Sid Meier's Civilization 5 UPick Mafia (GAME OVER)

[Kiana Kaslana]

Marshy is rather new.

>looks at my joindate
>looks at titus

these kids never show respect

Wow.

[Joey_]

creature might already be hammered, im unsure tho but i still unvoted to let kiana talk

[Klazam]

By my count, hammered.

Nero's general behavior has been antitown.

Kok- im voting gamma because im pretty sure that's where scum is. if youre so set on me being scum, why do you even care?

[Chara]

i'm still cute and happy.

[Kiana Kaslana]

Oh snap, Creature got hammered even before I returned.

Fortunately, our dearest hosts aren't around. This allows me to sneak in a couple of posts before the thread gets locked.

Confirmed town: Brassherald, Kiana
Townreads: Titus, Varsoon, Chara, Dunkerdoodles, Joey,
Town leans: Kokichi, Nero, Ranmaru, pidgey, Almost50
Null: Jodaxq, ActionDan,

Possibly scum, since they have posted and I don't have a townread on them: Elbirn, Bujaber, Shaziro, Klazam, Gamma Emerald
I have an active scumread on them: Marshy

[Kiana Kaslana]

This game has been more difficult so far as compared to my other games (completed) in which I don't have an instant lock-scumread on players immediately as a matter of fact, and the fact that there has already been 70 pages of content worries me. Scum must be rather strong in this game, I suppose?

[Chara]

talk to me about marshy and dunker if we have time?

pedit: have you played a large theme before, Kiana? this is basically how it always is.

[Chara]

what do you think Creature's flipping?

[Kokichi Oma]

Kiana you have to explain that Dunker read

[Kiana Kaslana]

talk to me about marshy and dunker if we have time?

pedit: have you played a large theme before, Kiana? this is basically how it always is.

Yes, I have time, I'd be happy to talk to you Chara. It's only an issue of whether we get stopped by the hosts if they come online.

I don't like a majority of marshy's posts, they seem actively trying to stay under the radar. However, I'm not very sure about my scumread on him, but he's my top pick for scum at the moment.

Dunker seems town, I don't see any reason to scumread him.

I'm in a couple of ongoing Large Themes. It doesn't matter about the size of the game, I'm usually able to lock down scum easily regardless of size, as you've seen what I did to Dunnstral in Purgatory, and I'm alarmed that I don't have any leads here, even though there are likely 1) More Scum and 2) More Content.

[Kiana Kaslana]

I'm not sure how much of my Dunker read is influenced by his appeasing Aang avatar, to be honest. I swear to goodness, that avatar has an effect on how I read him.

[Joey_]

By my count, hammered.

Nero's general behavior has been antitown.

Kok- im voting gamma because im pretty sure that's where scum is. if youre so set on me being scum, why do you even care?

What general behavior

[Joey_]

Oh snap, Creature got hammered even before I returned.

Fortunately, our dearest hosts aren't around. This allows me to sneak in a couple of posts before the thread gets locked.

Confirmed town: Brassherald, Kiana
Townreads: Titus, Varsoon, Chara, Dunkerdoodles, Joey,
Town leans: Kokichi, Nero, Ranmaru, pidgey, Almost50
Null: Jodaxq, ActionDan,

Possibly scum, since they have posted and I don't have a townread on them: Elbirn, Bujaber, Shaziro, Klazam, Gamma Emerald
I have an active scumread on them: Marshy

What about marshy?

[Kiana Kaslana]

I agree that Nero's general posting style is abrasive and grating, potentially anti-town. I am townleaning him to some extent, though.

[Chara]

Dunker seems town, I don't see any reason to scumread him.

you don't see any reason at all?
and what do you think Creature is flipping?

pedit: hahaha. ignore the avatar! play with an image blocker if you must. :>

[Joey_]

nvm already answered

[Kiana Kaslana]

Oh snap, Creature got hammered even before I returned.

