Mini Normal 2010 - Scientific Mafia [GAME OVER]

[Srceenplay]

So I am fairly confident there's 1 spy

What is a spy?

[Srceenplay]

I dislike his personality

Ouch. What did I do?

[Srceenplay]

Good observation on Sho/Brawl/Screen.

Garuga and Bu,
Tell me about your feels. You both make a comment about the three of us. I see scum but obviously for different reasons than you.

[Srceenplay]

Good observation on Sho/Brawl/Screen. Do you think the jokes about a scum PT are a hint of some sort?

It might be. The whole thing just seems off, y'know?
Just seems like a weird progression of RVS.
Like it is clear that screen is going for some shock value with his opener. Is it a townie just making a joke for laughs, or a reaction test of some sort or is it scum doing something rediculous so that we all think "must be townie; scum wouldn't expose themselves like that".

So without additional info about screen we can only say it's NAI. Sho townreading him for it is also NAI because town can be wrong. Just because she's townreading something NAI doesn't automatically make her scum. Byron then scumreads her for 'buddying'. Sho responds back with a countercase on Byron. It just all seems forced and escalating too quickly for it to be a genuine TvTvT convo. Hence my suspicion that it is TvTvS. It might be TvSvS but scum tend to think twice about joining their buddy in the spotlight so I think the average scum instinct would be to take a step back. So 1 scum seems more likely than 2.

Bu already answered.
But it’s off.

He asked about sho brawl and Srceen. You talked about Byron, not brawl.

[Srceenplay]

You defended Screen, said his creepy vote made sense to you, and then you followed Screen's vote. How isn't that cozying up to Screen? I get the sense that you're projecting your own motivations onto me.

Are you implying that whenever someone votes or agrees the same as someone else they are buddying?

[Garuga]

Good observation on Sho/Brawl/Screen.

Garuga and Bu,
Tell me about your feels. You both make a comment about the three of us. I see scum but obviously for different reasons than you.

From what I've pieced together, BuJaber seems to think you three are a role with a PT. Brawl is townlean, Screenplay is meh, Shoshin is kinda meh too but has some suss points like 59 so if you're looking for scum in that trio I'd start with her.

[Srceenplay]

Getting really active when accused is a scumtell that actually works, right Screen?


Getting really active when accused is a scumtell that actually works, right Screen?

I’ve seen people push it.

Bah

[Srceenplay]

Good observation on Sho/Brawl/Screen.

Garuga and Bu,
Tell me about your feels. You both make a comment about the three of us. I see scum but obviously for different reasons than you.

From what I've pieced together, BuJaber seems to think you three are a role with a PT. Brawl is townlean, Screenplay is meh, Shoshin is kinda meh too but has some suss points like 59 so if you're looking for scum in that trio I'd start with her.

You said it’s a good observation. Why do you think it. Don’t answer from their perspective.

[Garuga]

Brawl and you seem to have a lot more interest in scumhunting within that trio than the other players.

[Garuga]

After all, you seem to be ignoring pretty much everything that's been going on in the thread that doesn't pertain to them aside from Byron's readlist and buddying TiaM.

[BuJaber]

That's not exactly accurate anyway

I have mixed up brawl and byron a few times.

But basically the original trio of shoshin/brawl/screen had an escalating discussion spurred on by what was obviously a joke by screen. The fact that it was a joke does not necessarily mean that screen isn't telling the truth with his soft scum claim but in my mind if all 3 were townies we would have not had that conversation in the first place. It was being spurred on by one of them hiding as scum trying to imitate how a TvTvT would go. It doesn't feel genuine.

Since byron have put himself in the conversation it has made some reads clearer. I have since leaned town for both brawl and byron. And between sho and screen sho seems scummier by posts.

I'd hate to give scum a pass for making a scum claim joke but screen does realy look like town so far.

[Srceenplay]

This is what they originally said.

I think the screenplay's joke vote is NAI, the reaction to it is NAI, and shoshin getting involved with it is NAI. That said, the 3 things together feel forced and odds are a chain of posts like that in RVS contains 1 spy at least. So I am fairly confident there's 1 spy among {shoshin, brawl, screenplay}. So FOS on you 3 while I try to sort you.

You say good observation.

Good observation on Sho/Brawl/Screen.

So what is it that you think is a good observation?

[BuJaber]

What I'm trying to tell you garuga is that I never focused on the PT aspect of it. It's only relevant if screen and brawl are both scum which is highly unlikely.

[Garuga]

This is what they originally said.

I think the screenplay's joke vote is NAI, the reaction to it is NAI, and shoshin getting involved with it is NAI.

That said, the 3 things together feel forced and odds are a chain of posts like that in RVS contains 1 spy at least. So I am fairly confident there's 1 spy among {shoshin, brawl, screenplay}.

So FOS on you 3 while I try to sort you.

You say good observation.

Good observation on Sho/Brawl/Screen.

So what is it that you think is a good observation?

Bolded.

[Srceenplay]

What I'm trying to tell you garuga is that I never focused on the PT aspect of it. It's only relevant if screen and brawl are both scum which is highly unlikely.

But why would he assume that then?

Don’t lead him. Let’s hear his thoughts to help us understand where he is coming from.

[Srceenplay]

Bolded.

Why?




Also wtf is a spy?

[BuJaber]

Oh btw screen spy is just scum. Sorry playing mish mash games and the word for evil faction gets overlapped in my posts.

Pedit - everytime he responds he keeps bringing up the PT so I feel he's not totally understanding my pov. I'm not trying to lead him just explaining myself better.

[Garuga]

Bolded.

Why?




Also wtf is a spy?

I just agree with him what else is there to explain

[Srceenplay]

Bolded.

Why?




Also wtf is a spy?

I just agree with him what else is there to explain

He just said he doesn’t think you are understanding the his point but you keep saying you agree with his point.

[Garuga]

Bolded.

Why?




Also wtf is a spy?

I just agree with him what else is there to explain

He just said he doesn’t think you are understanding the his point but you keep saying you agree with his point.

If he meant something else when he said Sho was a spy, that's where our views diverge. I think that there's 1 scum in that trio, and I think they all have a PT role.

[Srceenplay]

Who are you voting?

[Garuga]

Who are you voting?

VOTE: Srceenplay

[BuJaber]

Then we are agreeing on the first part and disagreeing on the other.
1+ scum in trio. The other 2 would be town. No reason to think they would have PT also

[Srceenplay]

so if you're looking for scum in that trio I'd start with her.

So if you where to look for scum in us it would be Shoshin.

This is what they originally said.

I think the screenplay's joke vote is NAI, the reaction to it is NAI, and shoshin getting involved with it is NAI.

That said, the 3 things together feel forced and odds are a chain of posts like that in RVS contains 1 spy at least. So I am fairly confident there's 1 spy among {shoshin, brawl, screenplay}.

So FOS on you 3 while I try to sort you.

You say good observation.

Good observation on Sho/Brawl/Screen.

So what is it that you think is a good observation?

Bolded.

You agree with how that there is scum in us three.


Now you vote me after all else you just said?

[Srceenplay]

Then we are agreeing on the first part and disagreeing on the other.
1+ scum in trio. The other 2 would be town. No reason to think they would have PT also

The thing is. We are in a pt together.