SUPP 2017 MAFIA: COMPLETE

[the worst]

gotchu fam<3

[Taly]

kfam <3

Also, if I were scum, half of my posts in this game wouldn't exist LOL

I don't give people leverage to scumread me as scum.

[the worst]

I mean there's a reason why I went from paranoia lock-5ing you to townreading you (also Chara helped a lot w that)

[Taly]

Sacred Townybloc

Chara
the worst
Taly

I want to hear more rankings and that

Pine

-vig explanation from

Pun

before I extend this.

[Vaxkiller]

I still want lists from people

[TehBrawlGuy]

BTW the fucking kills went AS PREDICTED

Whats going to happen tonight is this: Everyone is going to submit thier numbers and more than likely l

urkers/low content people/anyone who is being shaded in the thread

are going to die, because this is more of a consensus, instead of pushing people to vote a specific way.

no shit, dude, when you leave it as vague as that it encompasses pretty much everything

I still want lists from people

Yeah, and I want you to explain why I was apparently your top scumread before your buddies can come online to tell you how to.

[Taly]

OK maybe

TBG

truly is town

[Taly]

OK maybe I was onto something when I gave

Vax

a 0

[the worst]

no shit, dude, when you leave it as vague as that it encompasses pretty much everything

this sentence speaks into my soul (this is exactly what I thought as I facepalmed)

[TehBrawlGuy]

no shit, dude, when you leave it as vague as that it encompasses pretty much everything

this sentence speaks into my soul (this is exactly what I thought as I facepalmed)

what makes it really hurt me, is that I considered coming in here after the two town ranking deaths, and going all told ya so and stuff. i considered that it wasn't an impressive enough prediction, and that if I come in here and swing my dick around too much it'll lose impact for the really egregious stuff

so i was like, alright, I'll play nice and not talk about predictions

and then that got posted and I just couldn't

[Nahdia]

TBG fwiw i dont know EP's personal feelings on it but using stuff like google sheets that you cant embed into the forum tends to get you in trouble, since you can alter it irrevocably after posting it and during times you shouldnt be able to post.

PenguinPower - 8
Taly - 5
MariaR - 3

Nahdia why PP so high and Taly/Maria so low?

pretty sure i made my PenguinPower read clear yesterday.
Taly I just had mixed feelings on since i didnt see anything super towny despite a huge mass of posts but i still wanted them around because people who post a reasonable amount help the game, town or scum.
Maria I'm just fucking incapable of reading and she was low by process of elimination because i'm mostly just townhunting here because my scumreading abilities are absolute fucking shit, as she can attest to from our last game together.

Taly's posts today have been solid though and we seem pretty much on the same page on stuff for the moment.

[TehBrawlGuy]

ah shit I suppose that's true. EP, if you have any issues with it let me know and I'll remedy as I can. Of course, you can feel free to purge the link or whatever if you feel that's best.
here's a shitty unformatted plaintext ver. to keep me honest

Spoiler: plaintext rankings

Player# Player Name Ranking Reasoning Order ranking assigned
1 1 - TehBrawlGuy 10 - 1
2 2 - Taly 1 Doesn't need the points and I want to make sure my lowest point values go to people not on the lynch block 9
3 3 - Punreader 10 I buy his claim and I want him to be superpowered 4
4 4 - MariaR 8 Gaming the vote system to prevent lynch 7
5 5 - DeasVail 5 See Notes 15
6 6 - Espeonage 0 obvscum 3
7 7 - Dunnstral 9 He needs to be > espe 5
8 8 - Nahdia 6 Filler Town read 14
9 9 - the worst 2 Doesn't need the points and I want to make sure my lowest point values go to people not on the lynch block 10
10 10 - Pine 10 Gaming the vote system to prevent lynch 6
11 11 - Shoshin 7 Filler, but a combination of Sho seeming different than her scumplay in our last game, and thinking she's decent skill-wise 12
12 12 - Fire Assassin 4 See Notes 15
13 13 - Lovebird 5 See Notes 15
14 14 - Chara 6 Filler Town read 13
15 15 - Srceenplay 3 Doesn't need the points and I want to make sure my lowest point values go to people not on the lynch block 11
16 16 - Vaxkiller 4 See Notes 15
17 17 - PenguinPower 0 obvscum 2
18 18 - NicoRobin 0 hard lurking, not sure if Scum but would rather PL via rankings than actual lynch 8

