NY214: Project Pinecone (Game over! Town wins!)

[brassherald]

And before I'm asked, exactly 1 of those is simply because I'm paranoid, the others are actually pretty legit reads from me.

The paranoid is HWS, who seems to end game me constantly as scum. So, I refuse to ever really town read him.

[Gustavo]

So you admit I’ve contributed something. Why did you lie about me and say I haven’t contributed?

I’m not tunneling either. Please stop lying about me.

This reads as needlessly defensive.

Actually it was justified defensive.

[HitAlt]

Actually we lynch dramonic today.
And since brass seems to confirm my read there..good detective work guys, let's wrap it up!

[davesaz]

Happy scumday Flubbernugget!
Did you mean not flailing?

HitAlt seems townier than what I'm used to. So does HeWhoSwims.

[HitAlt]

I mean there's some pretty comfortable theories about who you are.

Where?
Who has the case-file?

[HeWhoSwims]

who seems to end game me constantly as scum.

Are you drunk?

The only time I played scum with you was in your first game and then you caught me in lylo! And one time where you replaced out after 2 days idk if you count that

[davesaz]

Enough time has passed that I can't be sure if it's a true memory, but I think I've incorrectly scumread Dramonic before for posting like this.

[brassherald]

who seems to end game me constantly as scum.

Are you drunk?

The only time I played scum with you was in your first game and then you caught me in lylo! And one time where you replaced out after 2 days idk if you count that

I count it. That's 2 for 2 by my count. TWO FOR TWO.

But, let's be honest, I just needed to put a fourth person in there, yours was semi-random, there's a pool of people who are pretty much null and I chose from that pool.

[HeWhoSwims]

I feel honoured I guess.

[brassherald]

You should be, as we all know, I am always serious about everything and nothing I ever say is a joke.

[Inferno390]

AbN is Assumption Before Narrative. Basically it means that Gustavo was calling Profii’s play scummy and then coming up with reasons for it to actually be scummy.

Do it, brass.

Have you played mafia before?

Well this is incredibly evasive. I agree with Chickadee on 186. This is pretty flaily scum.
I’m just gonna shoot you so I can go on to hunt your buddies.

Dayvig: Gustavo

[brassherald]

Wait, you haven't asked me if I was serious, so, pretend I didn't say that last bit, so that if someone asks me if I'm serious, I can use that later. I forget where I'm going mid sentence sometimes.

[Gustavo]

AbN is Assumption Before Narrative. Basically it means that Gustavo was calling Profii’s play scummy and then coming up with reasons for it to actually be scummy.

Do it, brass.

Have you played mafia before?

Well this is incredibly evasive. I agree with Chickadee on 186. This is pretty flaily scum.
I’m just gonna shoot you so I can go on to hunt your buddies.

Dayvig: Gustavo

How is that envasive? You accused me of something that almost every player does. Scum reading somebody and explaining why is like the foundation of mafia.

[brassherald]

AbN is Assumption Before Narrative. Basically it means that Gustavo was calling Profii’s play scummy and then coming up with reasons for it to actually be scummy.

Do it, brass.

Have you played mafia before?

Well this is incredibly evasive. I agree with Chickadee on 186. This is pretty flaily scum.
I’m just gonna shoot you so I can go on to hunt your buddies.

Dayvig: Gustavo

Is this finally a not Bad Idea Mafia game I'm in where a dayvig is a real thing?

I'm so hype to find out!!!!!

[Gustavo]

I hope it is real. I can’t play with incompetent people.

[Ausuka]

I'm glad dayvigs are explicitly banned from normal games so that we can put the boring and utterly unhelpful gambit to rest.

[Inferno390]

AbN is Assumption Before Narrative. Basically it means that Gustavo was calling Profii’s play scummy and then coming up with reasons for it to actually be scummy.

Do it, brass.

Have you played mafia before?

Well this is incredibly evasive. I agree with Chickadee on 186. This is pretty flaily scum.
I’m just gonna shoot you so I can go on to hunt your buddies.

Dayvig: Gustavo

How is that envasive? You accused me of something that almost every player does. Scum reading somebody and explaining why is like the foundation of mafia.

You’re missing the point.
In mafia, what you do is form a case and then judge someone based on that case. In AbN, you assume someone’s alignment and then build a case around the assumption.

Ex.
“Player X has been doing this, so he’s scum.”
Vs
“Player X is scum!”
*Player X does something*
“See? What Player X sis is scummy! Die scum!”

Your progression is firmly of the latter.

[Gustavo]

You’re missing the point.
In mafia, what you do is form a case and then judge someone based on that case. In AbN, you assume someone’s alignment and then build a case around the assumption.

Ex.
“Player X has been doing this, so he’s scum.”
Vs
“Player X is scum!”
*Player X does something*
“See? What Player X sis is scummy! Die scum!”

Your progression is firmly of the latter.

Except that’s not what I did at all. Yet another lie from you.

[brassherald]

I'm glad dayvigs are explicitly banned from normal games so that we can put the boring and utterly unhelpful gambit to rest.

You make me sad, Ausuka. I was like

But now, I'm like

The Marvel Netflix series are pretty good, by the way. Except Iron Fist, I watched like 5 episodes of that then gave up.

[Inferno390]

I’m done
VOTE: Gustavo

There’s not even any defense coming from him. He’s just calling me a liar and being evasive.

[dramonic]

Actually we lynch dramonic today.
And since brass seems to confirm my read there..good detective work guys, let's wrap it up!

thanks but no thanks.

[Gustavo]

I’m done
VOTE: Gustavo

There’s not even any defense coming from him. He’s just calling me a liar and being evasive.

I’m not being invasive and I’ve called you a liar cause as I’ve shown you have lied multiple times.

I don’t have to defend myself from lies.

[dramonic]

I’m done
VOTE: Gustavo

There’s not even any defense coming from him. He’s just calling me a liar and being evasive.

hm

[Gustavo]

I also don’t think you know what evasive means.

[Inferno390]

I’m done
VOTE: Gustavo

There’s not even any defense coming from him. He’s just calling me a liar and being evasive.

I’m not being invasive and I’ve called you a liar cause as I’ve shown you have lied multiple times.

I don’t have to defend myself from lies.

Where exactly have you shown anything? And asking me if I’ve ever played Mafia before in response to me explaining my point is being evasive: You’re avoiding engaging with me because you don’t like what I’m saying.
Stop being toxic and calling names, SCUM. We don’t want any of that here.