Mafiascum.net

You may discuss here at all times.

Dunnstral
Vanderscamp
GuiltyLion
Hopkirk
Lukewarm
marcistar

Ego

Hello

id

In post 2, Lukewarm wrote:Hello

Bestie, hru?

Do you like ur role this game..? Can I trust you?

In post 4, marcistar wrote:

In post 2, Lukewarm wrote:Hello

Bestie, hru?

Do you like ur role this game..? Can I trust you?

You can trust me, but... can I trust you?

I could imagine you putting us in the same neighborhood after asking me to sign up with you

In post 5, Lukewarm wrote:

In post 4, marcistar wrote:

In post 2, Lukewarm wrote:Hello

Bestie, hru?

Do you like ur role this game..? Can I trust you?

You can trust me, but... can I trust you?

I could imagine you putting us in the same neighborhood after asking me to sign up with you

yeah yeah ofcofc i put us in the same neighborhood and just forgot about norwegienboyee

bestie you forgot some of the questions

Yeah, I skipped them because I thought it would give you the wrong idea.

I am town, but I am not happy with my role

But Norwee not being in here is a good point. I forgot he was in the last game, because he died before I replaced in lol

In post 7, Lukewarm wrote:Yeah, I skipped them because I thought it would give you the wrong idea.

I am town, but I am not happy with my role

Spoiler:

It feels like I am always vanilla townie

isn't this game only vts for the townside? im confused on the setup if its not like that LOL
you wanted to be a dirty scummy?

Where I play usually with my friend, people underestimate vts a heckton.

In post 9, marcistar wrote:

In post 7, Lukewarm wrote:Yeah, I skipped them because I thought it would give you the wrong idea.

I am town, but I am not happy with my role

Spoiler:

It feels like I am always vanilla townie

isn't this game only vts for the townside? im confused on the setup if its not like that LOL
you wanted to be a dirty scummy?

Where I play usually with my friend, people underestimate vts a heckton.

Spoiler:

tbh ur post gave me the wrong idea either way, because it looks like you just jumped to the most accusational thing, while i'm just trying to make talk.

Yeah, I think being scum at least once would be neat.

I have been vanilla townie in every completed game I have been in

In post 10, Lukewarm wrote:

In post 9, marcistar wrote:

In post 7, Lukewarm wrote:Yeah, I skipped them because I thought it would give you the wrong idea.

I am town, but I am not happy with my role

Spoiler:

It feels like I am always vanilla townie

isn't this game only vts for the townside? im confused on the setup if its not like that LOL
you wanted to be a dirty scummy?

Where I play usually with my friend, people underestimate vts a heckton.

Spoiler:

tbh ur post gave me the wrong idea either way, because it looks like you just jumped to the most accusational thing, while i'm just trying to make talk.

Yeah, I think being scum at least once would be neat.

I have been vanilla townie in every completed game I have been in

scum is so hard tho.. what would you do if you were scum?

before last game i've only been vt
vt is so much better for me, because i can pressure people without caring about consequences.

--
bro wtf, wheres my teacher all my classmates are here

hi diddly ho neighborinos

do you all see any real value we can get out of this neighborhood? I feel like neighborhoods are most useful when they're not known to the rest of the playerbase, I don't know if there's anything I'd rather post in here than the main thread

In post 12, GuiltyLion wrote:hi diddly ho neighborinos

do you all see any real value we can get out of this neighborhood? I feel like neighborhoods are most useful when they're not known to the rest of the playerbase, I don't know if there's anything I'd rather post in here than the main thread

I'm not sure. I think that the neighborhoods may be a bit more beneficial for the 3 person neighborhood, because the town players over there know that they are in a room with exactly 1 scum and 1 town, so it is a narrower lens to examine.

In post 11, marcistar wrote: scum is so hard tho.. what would you do if you were scum?

before last game i've only been vt
vt is so much better for me, because i can pressure people without caring about consequences.

