Mini 2266: GnG's Upick Mafia [GAME OVER]

[Reinhardt]

Egoposting.
Whatever pick I get, I hope it’s given its due.

[Reinhardt]

I would like to participate in the challenge.

I think I will make the sacrifice of figuring out what “one-shot miller” means here. It says that the details will be revealed once the ability is selected.

1

[Reinhardt]

I would like to state my role as it is is not great but I expect it to be by design, where getting hit with an engineer would assist me rather substantially. As such, I would like to have one used on me earlier rather than later.

In addition, I feel like my skillset makes sense to my flavor, if not to my role.

2

[Reinhardt]

I want it on record that I have never before received a role that is more in line with my skillset
3

Eh, my role's deserved--it's a tradition for me to submit trollish picks in Ginngie games and for Ginngie to then punish me for having done so. I do need to constantly say I am town (because I am in fact town), but the role itself is quite good imo.

I don't believe you.

You better tho since I am in fact town.

I would like to participate in the challenge.

Town?

I will participate

Scum. </3

3/5

My role could be described as one of the most brutal interpretations of a pick to date. So I believe what you are saying.

3

[Reinhardt]

I notice a couple things in the vote count post. First, the notation of how close someone is to being voted out seems to still be based on the “L-word”. Also, despite the rules saying simple majority is required to vote someone out, the vote count seems to indicate the person with most votes would be ejected at deadline.

4

[Reinhardt]

GeTtInG tHiS oUt Of ThE wAy.

5

[Reinhardt]

In that case I will not be picking up the Miller unless I want the doctor ability from the Mage tree.

1

[Reinhardt]

I misthought something. No dual lim today.

UNVOTE: Gypyx

3

Now I'm curious what your idea was.

[Reinhardt]

Fair enough.

3

[Reinhardt]

This game seems a little stagnant, and while I'm not in a state to focus on things here currently, I would at least like to move things along so when I am in the mood things will be more active.
VOTE: Dunnstral
Out of the existing votes, this is the one I like the most. I don't really get the issue about scum knowing or not knowing certain things but the other votes either feel barely substantiated or are not ones I agree with.

4

[Reinhardt]

PlEaSe LeT mE kNoW iF yOu HaVe AnYtHiNg FoR mE.

5

[Reinhardt]

This game seems a little stagnant, and while I'm not in a state to focus on things here currently, I would at least like to move things along so when I am in the mood things will be more active.
VOTE: Dunnstral
Out of the existing votes, this is the one I like the most. I don't really get the issue about scum knowing or not knowing certain things but the other votes either feel barely substantiated or are not ones I agree with.

4

This doesn't make sense

1

How so?

1

[Reinhardt]

VOTE: mastina

Lal

VOTE: Yume

while i'm at it

Why did you opt to vote Yume for this?

2

[Reinhardt]

Based on their interactions though, mastina and Yume seem acquainted. Wouldn’t Yume probably have some idea of how to react, then?

3

[Reinhardt]

I’ll grant that the reaction might be forced, but I don’t think the interpretation is as clear-cut as you do.

4

[Reinhardt]

I aM hErE.

5

[Reinhardt]

VOTE: Shiro

What is going on with her? She said she would be here yesterday and she didn’t show up.

1

[Reinhardt]

Why?

2

[Reinhardt]

Reinhardt: game is stall, lets vote and make convo

same person park vote on dunnestral saying cause its only wagon existing he can support

doesn't clarify why, doesn't ask a question, doesn't even engage with the slot = was pretty much just a RVS vote ...


typical lazy scum act or just a lazy town, it's still one of the stuff to note and keep in mind. Will become a meaningful read when you see a pattern of behavior/actions and reactions in thread.

Why do you think it's a bad reason to FoS someone or do you just find dunn shipping it bad as it's somehow about his own slot?

4

The Gypyx wagon was swollen, and mastina felt town to me. Between Yume and Dunn, while it wasn’t much, there was some stuff regarding Dunn that made him a vote I felt was reasonably good.

