Mafiascum.net

"Split Judgement - Team Blue"

All players vote to nominate a player on the opposite team.
They will be put up for elimination once both teams reconvene.

---

DECISION 4.0

Team Pink Members:

ulyana, skitter30, Infinity 324, Toogeloo, Dwlee99, Taly

Not Voting [7]:

petapan, Ydrasse, Saber, SirCakez, Gypyx, unwnd, Gamma Emerald

With 7 players on the team, it takes 4 votes to decide. If deadline is reached, plurality is in effect.

Link to deadline timer. If the other team makes a decision, the timer is set to 48 hours.

[/mech]

Now playing..

♫

Young the Giant - Cough Syrup

♫
                        

▶ ❚❚ ────────────────────────────── 0:00 / 4:09

                       

Is it wrong to think that I don't think Toog is any more or less cleared lol

In post 2, unwnd wrote:Is it wrong to think that I don't think Toog is any more or less cleared lol

i don't think any of that is remotely clearing

I'm Blue da ba dee da ba daa
Da ba dee da ba daa

second spin from dunn was kinda weird in the duel, like, why would you re-randomize the random? Think we haven't been told all the info but whatever really

i

have absolutely no clue who i want to nominate though

maybe it's best to agree on a pool of peeps we're not nomming to start things off?

In post 4, Gypyx wrote:I'm Blue da ba dee da ba daa
Da ba dee da ba daa

second spin from dunn was kinda weird in the duel, like, why would you re-randomize the random? Think we haven't been told all the info but whatever really

it was weird, i think it was trying to offload the risk? but using the spin there isn't really optimal, i would have told him to shoot at toog

wdym by "offload the risk"?

btw cakez - you were absolutely right about dunn being in scum meta, although the reason i reversed on him was a little different

i was giving him too much credit for posts i remembered in the moment and on a reread of the iso he scumclaimed, not going to explain it here, might tell you in post

In post 1, Morning Tweet wrote:Link to deadline timer. If the other team makes a decision, the timer is set to 48 hours.

Note that I added a clarification to the deadline timer.

could you maybe make a post in the main thread if the deadline gets reduced please?

I will do so both in the main thread and in here.

also, i re-read the duel, and like, does dunn really bother to make that big wall of text only to randomize it all if they were both stagehands?

pedit : neat

In post 8, Gypyx wrote:wdym by "offload the risk"?

first one to shoot risks dying, i dunno, if he waits he gets a trigger pull that has a higher chance of killing toog

if both sides play optimally the expected winrate for the game is 50/50 but there's a chance the first shooter can misplay it

In post 13, Gypyx wrote:also, i re-read the duel, and like, does dunn really bother to make that big wall of text only to randomize it all if they were both stagehands?

pedit : neat

i

don't see why he wouldn't


like if we actually got dueling scum wagons they'd be obligated to theater it up - him asking toog what his read on him was odd


this is purely hypothetical i'm not keen on going back to the well with toogeloo but the immediate impulse to clear him isn't a good one based on available evidence

but i'll go over everyone individually

I also felt it was theater

most of the stuff i had from his iso was relevant to people in this room unfortunately

while going through i noticed this, though:

2276
2279

first glance, surface level read is this is a good look for skitter given him popping off at the fos from her?

The consensus felt on Dunn when we all agreed to pit him and Toog off felt good. I'm glad I trashed my read early.

I think I would be..alright with thinking Cakez is fine for now because I don't think Dunn's strongsuit as a scum is to distance his partners effectively, he's more of an oasis

In a vacuum I think his Taly takes and interactions look decent as well

dwlee i just

do not think they bus dunn in that manner at all

i haven't reread the iso to check yet

I'm glad I was basically right about dunn
his scumplay recently has felt extremely one-dimensional ngl
I also think I'm borderline obvtown based on how he pushed against me

I don't feel like that event really helped to bring toog into the light like I'd hoped it might
the two of them felt very terse so it very well could have been S/S

I also think it could be S/S lol

unwnd's attitude seems to have perked up based on his posting in here tho, which is prolly a good sign for him

In post 15, petapan wrote:

In post 13, Gypyx wrote:also, i re-read the duel, and like, does dunn really bother to make that big wall of text only to randomize it all if they were both stagehands?

pedit : neat

i

don't see why he wouldn't


like if we actually got dueling scum wagons they'd be obligated to theater it up - him asking toog what his read on him was odd


this is purely hypothetical i'm not keen on going back to the well with toogeloo but the immediate impulse to clear him isn't a good one based on available evidence

but i'll go over everyone individually

yeah it was super akward i agree, but like, not necessarily theater

like, in my eyes, toog's reaction doesn't fit a scum theater as he would've rolled with it way more than he did there as a scum, unless like, dunn started it on his own and toog was like "yo why you doing this it's scummy af"
but even then, not the most likely thing ever