sort of thing is exactly why I’m voting for Not_Mafia. It’s going to take a lot to change my opinion at this point.

What did I do now?

So far, this is one of my more serious games, god help you if you played in some of my other games.

Seriously, N_M what is this?

[ManWithNoName]

dude i'm always town leader

This is pretty true from a normal I ran.

[ManWithNoName]

nice pagetop

Also I don't understand the whiny singer wagon. Anyone want to clue me in?

Wagons are good. You have an alternative or you just want to say that?

Wagons are good but I do like to know why people are on the wagon to determine if I like the particular wagon enough to paint it.

[ManWithNoName]

everyone is ok with a taylor wagon but no one has given strong reasons for a taylor wagon. what does that tell you?

This is a really really bad post but it doesn't feel like scum

WHAT IS THIS? I've seen both town and scum N_M and I've never seen him play the game!

[ManWithNoName]

VOTE: dogempire does seem good though.

[ManWithNoName]

Not mafia, you town?

[ManWithNoName]

Looks good to me

[ManWithNoName]

N_M might be scum.

[ManWithNoName]

He hasn't said he's town yet.

[ManWithNoName]

Well, Dong had to know what he was getting into. N_M always lolhammers.

[ManWithNoName]

That's not the scum indicative part of his play. I feel like when he's town it at least used to be a good tell that he actually said he's town.

[ManWithNoName]

Mafia... is no joke... people are dying every day that the scum lives. Do you want to be responsible for these deaths via inaction?

You are boring

[ManWithNoName]

Wagons

[ManWithNoName]

Mafia... is no joke... people are dying every day that the scum lives. Do you want to be responsible for these deaths via inaction?

You are boring

If I’m boring, I guess Mafia is too, as I’m simply playing the game.

Have you ever tried having fun?

[ManWithNoName]

Someone shoot him, he's a not fun haver

[ManWithNoName]

By golly Ms. Molly, this guy really doesn't have a sense of humor at all.

[ManWithNoName]

He's a regular Judge Doom

[ManWithNoName]

This guy's the one who's upset during comedies because he doesn't get the jokes.

[ManWithNoName]

[ManWithNoName]

VOTE: NM seriously, he hasn't claimed town that's his tell

[ManWithNoName]

Too late.

@mod VLA from Thursday to Saturday, by the way please

[ManWithNoName]

I wish

[ManWithNoName]

And I legitimately gave my reasoning. I don't understand why people don't read my stuff where I say stuff and know what stuff I say as stuff.

[ManWithNoName]

And I legitimately gave my reasoning. I don't understand why people don't read my stuff where I say stuff and know what stuff I say as stuff.

is your reasoning "he's scum because he didn't say he's town"?

Yes, I'm fairly sure that's the accurate way to read him. It's been a few years but that was my tell on him back in the day

[ManWithNoName]

no one is scumreading NM for lolhammering.

Right, just ignore my persistent scumreading and my vote for Not_Mafia. Because apparently my scumreading somehow isn’t worth acknowledging.

You aren't voting him

[ManWithNoName]

I think Lost reactions to Taylor are town

[ManWithNoName]

Lost, ManWithNoName, t, MURDERCAT, NorwegianBoyEE, t, Not_Mafia


I wouldnt expect more than one scum in that list. The wagon is so early and quick it reminds me of a similar wagon that was all town in another game. (didnt end in lynch as there was no self vote)

I did forget a kill on the wagon more likely indicates scum off the wagon.

VOTE: Tayl0r

I still think N_M is scum for not straight out saying he's town day 1, but at the same time, his day play is going to be the same regardless of his role, so, I guess I'll just go onto my next preference.

[ManWithNoName]

GeniusGamer ??
Tayl0r Swift -
bob3141 +++ town savior (?/+)
Not_Mafia ??
ManWithNoName ?
Dongempire x
Bambi Jay +
NorwegianboyEE +
MURDERCAT <3
Battle Mage x
PenguinPower ?
Isis +
Lost +

VOTE: PP

These don't really make sense together for me.

