Mini 2006: Scummer in this game UPick GAME OVER

[Eddie Cane]

I am not wrong about Math, Mastina, Nico, probably Lovebird. There is no universe those 3 are scum ever.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

I don't know how I feel about Math, but I agree about not lynching any of those today.

What is left?

[Eddie Cane]

us, pine, nahdia, otm, not mafia I think

[Eddie Cane]

Mathdinkle claims a 100% confidence townread on redflavour. He can correct me, but if that stands not mafia isnt a valid lynch. I am not overly inclined to do you or nahdia, so Pine and OTM are what's left and you dont want either.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

us, pine, nahdia, otm, not mafia I think

See, like, something is wrong here.

OTM is town, Pine is town...

Is it really just Nahdia and N_M? I mean, RedFlavour was a solid solid scum read for me and people are just ignoring it because Math screams loud about some kind of meta clear that I honestly don't trust.

And Beeboy faking the mason thing has very high scum equity.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

Here's my thing.

When you PoE down to 3 players and all 3 of those players are town, somewhere in your "confirmed townies" something has gone fucking horribly wrong.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

I've seen a lot of "I have secret reasons to think X is town" today, so I'm half tempted to say "fuck it day 2 massclaim" and try and sort eveyrthing publically.

Because these PoE lists are getting degenerate levels of bad and are likely to lose us the game.

[OnTheMark]

VOTE: Momomen

Could be convinced here too.

Something in your confirmed townies is very horribly wrong. You don’t say?

[Eddie Cane]

I've seen a lot of "I have secret reasons to think X is town" today, so I'm half tempted to say "fuck it day 2 massclaim" and try and sort eveyrthing publically.

Because these PoE lists are getting degenerate levels of bad and are likely to lose us the game.

in what possible way is my list bad

yesterday I had to spend 50 pages arguing why 2 obv town mason claims were town

duck I'm getting angry thinking about it I'm done posting in this one for a while

[Eddie Cane]

oh after this

VOTE: OTM

[Pine]

{Nahdia, Momo/Eddie}

Increasingly confident this is the scumteam.

[Mathdino]

Mathdinkle claims a 100% confidence townread on redflavour. He can correct me, but if that stands not mafia isnt a valid lynch. I am not overly inclined to do you or nahdia, so Pine and OTM are what's left and you dont want either.

95%

Not_Mafia literally playing his scumgame is problematic but redflavor is otherwise 100% town

[Nahdia]

Well someone's getting falsely towncased here, because I'm not scum. ATM I'm thinking one in {Pine, Math} and one in {LLD, MOMO, Not_Mafia}.

[Pine]

Yeah no, it's you. You and MOMO. Edge case for LLD.

[mastina]

Momo

To be honest I frankly think that quite realistically it's probably MOMOMEN as the third scum with the second scum most likely being in LLD/Mathdino, probably Mathdino.

VOTE: Mathdino.

Why?

Honestly.

Just general feelings, I don't really have much in the way of specifics.

[mastina]

I hate to be that person but can you restate your question please with saying which wagons specifically?

...The wagon I was fucking quoting in that very same spot?

[Not_Mafia]

VOTE: MOMO

[Pine]

Well someone's getting falsely towncased here, because I'm not scum. ATM I'm thinking one in {Pine, Math} and one in {LLD, MOMO, Not_Mafia}.

Also this is a super flexible position for scum. "It's two people in all the ones you suspect and also these other four." You're basically painting half the living playerlist at that point.

[Pine]

N_M

I think you are Town for reasons you are (likely) also aware of. I think it was a scum-motivated night action.

Talk to me please.

[Nahdia]

Oh.

VOTE: Pine

[Lovebird]

Yeah no, it's you. You and MOMO. Edge case for LLD.

Why?

[Lovebird]

N_M

I think you are Town for reasons you are (likely) also aware of. I think it was a scum-motivated night action.

Talk to me please.

It wasn't

[Lovebird]

Idk what people see scum math or momo

[mastina]

unless they thought they could manipulate me into tunneling you and Nico into tunneling me.

Yeah, abooooooooooooooout thaaaaaaaaaaaat......

If scum had confirmed you as masons already, why push the mason cop?

Because they couldn't win the game with the mason cop and the masons all treated as town--there's a damn good reason that the mason cop was nightkilled; Momrangal, if treated as town and conftowning the masons, would give too large a townbloc for the scum to overcome. (Because a non-Momrangal, non-mason nightkill removes a player from suspicion, and throw in gamesolving POE and it becomes fairly easy to just POE the scum.)

As-is, a dead Kokichi makes the game significantly easier to POE.

Mastina, you have one shot to convince me why you're TRing Nahdia, because I don't see it.

One. Check my reasoning on Kokichi spewing the masons which at the time included beeboy/Nahdia as town. (

Particularly because Kokichi Oma was suspicious of beeboy/Nahdia of the two by virtue of consistently naming me as a townread.

I can cite evidence of this if you need me to show my homework.)

Two. Iso me to check my reasoning on beeboy. Control-f search said iso, which is here for reference, beeboy conveniently highlighted. That gives you the reasoning beyond Nahdia.

Three. Gut on Nahdia's posting.

Four, the retraction no matter what anyone else says--not the act of retracting, but the way the retraction was done. That I feel strongly was indicative of town, not scum. Nahdia can state all they like they'd do it as either alignment; I don't care. The way it was done was town, and Nahdia's process was even moreso.

So.

[Lovebird]

VOTE: pine