Fortunately, our dearest hosts aren't around. This allows me to sneak in a couple of posts before the thread gets locked.

Confirmed town: Brassherald, Kiana
Townreads: Titus, Varsoon, Chara, Dunkerdoodles, Joey,
Town leans: Kokichi, Nero, Ranmaru, pidgey, Almost50
Null: Jodaxq, ActionDan,

Possibly scum, since they have posted and I don't have a townread on them: Elbirn, Bujaber, Shaziro, Klazam, Gamma Emerald
I have an active scumread on them: Marshy

What about marshy?

Marshy's my scumread. He's at the bottom of my readslist, maybe you missed him.

[Kiana Kaslana]

Dunker seems town, I don't see any reason to scumread him.

you don't see any reason at all?
and what do you think Creature is flipping?

pedit: hahaha. ignore the avatar! play with an image blocker if you must. :>

Probably Creature is scum? I've seen him in Purgatory too, so yeah.

[Kiana Kaslana]

Dunker seems town, I don't see any reason to scumread him.

you don't see any reason at all?
and what do you think Creature is flipping?

pedit: hahaha. ignore the avatar! play with an image blocker if you must. :>

No, then I wouldn't be able to see your avatar and Titus's too :<

Nope, I don't think Dunker is scum. Why do you think he is scum?

[Joey_]

Oh snap, Creature got hammered even before I returned.

Fortunately, our dearest hosts aren't around. This allows me to sneak in a couple of posts before the thread gets locked.

Confirmed town: Brassherald, Kiana
Townreads: Titus, Varsoon, Chara, Dunkerdoodles, Joey,
Town leans: Kokichi, Nero, Ranmaru, pidgey, Almost50
Null: Jodaxq, ActionDan,

Possibly scum, since they have posted and I don't have a townread on them: Elbirn, Bujaber, Shaziro, Klazam, Gamma Emerald
I have an active scumread on them: Marshy

What about marshy?

Marshy's my scumread. He's at the bottom of my readslist, maybe you missed him.

hmm no, its the reason of me asking you but i didnt see you already did answer

[Joey_]

Koki whats your read on kiana?

[Chara]

you have dunker in a category with players i'm townreading, i'd like to know why you're confident there. how you're reading me would also be good to know, though i'm less interested in that.

pedit: i think Dunker was openly avoiding Creature's wagon. i actually don't know if scum would be so blatant about it.. there were other things i don't like but i can't remember right now.

[Kiana Kaslana]

I'd like to elaborate on my Joey read though, I found him interesting. His RP-ing early game was an interesting catch, I flagged it as anti-town and potentially scummy behavior; if he were to continue that for the entirety of the game, he would be lock scum for me. The fact that he stopped the RP-ing exactly at the time or area which i expected him to stop, and the fact that he did that entirely by initiative and of his own volition, gives him good townpoints for me. My early scumread on Joey was rescinded. I see no reason to scumread Joey from that point onwards.

Just sharing, though nobody asked.

[Kiana Kaslana]

you have dunker in a category with players i'm townreading, i'd like to know why you're confident there. how you're reading me would also be good to know, though i'm less interested in that.

pedit: i think Dunker was openly avoiding Creature's wagon. i actually don't know if scum would be so blatant about it.. there were other things i don't like but i can't remember right now.

Alright, that's true, maybe Dunker is the odd one out in that list, I recall some people were scumreading him earlier in the game, but I didn't agree with those scumreads. As far as possible most of his posts seem town to me on a tonal level, although, I am hoping this isn't another repeat of the ZZZX situation where I mis-townread someone based on hindsight-proven weak reasons.

I don't think avoiding Creature's wagon is scummy. Scum on Creature's team would have known that Creature's lynch was almost inevitable and be hard-pressed to bus. Also, someone who didn't know Creature's meta would find it difficult to differentiate Creature's alignment-indicative lurking from other lurking players like Joda and ActionDan.

[Joey_]

I have a meta game questino, why did you replace-in this game?