[ManWithNoName]

GeniusGamer ??
Tayl0r Swift -
bob3141 +++ town savior (?/+)
Not_Mafia ??
ManWithNoName ?
Dongempire x
Bambi Jay +
NorwegianboyEE +
MURDERCAT <3
Battle Mage x

PenguinPower ?

Isis +
Lost +

VOTE: PP

These don't really make sense together for me.

Just highlighting the part I don't get.

[ManWithNoName]

- goodnight friends!!

Upside down duck.

[ManWithNoName]

You're the Avatar, Bob. It's up to you.

I just can't let this stand without fixing it.

[ManWithNoName]

I'm confused about PP but feeling good about norwegian and isis and the bob vote is obviously going nowhere

Do you have sufficient history with norwegian and isis to show either of them as particularly prolific scum hunters?

[ManWithNoName]

I am trying to figure out why voting to PP rather than what is presumably a scum read in your list is superior play to get "clarity" we have lost two town members, I would think one would be more likely to pursue a scum read if there is no basis that two town reads are better at scum hunting than an average player.

To me, it doesn't matter if someone is town to vote with them unless you respect their scum hunting ability. I trust my abilities more than those of just random town reads.

The clarity will, perhaps, help me sort MURDERCAT.

I do not think "wanting clarity on PP" is a great reason to vote for PP. Thus, I have some more information on MURDERCAT.

Would you all like me to walk you through why I am asking questions every time I ask one? I'm more than willing to assume you cannot think on your own.

[ManWithNoName]

When the answer is that obvious, I don't see why multiple people needed to ask the question.

[ManWithNoName]

Fine

[ManWithNoName]

Please refrain from using non-Clint Eastwood gifs for me.

Nic Cage is also acceptable

[ManWithNoName]

I signed up because the worst.

[ManWithNoName]

sure, I'll keep looking for evidence of actual amusement

AHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAH

Burn yourself?

[ManWithNoName]

I would not be opposed to tractors on the Taylor votes.

[ManWithNoName]

I'm not anonymous, I'm an outed alt.

[ManWithNoName]

People give him a free pass.

[ManWithNoName]

One, that's false.

Two, even if it was true, I would prove it false.

[ManWithNoName]

@mod I'm not on Bambi

Well I should be back home sometime tomorrow but checking up that's pretty important to say imo

[ManWithNoName]

Still need a read through from MWNN

HI, can you guys give me tomorrow for this?

Lots of pages, a few things to do today and now I can't get my computer to hook into the internet. I definitely don't want to read all these pages on my phone

[ManWithNoName]

Not lynching Taylor loses the game. And thanks for not giving me any time to talk yesterday, not mafia. Not like I asked for it or anything.

[ManWithNoName]

We do have a clear on NM, mechanically. So I was wrong on that one

[ManWithNoName]

Just a reminder that Norwegian is not actually mechanically cleared since GG was jail keeper. I also don't like the turnaround from Norway on PP slot, weren't you pushing him Day 2?

[ManWithNoName]

Just a reminder that Norwegian is not actually mechanically cleared since GG was jail keeper. I also don't like the turnaround from Norway on PP slot, weren't you pushing him Day 2?

Why would nord not be mech clear if bambi is in fact town?

Bambi could have been the JK target

[ManWithNoName]

I'm just not taking the result for granted at this time. I am positive that Murder told us Bob didn't perform the N1 kill

[ManWithNoName]

Right now I'm working out information that we know for sure and information that needs to be evaluated in light of the revelations eod2 and start of day 3

[ManWithNoName]

Then I'll go through again and see if I can't figure out more from talk

[ManWithNoName]

Just a reminder that Norwegian is not actually mechanically cleared since GG was jail keeper. I also don't like the turnaround from Norway on PP slot, weren't you pushing him Day 2?

