newbie 2060: creatures, game ofer

[WhemeStar]

Hihi VOTE: endless dark

I like a wagon

L-2 btw. Which means 2 more votes is a hammer which is a flip. Something we don’t want currently.

[WhemeStar]

no triple hmmmmm?

[WhemeStar]

UNVOTE:

[WhemeStar]

Why

I liked the posts.

[WhemeStar]

I don't have any scum pings from anyone yet and thats sad;/

[WhemeStar]

VOTE: WhemeStar for shying away from the vote.

How is that shying away?

[WhemeStar]

VOTE: whemestar

Only person I have gotten scum vibes from. His "voting for the same thing is something we don't want" while simultaneously joining a wagon felt off to me lol.

Btw, today is my husbands birthday, so I probably won't check this forum again until in the morning. Promise to be more after that tho

The wagon was formed before endlessdark made a post, so a hammer to that isn’t what we wanted currently. It was used to get test endless darks reactions, which I liked. So I un voted.

[WhemeStar]

That post feels a bit scummy to me.

Which one?

[WhemeStar]

The one right above mine, i.e. Wheme's second post. Too defensive.

Don't you think I should be defensive at L-1?

[WhemeStar]

endlessdark wasn't.

Would love to see the vote actually reaching majority, but that will probably never happen.

So do you agree with me that you liked his posts

[WhemeStar]

So do you agree with me that you liked his posts

Enough to have a much scummier target to go for, yes.

So if you agree with me that you like his posts why did you not like my unvote?

[WhemeStar]

Why so?

That post was meant to be tongue-in-cheek, of course day won't end this early. My point was that

no one

would have the guts to dump the final vote on WhemeStar, so his E-1 argument was largely moot.

Unless early D1 majority votes are common here, in which case I stand corrected.

My last 2 newbie games had a d1 quick hammer for 0 reason

[WhemeStar]

So if you agree with me that you like his posts why did you not like my unvote?

You can misinterpret what I said in any way you want, but you won't bait me into saying something I don't agree with. I said I had a scummier target to go for (aka you, after you immediately unvoted once endlessdark appeared in the thread).

You still haven't convinced me that you're not scum.

How is that misinterpreting what you said

[WhemeStar]

I asked if you liked his posts and you said yes

[WhemeStar]

I said

Enough to have a much scummier target to go for, yes.

What does "much scummier" imply?

But what was scummy about me was my unvote which I don’t understand why you think it’s scummy when you think his posts were good?

[WhemeStar]

I just don’t get how you can scumread someone I scumread and vote me unless you think I bussed

[WhemeStar]

Whemestar's original post:

Hihi VOTE: endless dark

I like a wagon

L-2 btw. Which means 2 more votes is a hammer which is a flip. Something we don’t want currently.

(1) You were only the third vote on the endlessdark wagon, (2) you voted when it was clearly still RVS, and (3) how can you scumread someone who hadn't even posted yet when you voted for them?

Oh yeah i guess that’s true. So you scumread both of us but just me more p

[WhemeStar]

I missed that part of claskos post

Clasko why do you townread both of us if you don’t think it’s a WvW argument?

[WhemeStar]

(1) You were only the third vote on the endlessdark wagon, (2) you voted when it was clearly still RVS, and (3) how can you scumread someone who hadn't even posted yet when you voted for them?

I think Demainer is on point here and WhemeStar's frustration is not the towniest thing ever either.

What frustration?

[WhemeStar]

VOTE: Endlessdark

[WhemeStar]

Ivy is a strong townread for me

mod could you please add day timers to vote counts

[WhemeStar]

What frustration?

VOTE: Endlessdark

This made me lol.

I don’t think I have came off as frustrated at all and am confused on why you think that

[WhemeStar]

Your tunneling hard and already want a flip on page 5?

[WhemeStar]

I don’t like how you are set on me being the flip on page 5

[WhemeStar]

What do you think of endless darks latest posts?

[WhemeStar]

To clarify -- I'm down to eliminate WhemeStar. I'm not voting him yet in order to prolong the day / get more info.

I'm a little bit concerned about my read, though. WhemeStar, your play isn't ideal so far, but you almost feel like an obvious elimination. Despite the fact that there's rational arguments against you, the ones Demainer pointed out, and your vote on me which seemed rash, my read on you is more based on feeling ultimately. You could just be having a bad game. Do you genuinely think I'm mafia and if so mind elaborating?

I think you were trying to make up a reason for scumreading me and it sounded made up and fake

[WhemeStar]

What game did I play with you before? Was it the newbie I got night killed n1?

[WhemeStar]

Demainer can you answer post #40

[WhemeStar]

Why would I vote him in the first place then if I was scum?

[WhemeStar]

What your saying makes no sense if I’m scum.

[WhemeStar]

I randomly vote someone to get a wagon going and then immediately unvote as scum and then I try to shy away from my random vote?

Why do I need to defend/shy away a random vote

[WhemeStar]

Obvious scum tactic to protect yourself after shying away from the vote

Literally every alignment gives a reason to unvote this is NAI

[WhemeStar]

It’s just the vibes man

[WhemeStar]

Demainer your posts irk me

They irk me too but I don’t know if it’s OMGUS bias that makes me feel that way.

