Sid Meier's Civilization 5 UPick Mafia (GAME OVER)

[Chara]

Joey has a section for his reads and a section in the same post dor factual events.

[Joey_]

i dont know, i assumed. When i said i think theres 1religion spreader per team is just an assumption you know, i think a50 towntold a bunch and i townreads pidgey and marshy now, i wont lynch them based off an assumption

[Chara]

Almost is town and yeah, that. marshy i'm less sure about we'll sew where he goes.

[OnTheMark]

Also why do you even care to iso me if you dont open my reads lists lol, as if you could only judge my alignement from scum interactions and not my reads progression

1) Because you’re a spam poster to the point your reads and consistency isn’t how to read you. A spammy poster will always eventually be inconsistent. It’s about whether you are consistent during key events and then see if there is a connection between those two.

2) Mapping your reads progression and everyone else’s without posting real time is impossible. I do 90% of my heat mapping in my head. I can do it outside of that but that takes more time then I can do before EOD.

[Joey_]

Im not inconsistent at all and you have seriously no business telling me that if you havent bothered to read me so no offense but fk off

[OnTheMark]

Furthermore I work from FACTS then go backwards.

Fact scum had a religion spreader
So one of the other religion spreaders is almost certainly scum.

Pedit Chara there were three if memory serves who is the other? Shit *double checks*

[OnTheMark]

So Almost50 Pidgey and Marshy

Need to also focus on them tonight and see who could be scum with Varsoon.

[OnTheMark]

I noticed no one has answered my question.

What does religion actually do?

We have four religion spreaders (by claims) in the game.

So who is religious and what does it do?

[Joey_]

Dude you know that if theres actually a religion spreader orange in there, its still 1/3 and its an issue that will resolve itself naturally if we correctly lynch scum outside that pool ? its really not a big deal to lynch a scum rel spreader even, and in the case that we are incorrect we might end up lynching the whole pool when all of them flip town after the other. Lynching the in the religious pool is a non-issue atm

[Joey_]

I noticed no one has answered my question.

What does religion actually do?

We have four religion spreaders (by claims) in the game.

So who is religious and what does it do?

The religions spreader does not knows what it does, what we know tho is that :

- Someone can only be religious from 1 religion at the time
- If 2 religious spreader target the same ppl, the 1st sending his pm overrides the others.
- The resolution "Temporary Ban gold" roleblocked the religious spreading ability and they received a PM telling them it was blocked.

We assume that there's further resolutions down the line that might affect this, we don't know as of yet.

[Joey_]

Also OTM do you confirm or infirm Titus claim ?

[OnTheMark]

Dude you know that if theres actually a religion spreader orange in there, its still 1/3 and its an issue that will resolve itself naturally if we correctly lynch scum outside that pool ? its really not a big deal to lynch a scum rel spreader even, and in the case that we are incorrect we might end up lynching the whole pool when all of them flip town after the other. Lynching the in the religious pool is a non-issue atm

So a 33% chance odds of lynching scum
Or assuming 7 scum game 4 scum remain
14 alive take out three religion spreaders
4/11 which is 36% odds

...I could be convinced to leave it alone today. But tomorrow I think we look in the spreaders.

[OnTheMark]

Also OTM do you confirm or infirm Titus claim ?

I already said non conseq doc dude

[Joey_]

Dude you know that if theres actually a religion spreader orange in there, its still 1/3 and its an issue that will resolve itself naturally if we correctly lynch scum outside that pool ? its really not a big deal to lynch a scum rel spreader even, and in the case that we are incorrect we might end up lynching the whole pool when all of them flip town after the other. Lynching the in the religious pool is a non-issue atm

So a 33% chance odds of lynching scum
Or assuming 7 scum game 4 scum remain
14 alive take out three religion spreaders
4/11 which is 36% odds

...I could be convinced to leave it alone today. But tomorrow I think we look in the spreaders.

mafia is NOT a game about probabilities and that is only true assuming WE KNOW 1 scum in that pool and we don't

[Joey_]

Also OTM do you confirm or infirm Titus claim ?

I already said non conseq doc dude

cant blame me for half reading ppl can you

[OnTheMark]

For all the shit you give me about “reading” I find wholly inconsistent with how you don’t read mine. Spammy posters by their nature ARE inconsistent and going through every little word as if it is holy is not how to read them.

By contrast that IS how you read a lurker slot because they have time to prep their posts.

[Joey_]

Tbh i only read "i isoed titus' i didnt read the whole sentence <3

[OnTheMark]

Dude you know that if theres actually a religion spreader orange in there, its still 1/3 and its an issue that will resolve itself naturally if we correctly lynch scum outside that pool ? its really not a big deal to lynch a scum rel spreader even, and in the case that we are incorrect we might end up lynching the whole pool when all of them flip town after the other. Lynching the in the religious pool is a non-issue atm

So a 33% chance odds of lynching scum
Or assuming 7 scum game 4 scum remain
14 alive take out three religion spreaders
4/11 which is 36% odds

...I could be convinced to leave it alone today. But tomorrow I think we look in the spreaders.

mafia is NOT a game about probabilities and that is only true assuming WE KNOW 1 scum in that pool and we don't

Mafia is not a game solely about probabilities.

However as town we should be working from what is likely. Not from what is unlikely. Probabilities DO and SHOULD play a factor

For example if someone claims a night action
They are truth telling or lying

If unprovoked they are likely telling the truth about the action (alignment may be different)

Some cursory examination may be required if it is weird or silly but we natively already do this.

[OnTheMark]

I have to go again but always look at what is most likely.

If town or scum deviate from what is likely the first question should always be why? Why? Why?

[Joey_]

Then dont ever imply that you prefer to lynch in the non-rel spreader just because theres a 3% better odds to lynch scum

Also your post was really unwarranted

[OnTheMark]

Then dont ever imply that you prefer to lynch in the non-rel spreader just because theres a 3% better odds to lynch scum

Also your post was really unwarranted

Yeah. I actually do now I just fucked up the math earlier.

Apparently I still can’t do math lolz. Yay I can’t count.

I am afk starting now...

[Chara]

Mark, i'm very interested in how you're reading my by the end of your catchup, as well.
happy to see you in the game, also. <3

i don't agree with the certainty that one of the religion spreaders

has

to be scum by any means.

[Shaziro]

I'd be ok lynching OtM I think. The failure to fullclaim when it was specifically explained why -does- look super stally to me. I don't like the way he's catching up and ignoring advice/half reading things that are actually important...something seems off. We've got days, though, so I'm fine with holding my vote on Pine until he catches up. Come on Pine, I've -seen- your play be super good. Do me a proud.

[Almost50]

@Joey: Actually, OTM has just pointed out something... in your reads section you have me as possibly Orange but not either of Marshy/Pidgey. Why?

[OnTheMark]

I'd be ok lynching OtM I think. The failure to fullclaim when it was specifically explained why -does- look super stally to me. I don't like the way he's catching up and ignoring advice/half reading things that are actually important...something seems off. We've got days, though, so I'm fine with holding my vote on Pine until he catches up. Come on Pine, I've -seen- your play be super good. Do me a proud.

I did full claim. ?? Not following the point here.

Are my posts getting sucked up by mafiascum and put out in a foreign language?