Why would nord not be mech clear if bambi is in fact town?

Bambi could have been the JK target

What makes you think gamer jailed bambi?

I am just saying the information that we have before everyone leaps to conclusions. I don't think that he necessarily targeted Bambi but I don't know that he didn't , 90%of the time Norwee's town by the claim, but I'm not ruling out the outside chance

[ManWithNoName]

Just a reminder that Norwegian is not actually mechanically cleared since GG was jail keeper. I also don't like the turnaround from Norway on PP slot, weren't you pushing him Day 2?

So Penguin was voting their Jailkeeper as a buss?

Bussing occurs but I did want the answer as to why you changed your mind. That's all.

[ManWithNoName]

I think Hider beats JK but I can't remember how that stuff works

If it does, I'm wrong so I'll look into this and withdraw my statements if I'm wrong. It has happened, just look at my suspicion of NM

[ManWithNoName]

Because we just limmed a scum jailkeeper and Penguin was on the wagon early.

Did not think of that one. Good point, my point withdrawn as to you.

[ManWithNoName]

I think Hider beats JK but I can't remember how that stuff works

No i don’t think it does...?

Copy
Hide
Bus Drive
Block
Redirect
Protect
Miscellaneous
Kill
Recruit
Inspect

Actually, Isis appears to be correct. I was wrong. I think Jailkeep falls under Block, so, no, you're full cleared

[ManWithNoName]

I think lynching Anonymous, PinguFlamethrower and Earth, Wind and Dire wins the game

Who's earth wind and dire?

[ManWithNoName]

Bambi Jay, Isis, Lost, Not_Mafia. You're all members of the townblock.
Bob3141, Penguinpower can be honorary members.

Tayl0r and ManWithNoName. I don't townread you two at all right now, so if you are town. Feel free to start convincing me who else would be scum ASAP.

Honestly I think if you move Isis out of the town block, you're good. I know I'm town but, like that's my guess is that Taylor and Isis are the last Scum by play.

Anyway. That's all I got. I'll let you guys do what you will, we can spare another miselimination and I'm not super excited about defending against my own. I was kind of hoping some small miracle would occur and I'd be killed last night so that I wouldn't have to type this much.

[ManWithNoName]

So this disproves that N1 JK could theoretically target Hider who might subsequently target mafia and not die...?

Yeah, I believe so

[ManWithNoName]

Very opportunistic in my opinion and she had the scummy play with the weak excuse then of being drunk.

[ManWithNoName]

Applying my thought also hasn't worked so well in this game so I can just go with my gut feels at this point. Again, I feel I'm going to be the elimination today.

[ManWithNoName]

Off to cook, later.

[ManWithNoName]

I am positive that Murder told us Bob didn't perform the N1 kill

What? How did you come up with this?

In one post murder gave Bob a lot of plusses and gave him the title of town savior

[ManWithNoName]

There's no jackoff emoji on this site for me to make fun of you enough.

[ManWithNoName]

VOTE: EWD

Are you secretly voting for Expert Witness Disclosure which is what I read this as. Good God, I work alot

[ManWithNoName]

read my 2148 day one and the scum pt

What?

[ManWithNoName]

take a meta dive and just see what im like as scum.

See how i bus my partner with the intent of saving them. Where is bus them but keep giving them hints and tips how to get out of it. All the while making others balk at joining the wagon.

What game were you referring to before? I'm not going to read all your games

[ManWithNoName]

2148 Its not hard to find after it was my last complete game.

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=83299

OH, 2148 is the game, not a post! I'm an idiot

[ManWithNoName]

Except for when he tried to claim I was his partner at the end of the day. I didn't interact with him during my VLA because I was VLA and as far as I remember he didn't say much during the first day until after the hammer.

