In post 827, Color Blue wrote:I have trouble believing it's artificial from Green!scum because he pushed at you ~12m after replace in.
IMO that's far too short a time for someone to rep in, see they are scum, then scan the thread for things to attack with.
The belief that you are mafia because of that post should probably have been formed prior to replacing in, making it a belief Green had prior to receiving his role pm....
I guess it's possible he's a very daring scumbag who has no hesitation about getting into it aggressively right off the bat but I don't often see that.
I am wondering do you have any reason to townread Heart? I don't think there was anything in his iso that seemed townie and Circle does make a good case that he does seem to be just coasting with making some very noncommital comments.
I think they picked someone at random and went after them thinking their aggresiveness would look townie. They didn't have time to build a case bforehand which is why they don't have a case on me (one line is not a case, and attacking a specific post is usually scum indicitive)
Alternatively, they weren't satisfied with the gamestate as it was when they replaced in.
This would implicate the unpaired shapes as potential partners, but may not be the case.
As for heart, I don't townread them. They are scummy independantly of green. But I don't think their dynamic with green is s/s, and green's play looks like textbook scum play to me.