[WhemeStar]

VOTE: Lukewarm

[WhemeStar]

I don't understand why we need role claims so early in the game, it's only going to hurt town? Unless there are special mechanics in this setup I'm not aware of.

Not getting town vibes from that recent post.

That’s why I voted them

[WhemeStar]

If we take like 8 days to get one person to L-1, I would be concerned only having 2 days to rebuild a whole wagon from scratch. We seem like a slow moving lobby lol.

In like 90% of games a wagon can form in an hour on the final day.

[WhemeStar]

I think the person who best shares my reads is saudale so I want to talk to them.

[WhemeStar]

VOTE: Ahri

Idk anymore

[WhemeStar]

Does no one else share my feelings of icky against Dem??

i said i did

[WhemeStar]

Where is your vote though

VOTE: demainer

[WhemeStar]

also b4 mod gets on my ass for not posting a meaningful post,

I'm probably voting mafia.

thank!

Why do you think your voting mafia

[WhemeStar]

I don’t like how this game stagnated out with me being the leading wagon.

[WhemeStar]

What sucks is Im not good at leading games when it’s near deadline

[WhemeStar]

Saudale do you have experience with ahri?

[WhemeStar]

I don’t really like any of the votes on me :/

[WhemeStar]

Also, I apologize to Wheme if I'm wrong with my vote. I can't really say I've seen something that makes me think you're genuinely helping the town. That doesn't necessarily make you maf, but it's more than what I have on others.

Do you think ahri is helping the town more than me then?

[WhemeStar]

Also, I apologize to Wheme if I'm wrong with my vote. I can't really say I've seen something that makes me think you're genuinely helping the town. That doesn't necessarily make you maf, but it's more than what I have on others.

Do you think ahri is helping the town more than me then?

Do you think your helping the town by getting prodded and being bored with the game?

[WhemeStar]

I'm still outing my thoughts, silly. Doesn't mean I can't get bored at any point during the game

Getting prodded and being inactive this close to deadline is anti-town though. How do you not see that?

[WhemeStar]

You've got plenty more posts than her but your posts' content isn't really helping.

How am I not helping?

[WhemeStar]

Also, I apologize to Wheme if I'm wrong with my vote. I can't really say I've seen something that makes me think you're genuinely helping the town. That doesn't necessarily make you maf, but it's more than what I have on others.

Do you think ahri is helping the town more than me then?

ahri not posting is not helping anyone, but I prefer to deal with concrete information based on threadplay rather than random guesswork. Inactivity is NAI. Also, everyone apart from ahri has been active today, so I don't see any reason to policy lynch for inactivity.

Theres a difference in inactivity and coasting though

[WhemeStar]

Why has my posting given you scum vibes

[WhemeStar]

Can I get everyone's thoughts on endless dark?

[WhemeStar]

Also, I apologize to Wheme if I'm wrong with my vote. I can't really say I've seen something that makes me think you're genuinely helping the town. That doesn't necessarily make you maf, but it's more than what I have on others.

I don't see this post coming from town

[WhemeStar]

Or better, to not care so much about being eliminated, since we're all cannon fodder anyway, and even a miselimination can give good info.

But we’re not all cannon fodder

[WhemeStar]

Ivy do you townread demainer?

[WhemeStar]

VOTE: Ahri

[WhemeStar]

First sentence seems lamist but I don't really see the issue with the rest of the post. 115 feels off to me though.

It makes me think that he doesn't have any scumreads and I think scum have trouble getting scumreads.

[WhemeStar]

UNVOTE:

WhemeStar I am prepared to hammer when I log on tomorrow, so go ahead and claim your role.

I’m confused

Are you still planning on hammering me?

[WhemeStar]

Luke what would your reads look like if I said both ahri and I are town?

[WhemeStar]

Also I’m VT so feel free to hammer whenever unless other ppl have things to say.

I think towns pretty fucked here because I’m not even confident ahri is scum here. The issue with me is no one has really obv Towned this game which is where I usually start my reads. Very possible both wagons are Town which would be unfortunate. I do think though that scum are in the lurkers as I think scum here try to not say anything and drag the game out as much as they can so we are “forced” to mislynch.

I can’t really give a final read list because as I said no one here is obv town and I have to many scumreads. Let’s just say I still think every person here has a chance of being scum but I’m more certain That there’s scum on both wagons rather than two scum on one wagon.

That’s all I got feel free to hammer anytime ggs see you guys in dead/end thread

[WhemeStar]

Well gl finding scum on my wagon

[WhemeStar]

I don't think theres any obv town on my wagon so that sucks.

[WhemeStar]

Actually before thread gets locked ima go out on a limb and say both ahri and i are town

[WhemeStar]

Scum are in luke ivy demainer endless

[WhemeStar]

Looking at voting patterns our wagons don't make sense.

[WhemeStar]

GL guys I think this will be hard for town judging by how slow game is and how people are getting "bored" of the game. That's not a good look for town and lets scum coast to victory. Sorry I couldn't be the town leader we needed.