[ManWithNoName]

I'm just saying explicitly naming a partner post lynch is either game throwing if true or a lie, and the dude seemed to be intent on playing towards his wincon

[ManWithNoName]

Yeah it's Taylor

[ManWithNoName]

Plus the VC you used had my RVS vote based on a book I was reading

[ManWithNoName]

Why are we wagoning bob and not EWD?

No one knows who EWD is other than you

[ManWithNoName]

Like, I know that really doesn't answer the question, but in its current form, the question has no answer.

[ManWithNoName]

I just want to know who EWD is!

[ManWithNoName]

This is like one of those mystery books, but there aren't enough clues to figure it out.

[ManWithNoName]

I watched all of it, and not really...

I mean, the Island is made of earth, planes fly on the wind and there is fire.

[ManWithNoName]

VOTE: TSwift

Yeah, this is good elim.

[ManWithNoName]

I have no clue what I would have done as scum.

[ManWithNoName]

I know some of those words.

[ManWithNoName]

gimme time and ill give you town.

You think you’ve seen town? I’LL SHOW YOU TOWN!
I’LL HAVE YOU EATING SCUM AND CRAPPING VICTORY!!

And you'll move like Greased lightning.

[ManWithNoName]

Penguin, where your reads at?

[ManWithNoName]

Interesting like an episode of Ozark interesting or interesting like Sherlock Holmes finds a clue interesting?

[ManWithNoName]

(you're mrs hudson here - if that wasn't clear)

[ManWithNoName]

saw that coming

[ManWithNoName]

This is a really bad detective flik. It's so easy.

Someone else please edit this to be a Detective Flik, I have no photoshop.

[ManWithNoName]

unofficial vote count 3.08

Tayl0r Swift (5): NorwegianboyEE, ManWithNoName, Isis, bob3141, Not_Mafia
bob3141 (3): Bambi Jay, Tayl0r Swift, Lost

Not voting: PenguinPower

Deadline: (expired on 2020-09-30 08:00:00)

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to eliminate.


mod notes:
- bray.

I hate this, it murders my eyes in blue. Therefore, Green works better.

[ManWithNoName]

I like the color red better.
Because that's the color of Taylors flip☆

FTFY

[ManWithNoName]

I live closer to an anarchic region than Washington DC, according to the attorney general.

I also think last scum might just be bob.

[ManWithNoName]

we should have a hider with 3 inno. So i think the game is solved. Plus a tracker who should also have inno

We don't necessarily have three new innos though, if they checked a player that died N2 or N3, we don't have full solve.

Also, not everyone has posted yet so how would we know tracker has an inno and not a guilty?

Lots of heavy assuming here.

[ManWithNoName]

Also there could be overlapping innos. We do not definitely have a mechanical solve right now. We may, but chances are low

[ManWithNoName]

Yeah. I do think that unless we have two people dead of the hiders checks, which is highly unlikely, Hider revealing the clears just wins us the game.

[ManWithNoName]

I mean a pool of three is a winning strategy right now. We have two miseliminations left, if my math is correct

[ManWithNoName]

HA, TAKE THAT, DUCKO!

[ManWithNoName]

I'd like to give an opportunity to Penguin to at least come in and make a claim and I also can't count so no vote yet, but this game is pretty much solved. I figured out Day 3 that Norwee was Hider so, I do kind of feel like Bob could have and found a better shot than NM. I would think he would have shot in Norwee's early day town reads

[ManWithNoName]

DUCKO just doesn't like fun. He told me one time

[ManWithNoName]

Who was tracker?

[ManWithNoName]

Oh I'm a dummy

[ManWithNoName]

Well thank you to my second favorite site mod for the game. When I talk to my favorite people just think I'm crazy

[ManWithNoName]

Do my PMs get published?

[ManWithNoName]

Oh good

[ManWithNoName]

Do my PMs get published?

don't worry, they're between you and me. :*

Oh good

Now I’m wondering what was in those PMs...

They were dirty. I dropped so much peanut butter and jelly on them it was gross