--
bro wtf, wheres my teacher all my classmates are here

If I were scum, I probably would have put myself in the 3p neighborhood, because it seems important for the better/more experienced scum player to be in this neighborhood.

It could have been funny to put me + you + Norwee all in the 3p neighborhood. Because I might be able to convince Norwee that you would have designed our neighborhood that way

I don't know that that is the best trio, and I would have had to have run that by my partner, but I think I would have pressed pretty hard to be in the 3p set up.

In post 14, Lukewarm wrote:If I were scum, I probably would have put myself in the 3p neighborhood, because it seems important for the better/more experienced scum player to be in this neighborhood.

It could have been funny to put me + you + Norwee all in the 3p neighborhood. Because I might be able to convince Norwee that you would have designed our neighborhood that way

I don't know that that is the best trio, and I would have had to have run that by my partner, but I think I would have pressed pretty hard to be in the 3p set up.

What do you think of the trio neighborhood so far?
-
Tbh i'm easy to manipulate sometimes, so u better not be scum

So far I am leaning Not_Mafia. But then I have a physiological negative reaction to having a Day 1 scum read on Not_Mafia :sick:

I am cautious of giving Bingle a TR though. I have not finished my other game with him yet, but the way everyone else speaks of him makes me worried about facing him as scum in the future.

Norwee's reaction to Not_Mafia seems the same as I saw in our last game, and the fact that he is pushing for us to vote in the 6P neighborhood gives him bonus points imo.

So I think I am currently leaning Not_Mafia > Bingle > Norwee

In post 12, GuiltyLion wrote:hi diddly ho neighborinos

do you all see any real value we can get out of this neighborhood? I feel like neighborhoods are most useful when they're not known to the rest of the playerbase, I don't know if there's anything I'd rather post in here than the main thread

Was thinking more about this, and realized that our neighborhood will probably be more powerful once we have purged the scum from it, because it will be only confirmed town in here.

I think Bingle is still the most likely scum in the trio tbh. I was waiting to see if he was gonna add any more thoughts after he emphasized that giving cross-group reads was important, but he hasn't said much beyond a townread on Dunn and a scumread on me, and he's not really pushing the scumread on me at all

Lukewarm, assuming you're town, you should move your vote to within our group. I frankly wouldn't mind if you even wanted to push me a little bit, I'm kinda starting to see you as potential town now and I'm curious to see if Bingle/N_M run with a scumread on me if you voiced more interest there. That said, I don't wanna pressure you to play in any kind of way, so do whatever you think is best, but could be an interesting gambit/reaction test to consider. I'm trying to think of creative ways we can use this hood

You realize mafia have day talk, right?

lol I honestly hadn't realized that until I just thought to check and was about to post in here again. I actually think that makes Lukewarm a lot more likely town as I think he probably thought he was giving an honest read without Bingle/NM likely to see it too, it definitely put me in that headspace

this setup would be better without mafia daytalk IMO, it makes the hood almost completely pointless unless we eliminate the scum from it. I guess scum have to be careful about not slipping that they know what was discussed in the other hood, but that doesn't seem that difficult

Dunnstral what's your read on Bingle

I get the feeling that the neighborhoods are good for the basic information that we gained of there being exactly 1 in each, and the chat is probably better for the people in the 3p chat to be able to solve that neighborhood, and the 6p chat will become really useful after the scum is eliminated.

I agree that this neighborhood seems a bit useless atm, but that is not necessarily a flaw with the setup, I mean most 9 player games are filled with 5 vanilla townies, so we are the 5 town players that are filling that space in this set up.

In post 22, GuiltyLion wrote:this setup would be better without mafia daytalk IMO, it makes the hood almost completely pointless unless we eliminate the scum from it. I guess scum have to be careful about not slipping that they know what was discussed in the other hood, but that doesn't seem that difficult

I mean it would be better for the town to mafia to lose day talk, but I don't know that that would make the setup better or not. Do you think that the mafia are in need of a nerf? They already have the nerf that one person cannot ever bus the other Day 1 no matter what.