Sid Meier's Civilization 5 UPick Mafia (GAME OVER)

[brassherald]

Okay let's just put in the three bans each in whatever order

[Joey_]

Thats unfun, i already sent the order i stated
1. Ban gold
2. Embargo City States
3. Ban ivory

[Shaziro]

Anything that gives a boon to every civ is wildly in towns favor atm anyhow. Even one that gave 50/50 town scum books previously is still wildly favorable for town now.

[Joey_]

The boost could be different for town and scum, we don't know

[Shaziro]

See my previous post for my thoughts on how the World Congress is designed.

[brassherald]

FYI my picks are in

[Shaziro]

Wish you’d given it more time for discussion, but given that you’re conftown and Joey is a decent townread for me I’m not super concerned.

[Kokichi Oma]

Okay picks all in? Now we can move onto a lynch.

[Klazam]

VOTE: Ranmaru let's start here.

[Joey_]

@KO who would you like to flip beside gamma ?

[Maestro]

World Congress

Open Debate on Day 2 (Update 4.0)

Your resolutions for open debate on Day 2 are:

• [

  Ban Luxury

  ~ Gold]
  - Seen as the symbol of greed itself, Gold is immoral and its worth is best measured in the blood spilled to obtain it. Religious Gold especially must be eliminated or examined, as it is an affront to Gods and Kings to have effigies made from impure or ill-gotten materials. Assign delegates
  supporting or opposing a temporary Ban on Gold
  . This resolution
  may not
  be enacted consecutively.
  
  
  [

  Ban Luxury

  ~ Ivory]
  - The Ivory trade has existed for too long as an indication of the very worst ways in which humanity imposes on nature's great balancing act. Gentle giants such as the rhinoceros and the elephant have never been more threatened, and now is the time to take a stand. Assign delegates
  supporting or opposing a temporary Ban on Ivory
  . This resolution
  may not
  be enacted consecutively.

Remember, only the HEAL: and HURT: tags will be counted as valid delegate assignments for resolutions, for "support" and "oppose" respectively. Be sure to specify which resolution you are supporting or opposing when assigning delegates. Players will be notified in-thread if their delegate assignment is invalid for any reason.

---

Spoiler: Delegates Cast (0)

[0]

HEAL: SUPPORTING

[Ban Luxury ~ Gold]

[0]

HURT: OPPOSING

[Ban Luxury ~ Gold]

[0]

HEAL: SUPPORTING

[Ban Luxury ~ Ivory]

[0]

HURT: OPPOSING

[Ban Luxury ~ Ivory]

Spoiler: Delegates Not Cast (36)

Nero Cain (2), Kiana Kaslana (2),

brassherald

(

4

), BuJaber (2), Kokichi Koma (2), Chara (2), Gamma Emerald (2), Klazam (2), Titus (2), Shaziro (2), ActionDan (2), Joey_ (2), pidgey (2), Jodaxq (2), Almost50 (2), marshy (2), ranmaru (2)

NOTES

:

• [*]

  brassherald

  was elected Host
  [*]

  Joey_

  was the runner up
  [*]Deadline is in (expired on 2018-03-27 12:00:00)...
  [*]...on Tuesday, 27 March @ 12:00 PM EST

[Kokichi Oma]

@KO who would you like to flip beside gamma ?

Marshy I guess

[Joey_]

whut, what did you send brass

[Kokichi Oma]

Still a good turnout.

[Joey_]

HEAL: Ban Ivory
HEAL: Ban Gold

[Titus]

Dumb question, if we are testing religion why are we banning the one that mentions religion?

[Gamma Emerald]

HEAL: ban ivory
I saw Titus' post and yeah I think we need to think about that gold ban a bit

[marshy]

HEAL: ban ivory
HEAL: ban gold

[Gamma Emerald]

HEAL: ban ivory
HEAL: ban gold

There's no way you didn't notice Titus' post, what are you even thinking?

[Joey_]

Dumb question, if we are testing religion why are we banning the one that mentions religion?

tbh i picked it because it hinted at kills, seems more important than to test religion, unsure tho

[Nero Cain]

The first point is alright but I don't really see the problem with thinking it's 3of2

3 or 4 man teams seems like it would be more plausible. Suggesting that there are maybe 3 teams seems like an attempt to not hunt a bigger team. For example, we have 2 dead red, in his proposal, we'd be not hunting any other red scum and that doesn't make any sense to me. Or it being a slip is also a possibility. Also, wasn't Varsoon pushing that there are two teams of 3? Why does he ignore that?

[Nero Cain]

Religious Gold especially must be eliminated or examined, as it is an affront to Gods and Kings to have effigies made from impure or ill-gotten materials.

I mean, it sounds like a good reason to ban it all together, no?

Like, maybe Gold is what gives them their ability and banning it would 'cause their religion spread cease tonight so banning it would atleast tell us what it does, atleast if the former theory is correct.

[Joey_]

City States could be traitor ? I would fit the theme and flavor

[Joey_]

It*
Was thinking about 4 man teams too but seems too much, 2x3 with a traitor and a SK or something seems fine tho

[Nero Cain]

HEAL: ban ivory
HEAL: ban gold