Notes
There's a hard drop off in how much I care about the rankings between #8 and #9, and again between #11 and #12

DV, Fire, Lovebird and Vax were pretty much looked at as a unit. Lovebird just subbed in, so she gets a pass - Fire and Vax both ping me a little, Vax is pretty useless atm, and my read on DV settled to nulltown so it made sense to rank this way -

[PenguinPower]

Spoiler: Rankings

1. TehBrawlGuy - 9
2. Taly - 0
3. Punreader - 0
4. MariaR - 10
5. DeasVail - 8
6. Espeonage - 7
7. Dunnstral - 10
8. Nahdia - 3
9. the worst - 6
10. Pine - 2
11. Shoshin - 4
12. Fire Assassin - 4
13. Lovebird - 5
14. Chara - 0
15. Srceenplay - 5
16. Vaxkiller - 6
17. PenguinPower - 10
18. NicoRobin - 1

[Vaxkiller]

@brawl I made it well known I wanted you dead yesterday, I feel like you are pushing in all the wrong places, like wanting to lynch the easy lurkers. You are going after the low hanging fruit.

[TehBrawlGuy]

You made it well known you wanted me dead, yes, but it was pretty early on and your only stated reasoning was the whole wang thing (which has provided me far more entertainment than I originally thought it would). I was wondering if you ever actually scumread me on something substantial.

I've got no idea where you think I wanted to lynch lurkers from, though. I wanted espe/PP dead pretty much the whole day, neither of whom was lurking, and defended Pine, who was very obviously lurking.

[Vaxkiller]

I'm also not opposed to giving lurkers low-scores,

Guess this was Taly and not you.

[Vaxkiller]

Maybe im wrong about you. I want to think on that.

[Shoshin]

Here's my rankings:

10 - myself
10 - Taly
10 - Chara
9 - the worst
8 - TBG
7 - Screen
6 - DV
6 - Dunn
5 - Pun
5 - Vax
4 - Nico
4 - Nahdia
3 - Espeonage
2 - Fire
1 - Pine
0 - Lovebird
0 - Penguin
0 - MariaR

[Taly]

Vax

, have you read any of my posts?

Also, I kind of want to see why I give scum-vibes to you magically after I gave my rankings.

[Taly]

Egh. Not doing this whole tunnel thing, but still. And I'm gonna try to drop the "bitchy" tone a bit this dayphase.

@brawl I made it well known I wanted you dead yesterday, I feel like you are pushing in all the wrong places, like wanting to lynch the easy lurkers. You are going after the low hanging fruit.

I'm also not opposed to giving lurkers low-scores,

Guess this was Taly and not you.

But writing D1-me off as wanting to lynch easy lurkers is an unapologetically wrong statement at best.

[Taly]

I'm still wrapping my head around why PP was ranked high

I don't get the townreads on PP, and I'm getting pretty annoyed that nobody's said a thing to me about this.

edited for coherency
quoted for relevancy

[Errantparabola]

Srceenplay has requested replacement. Finding one now.

[Errantparabola]

Votecount 2.1

Espeonage

(2): DeasVail, Fire Assassin

Vaxkiller

(1): the worst

Not Voting

(12): TehBrawlGuy, Taly, Punreader, MariaR/Chara, Espeonage, Dunnstral, Nahdia, Shoshin, Srceenplay, Vaxkiller, PenguinPower

With 15 alive, it takes 8 to achieve a majority.
Deadline in (expired on 2018-07-04 23:06:00)

[Vaxkiller]

Vax

, have you read any of my posts?

Also, I kind of want to see why I give scum-vibes to you magically after I gave my rankings.

You think it happened magically after you gave reads? Where is this?

[Taly]

I mean, it's not like you've really given reads that much in this game.

You never really pushed a scumread other than

TBG

Plus, you're actually active in the game now, that's more than what I can say D1. You also posted your rankings after me, and out of other people's rankings at the moment, I'm interested in the reasoning behind yours. Mostly your

PP/Pun/Pine

rankings.

Are you going to respond to 944?

Also,

Pun

has claimed vig for about 200-300 posts.