BTW, I'll be at Origins from this afternoon to next Monday, so my posting will be sporadic, if existent at all.
Mini 117:Marvel Superheroes Game Over
Forum rules
- mneme
- mneme
-
mneme
- emneme mneme mninie mno
- emneme mneme mninie mno
- Posts: 2443
- Joined: December 24, 2002
- Location: NYC
- Contact:
Phoebus: I try to never assume a game is "normal". If someone insists, without evidence, that there's exactly one serial killer, or 3 mafia, chances are they're selling something (or know something you don't.
But even without that, we had evidence of three killing roles last night: Venom, whoever killed Venom, and whoever killed prof X. The mod has already told us that Venom didn't get a chance to kill (and aside from that, neither kill looks like Venom's signature), so unless a vig unwisely targetted someone on night one, we have at least two killers left -- either the MoD and another mafia, or the MoD and a serial killer (er, or the MoD is a serial killer, obviously).
So....we're down a serial killer....
But even without that, we had evidence of three killing roles last night: Venom, whoever killed Venom, and whoever killed prof X. The mod has already told us that Venom didn't get a chance to kill (and aside from that, neither kill looks like Venom's signature), so unless a vig unwisely targetted someone on night one, we have at least two killers left -- either the MoD and another mafia, or the MoD and a serial killer (er, or the MoD is a serial killer, obviously).
So....we're down a serial killer....
Did I say too much?
- mneme
- mneme
-
mneme
- emneme mneme mninie mno
- emneme mneme mninie mno
- Posts: 2443
- Joined: December 24, 2002
- Location: NYC
- Contact:
I don't think he needs to explain anything. He was away, he came back -- it's not scummy to ignore a 3 vote bandwagon, just a sign of -actually- having limited access (far more scummy is to lurk until you are voted, and then only become active enough to shift attention away from you).Caveman wrote:No, you see, when you say you are away, that means you cannot check nor respond. You could do both, and you chose to not respond.
So I would say that you werenotgenuinely away. That is why you must explain.
Your hounding, on the other hand, would seem to have no excuse.
vote: Caveman
Did I say too much?
- mneme
- mneme
-
mneme
- emneme mneme mninie mno
- emneme mneme mninie mno
- Posts: 2443
- Joined: December 24, 2002
- Location: NYC
- Contact:
That should be a lynch, so I might as well add my voice to
And hey -- the Cypher claim was silly, but who -else- would be a townie in a Marvel game? Rick Jones?
-- Spiral, who like Cypher, is a marvel character out of another age...
(damned roll blocker, spoiling my fun...)
vote: mneme
And hey -- the Cypher claim was silly, but who -else- would be a townie in a Marvel game? Rick Jones?
-- Spiral, who like Cypher, is a marvel character out of another age...
(damned roll blocker, spoiling my fun...)
Did I say too much?
- mneme
- mneme
-
mneme
- emneme mneme mninie mno
- emneme mneme mninie mno
- Posts: 2443
- Joined: December 24, 2002
- Location: NYC
- Contact:
That should be a lynch, so I might as well add my voice to
And hey -- the Cypher claim was silly, but who -else- would be a townie in a Marvel game? Rick Jones?
-- Spiral, who like Cypher, is a marvel character out of another age...
(damned role blocker, spoiling my fun...)
vote: mneme
And hey -- the Cypher claim was silly, but who -else- would be a townie in a Marvel game? Rick Jones?
-- Spiral, who like Cypher, is a marvel character out of another age...
(damned role blocker, spoiling my fun...)
Did I say too much?
- mneme
- mneme
-
mneme
- emneme mneme mninie mno
- emneme mneme mninie mno
- Posts: 2443
- Joined: December 24, 2002
- Location: NYC
- Contact:
All I have to say is...we was robbed.
3 Maf, 1 SK, 8 town, in a game where EVERY TOWNIE HAD AN ABILITY (many of which were better than the "standard" abilities) and no scum did? (Actually, the SK had a decent ability, but got kileld off lucklilly -- in a "normal" game, this would have given the mafia the edge, but since almost every townie had a useful ability, this ended up meaning the maf were doomed...especially with Phoebus voting us off that way (ok, I was doomed from the time I was uber-blocked).
Let's see:
Strange; Immune to night kills (can use ability on others)
Punisher: Supervig (who I didn't realize existed, since I thought we'd killed Venom)
Wolverine: Immune to night kills (can give up ability for a single vig kill)
Cyclops (actually, a town-harmful ability, but a minor one)
Daredevil: Cop
Grey: an actually useless ability (telepath)
Spidey: super-roll blocker (everyone can see who he blocked, so he doesn't have to come out to get someone lynched).
Prof X; Uber-roll blocker (optimal is always to target people with their own ability -- if they're trying to kill, they'll die, otherwise, they'll take minimal harm)
Given this powerful array, the mafia should have had abilities beyond "you're a mafia".
But fun game, everyone!
3 Maf, 1 SK, 8 town, in a game where EVERY TOWNIE HAD AN ABILITY (many of which were better than the "standard" abilities) and no scum did? (Actually, the SK had a decent ability, but got kileld off lucklilly -- in a "normal" game, this would have given the mafia the edge, but since almost every townie had a useful ability, this ended up meaning the maf were doomed...especially with Phoebus voting us off that way (ok, I was doomed from the time I was uber-blocked).
Let's see:
Strange; Immune to night kills (can use ability on others)
Punisher: Supervig (who I didn't realize existed, since I thought we'd killed Venom)
Wolverine: Immune to night kills (can give up ability for a single vig kill)
Cyclops (actually, a town-harmful ability, but a minor one)
Daredevil: Cop
Grey: an actually useless ability (telepath)
Spidey: super-roll blocker (everyone can see who he blocked, so he doesn't have to come out to get someone lynched).
Prof X; Uber-roll blocker (optimal is always to target people with their own ability -- if they're trying to kill, they'll die, otherwise, they'll take minimal harm)
Given this powerful array, the mafia should have had abilities beyond "you're a mafia".
But fun game, everyone!
Did I say too much?