NY214: Project Pinecone (Game over! Town wins!)

[HitAlt]

So sorry for everyone who genuinely scumread me for how I've played.
All I can say is that this hasn't been anything like my usual playstyle.

[the worst]

I'm yet to experience a situation where confidence has let me down. let's sheep Andrius.

BTW you seem very considered and careful this game chickadee

I'm really ok with sheeping Andrius



And I'm not sure what you mean with that comment.

just a general comment, you're coming across as very reflective this game (more so than usual) :>

[HitAlt]

Yea, Chick has been surfing this whole game.

[profii]

So sorry for everyone who genuinely scumread me for how I've played.
All I can say is that this hasn't been anything like my usual playstyle.

you're either not who I think you are, or it's not that different :p

I wasn't lynching HitAlt anyway, but I still won't today.

Let's go flubber let's go

[the worst]

Yea, Chick has been surfing this whole game.

[brassherald]

Yea, Chick has been surfing this whole game.

Myloninja's not in this game.

[HitAlt]

you're either not who I think you are, or it's not that different :p

You don't know Jack.

[the worst]

myloninja is also terrible at surfing

[profii]

you're either not who I think you are, or it's not that different :p

You don't know Jack.

sure?

[brassherald]

Is role madness normal?

[the worst]

normal CAN be role madness and this was advertised as like.. ~mechanically interesting~ and basically lite role madness

[the worst]

iirc normal only needs at least 1 vt lel

[HeWhoSwims]

So what claims do we even believe

[the worst]

believe all claims

lynch scummy players regardless of claims or town loses

[brassherald]

Yeah, if this is role madness, I've got to withdraw my statement from several games about not lynching an un-CCed PR claim day 1, it's unrealistic.

[brassherald]

VOTE: dramonic

[the worst]

what's your take on andrius' hard town metaread on dram?

[Taly]

For comprehension, all the people that feel strongly on their lynch, can they make a short assessment or not-too-lengthy case of their thoughts?

I can't work with the whole

"vote here and yay it's going to flip scum"

reply....

-_-*... Especially in light with people telling me my votes and pushes so far have sucked without much reasoning beyond

"

Taly

is overreacting!"

but w/e.

There's at least 4-5 different wagons right now and that is very unhelpful given the lack of time we have.

***

I strongly feel that there's a huge lack of scum motivation in

Hit

once you read him in depth - he has literally nothing to benefit as scum from most of any of his posts this dayphase.

Short Answer:

I'm probably not voting here at all.

***

I don't like that

Flubb

only posts when he's being suspected and that warrants MY revote because he's the least present person with a wagon that several people are tip-toeing saying they'd jump on but aren't doing jackshit atm.

Short Answer:

I'll likely revote this.

***

I'm not lynching a

Dram

who made protective claim in a Normal on D1 - like seriously, wtf guys? Unless someone has this elaborate scum theory that revolves around

Dram's

fakeclaim, or discusses how his play deserves a lynch regardless, I don't think lynching a potential Town PR is optimal at all for D1.

Short Answer:

Very unlikely that I'll vote here.

Also

Chickadee

is getting by with nothing, and while I don't think

HeWhoSwims

and

Brass

are scum at the moment, their posts are essentially

"I'll lynch to lynch if I don't have a strong argument leading me to something when we have to lynch!"

But what are they doing right now?

I can understand why anyone would want to lynch for info but even if that was 2nd priority to scum;

NO WE'RE NOT DOING THAT. NOT IN THIS GAMESTATE.

I'm going to look into

xyzzy

tonight, or early tomorrow morning in depth.

[the worst]

***I don't like that Flubb only posts when he's being suspected and that warrants MY revote because he's the least present person with a wagon that several people are tip-toeing saying they'd jump on but aren't doing jackshit atm.
Short Answer: I'll likely revote this.

*fist bump*

[Taly]

oh wait

Brass

voted

Dram

...

[the worst]

taly my man we're gonna have PRs coming outta our ass this game
if i eat the NK please don't be chicken shit about lynching claimed PRs going forward

i'm valuing andrius' hard meta read a lot more than a roleclaim there

[Taly]

***I don't like that Flubb only posts when he's being suspected and that warrants MY revote because he's the least present person with a wagon that several people are tip-toeing saying they'd jump on but aren't doing jackshit atm.
Short Answer: I'll likely revote this.

*fist bump*

Actually...

I just stated a very valid reason for the

Flub

lynch, given my scumread on him never really dissipated.

VOTE: Flubbernugget

This may change when I look at

xyzzy

, but I'm fine with my vote here for EoD1.

P-Edit

taly my man we're gonna have PRs coming outta our ass this game
if i eat the NK please don't be chicken shit about lynching claimed PRs going forward

i'm valuing andrius' hard meta read a lot more than a roleclaim there

What's keeping you from changing your vote or unvoting then? If I read correctly,

Andrius

townreads

Dram

?

I'm not afraid to lynch PRs...

If it's any dayphase that's

NOT

D1.

In my experience, town more often flourishes when they take claims at face value, at least until they can be disproved, scumtainted or countered later in the game.

Also, nobody should ever look for a CC in good conscience, at least this early in the game.

[Inferno390]

@Hit:
Would you please fullclaim and link crumbs. Because that soft claim reads a whole lot like scum.

[Taly]

But, I have towned scum-PRs...

I'm not good at weeding what's a good fakeclaim or what a scum-PR claim would be in most situations, and how that changes with the circumstances.

I just don't want to lynch

Dram

and be like

"FUCK he could've been useful for town"

when I had the gut instinct/principle to

NOT

lynch him.

And then if he IS a Town-PR that whole argument becomes WIFOM against me and other townies on his hypothetical wagon.

The risk outweighs the benefit, depending on the game narrative.

[Taly]

Oh well fuck, just saw

Hit

claimed too...