3

[Reinhardt]

To point 1, I think I already established what my logic was, but to make it completely clear, I was picking between people with votes on them already.
As for what seemed reasonably good, there was talk of your idea of the skillset hoods being linked to skill trees being misinformed and you being scum for it. While I cannot say I processed the entire logic chain at the moment I voted, and I actually still wonder what Titus is talking about when saying scum would know why you are wrong, the thing that resonates with me was something about the way you presented your argument felt off: why are you claiming that you know these inner workings of the skillset hoods? I feel like further discussion demonstrates that it was just a hunch?

4

[Reinhardt]

I aM bAcK.
wOuLd LiKe If DuNn WoUlD rEsPoNd To My ReToRt.
I tHiNk ScUm ArE iN sOmE wAy InDiSpOsEd To ThE sItUaTiOn ReGaRdInG gYpYx.

5

[Reinhardt]

I posted this in my hood like a week ago but nobody said shit so I'm gonna go public with it now:

my solve rn is Mastina - LLD - Gypyx

Gypyx is cuz the dude is frozen scum

LLD is because Gypyx was frozen scum last time in Tenet when we played scum with him and LLD should want to yeet him out a window

Mastina is because her scumread of me is fake as fuck and not how town her treats me when she suspects I am scum because town her has suspected me many times and none have been as weak as this.

This concludes your scheduled content posting from me and I will go back to shitposting pls yeet Gypyx out a window thank you.

Also just another reminder that NOBODY SHOULD TARGET ME AT NIGHT because if I don't get targeted cool shit happens the next day thank you very much.

4

I mentioned yesterday I felt scum were unable or unwilling to address the Gypyx wagon. Do you think LLD does nothing here as scum in either direction with Gypyx as her partner?
To Dunnstral: I guess that answers my question, but it doesn’t make me feel better about you. My issue really is that you spoke with false authority.

1

[Reinhardt]

I don't expect my day 1 solves to be correct

3

Why would you post it then?

2

[Reinhardt]

Is LLD in a hood? She's not in mine, and you're not claiming she's in yours Pooky. It only leaves whatever one Titus/Enchant/Shiro/Gypy is in.

PE: So Pooky is in the Warrior hood. Why were you forced to invest in the Mage skill tree?

3

Scum probably know who is in which hood at this point unless they’re all crammed into the same one. I don’t think secrecy was all that important but that ship has just about sailed.
To PookyBear: I can get that desire.

3

[Reinhardt]

(Just to remind y'all, yes, I am town.)

Go on about his Pokémon style plz

Well if you read Pooky v Koba from that game (a predecessor to the Pooky v Milobird which was similar but imo Pooky v Koba is a better comparison) it's legit Pooky from this game.

I have very little engagement in this meta debate currently.

I will say, however, PookyBear seems wholly disinterested in things that might be able to presumably help him solve people.
VOTE: PookyBear

4

[Reinhardt]

Shiro's posting is really lame.

Yume posting AtE is really lame.

Enchant feels like town this game.

I assume we have a reason to keep Gypyx alive.

Would maybe vote for Pooky. I don't like that 401 only makes sense if Gypyx is scum, could be focusing on the wrong thing as scum.

VOTE: Shiro

4

InTeReStInG yOu VoTe ShIrO oUt Of AlL tHrEe SuSpEcTs YoU lIsTeD, gIvEn My VoTe WaS tHeRe AnD yOu ThOuGhT i WaS sUsPiCiOuS?

5

[Reinhardt]

Titus, can I just check you understand the following;

The engineer ability upgrades someone else
You can't upgrade yourself with it. If Gypyx wants to get upgrade it makes sense for Gypyx to move the experience to someone else who can then upgrade them


2

-Giving one person all of the experience is a bad idea for multiple obvious reasons.
-Experience can be passed between two people who share a hood of any kind at a 1:1 rate. For example, LLD should be able to share experience with her mason partner regardless of whether or not they have the same skill related hood.
-From what Enchant has said, the 0.5 exp ability is just a separate target anyone thing.

You aren't coming across to me as the more coherent perspective any more, Titus. I think the bad assumptions are on your side of the argument.



3

I'd rather it die than go to scum or give scum an excuse to have visited town.
If experience can only be passed via hoods, then Enchant must have a hood with mastina.
There's no reason for Enchant to blackmail Gypyx to try and get the experience rather than give it to me. Enchant doesn't want exp in town hands. Enchant wants control. Scum's only move is to block conftowns and seize power themselves.
I may not have all the answers but I see a very boned scumteam. I don't make perfect sense because I can't know exactly how Enchant will sabotage but they will.

As I see it regardless of alignment Enchant wants to figure out as much about the game as possible, and if she's town presumably she can and will share that information with everyone after?

1

[Reinhardt]

I did blackmail Gypix though. I still consider i could waste XP better.


Also. I already gived solution.
WAIT MOMENT WHERE WE PLAN TO HAMMER SOMEONE, RETRY, POST 5 SENSELESS POSTS, GG YOU DONE CHALLENGE CAN HAMMER.

Is that's SO HARD?

2

Challenge requires 48 hours to pass. This plan doesn't work.

2

[Reinhardt]

Let me get into why I think Pooky isn't actually genuinely caring about solving.

what if gypyx is scum with a really cool ability that he wants to live to night to use?

then you are just being a useful tool for him and chainsawing the shit out of me for literally no reason


also i dont know if you've noticed

BUT I CANT FUCKING SEE WHAT GYPYX IS SAYING IN YOUR HOOD

so if im reading his play IN THREAD as being scum!gypyx and you're saying nah this guy is town cuz he's saying some shit in the hood that can only be town

then like you kind of have to show me?

i am town

if you dont want to work with me and just want to yeet me for ????? reasons then that's on you.


3

i also dont actually give a fuck if this town wants to drive off the edge of a cliff cuz sekrit hood shenanigans i have no patience for idiocy

4

I see these posts, and I realize if part of this debate is that Gypyx's skillset hood is unverified, I can rectify that with something I have access to. I can pick a player and slide into their skillset hood at-will. So I bring this up in my own skillset hood with Pooky to see what his thoughts are, and he gets cheesed at me thinking he gives a damn. Even after I establish what reason I had for bringing this to his attention, he doesn't seem to care.

3

[Reinhardt]

This is my ability, and i choose how i use it. I don't townread Titus nor Gypix (atleast now), there's simple practical reason to let them live.

You acting surprised when more than one player want you dead is strange.

4

Wait why do you not townread them now when you did before?

4

[Reinhardt]

I aM gOiNg To UsE tHaT aBiLiTy I mEnTiOnEd As TiTuS hAs NoT sHaReD wHaT gYpYx SaId In ThE hOoD yEt.

5

[Reinhardt]

I aM gOiNg To UsE tHaT aBiLiTy I mEnTiOnEd As TiTuS hAs NoT sHaReD wHaT gYpYx SaId In ThE hOoD yEt.

5

Interesting. Come join us. Need to mull what happens strategically from who knows what.

Pray tell who is in your hood again?

It was me, PookyBear, Yume, and jj.

1

[Reinhardt]

I'm not really convinced from what I'm seeing that Gypyx is as obvtown as suggested.

2

[Reinhardt]

I would like to participate in the challenge.

I will not be re-attempting if the first try falls through though.

1

[Reinhardt]

I will always copy this, and then copy this, and then copy this, and then copy this, at the beginning of literally every post after realising it might help other people too.

I have been rather busy these past few days, and I’m also dealing with a bit of fatigue. So I may not be entirely present mentally for a bit.

I will add, since I did happen to catch something about this, that I gave 1 XP to Titus to try and help her be able to upgrade someone, but I think other factors got in the way.

2